What the most important stats for a certain player - Discussion thread

M

matt75matt75

Member
Joined
Nov 16, 2010
Messages
160
Reaction score
0
Points
0
EDITED BY TBH

I have changed the name of the Topic, making it a discussion thread instead.



First question out was....well the old OP ;D



for exmaple you have a good

dc 1 mrk 15 tck 12 pos 12 str 12 jmp 12 hdg 12 with one star
dc 2 mrk 11 tck 9 pos 11 str 12 jmp 13 hdg 10 with 3 stars

which one would you choose someone can help me to choose my first eleven ?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I think coaches are considering age, avg. points and lots of other stuff that don't affect much -if any- to the following match performance to give stars for current ability. So i don't think it's wise to care about them much. Stars for potentials are more important than that but even those are not so reliable.
 
Coaches/scouts wouldn't normally give example #1 one star (unless all his other stats are absolute poo) as they take the most important stats for each position into consideration. Usually the one with the most stars (although not always, depends which role you play them in) is the best of the two.
 
matt75matt75 said:
for exmaple you have a good

dc 1 mrk 15 tck 12 pos 12 str 12 jmp 12 hdg 12 with one star
dc 2 mrk 11 tck 9 pos 11 str 12 jmp 13 hdg 10 with 3 stars

which one would you choose someone can help me to choose my first eleven ?
Click to expand...

Personally, I would go with the following stats ( in order)

Determination + Work Rate - His mental stats, if he is useless here, he wont bother anyway
Positioning + Anticipation -Making sure he is in a good position that he knows where the ball is going to end up
Marking - The ability to mark a player in movement
Decision - To make the right call, when to close down etc
First Touch - To be able to handle the ball in a tight spot
Jumping, heading, Strength- His physic

I supsect that the player with 3 stars is much better when looking at my stats, correct ?
 
I have changed the name of the topic, making it a discussion thread for all positions at all levels

Good eh ? :D
 
TheBetterHalf said:
Personally, I would go with the following stats ( in order)

Determination + Work Rate - His mental stats, if he is useless here, he wont bother anyway
Positioning + Anticipation -Making sure he is in a good position that he knows where the ball is going to end up
Marking - The ability to mark a player in movement
Decision - To make the right call, when to close down etc
First Touch - To be able to handle the ball in a tight spot
Jumping, heading, Strength- His physic

I supsect that the player with 3 stars is much better when looking at my stats, correct ?
Click to expand...

yes mate you are right so the *** report is better - can i ask you soemthing more about team talks do you know something easy because i seem to struggle with them pls

---------- Post added at 02:20 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:19 AM ----------

good better half i like your topic
 
Most positions have 10 main attributes which you can look at. Unless the player is a box to box or complete striker(20 attributes). I just do a spreadsheet and get the attributes to a %.
 
I use FM Genie Scout and I think sometimes the rating isn't that accurate, maybe we can do a new Stat Weights for it.

Here's an example of DC

View attachment 170396
 
Last edited:
It's not about me making it, it's already made in FM Scout, I just dont think it's accurate.
 
If you wanna know who is better in that certain position:
On tactics click on player instructions i think and basic and the attributes highlited at the bottom are the important ones and then decide how u wanna play. So lets say its a right back and u have ivanovic and Bosingwa despends if you want full back defesive or wing back
 
Still having 2 atributes highlighted doesnt mean they have the same weight.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top