Which Defender Should I Sign?

[hidude454]

I have a choice right now between 3 defenders; I'll give the brief rundown of the current stats:

Niklas Sule (Hoffenheim): 40m initial, 0% profit from next sale
Jonathan Tah (Leverkusen): 40m initial + possible 6m additional, 20% profit from next sale
Jesus Vallejo (Real Madrid): 45m initial + 0% profit from next sale

Which of these sounds like the best deal, or which defender has consistently performed well for you guys?

 

[Animus]

Years ?

And have you some screens of the 3 defenders ?

 

[hidude454]

Years ?

And have you some screens of the 3 defenders ?

Oh, sorry about that.
Here are some screenshots: http://imgur.com/a/JKuCz

 

[djs1]

have a schalke save in which i signed sule season 2 for 10 million and he was very solid.lots of room for improvement too

 

[Animus]

no constest with the choice !

The best is Vallejo !

 

[Cryus]

Witch club are you? Vallejo is the best, but the to germans are very good.

 

[Agenteusa]

Vallejo is the best at the beginning but Tah can become better. Sule is also very solid but isn't an all around DC as he isn't very fast nor does have lots of agility. If you want strong DC's also look Srdjan Babic which can reach 20 in STR.

 

[loveunitedhatecity]

i'd go for tah out of them 3 but 1 i would recommend is goldaniga plays for palmero quality young defender with bags of potential to improve potentially cheaper as well if u negotiate a price