Your over rated world 11

[Ride The Walrus]

GK:Cassilas
RB:Ramos
CB:Upson
CB:Vermalen
LB:Clichy
RM:Walcott
CM:Busquets
CM:Barry
LM:Robinho
ST:Benzema
ST:Bojan

Casillas and Ramos?! I don't agree with that. As much as i love Reina (H), Casillas is the best in the world IMO easily.

 

[MrLuketastic]

Robert Green
Jose Bosingwa
Darjio Srna (he's good on FM but...)
Christoph Metzelder
Kyragkios (or what it's spelt - Greek guy for Liverpool)
Maxi Rodriguez (one goal in WC 06 - otherwise...)
Juan Manuel Mata
Michael Carrick
Wesley Sneijder
Carlton Cole
Mario Gomez

Just my thoughts

 

[markodragojevic]

He is always **** against Barca.

 

[Ben]

Pretty decent team there, although Vidic and David Silva aren't overrated IMO.

But them players are very over-rated.

Reason I put Vidic is because whenever he plays against a world-class striker he gets slaughtered he is too slow and often just fouls when up against quick players. And I just simply don't rate Silva, whenever I watch Valencia he is a bit average tbh.

---------- Post added at 08:27 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:25 PM ----------

Robert Green
Jose Bosingwa
Darjio Srna (he's good on FM but...)
Christoph Metzelder
Kyragkios (or what it's spelt - Greek guy for Liverpool)
Maxi Rodriguez (one goal in WC 06 - otherwise...)
Juan Manuel Mata
Michael Carrick
Wesley Sneijder
Carlton Cole
Mario Gomez

Just my thoughts

Kyrgiakos :O He has been our best defender this season, much better than Skrtel and we payed £1 Million for him. Carrick is not overrated either IMO,I also disagree on Maxi of what I have seen of him other than them a good team

 

[Ride The Walrus]

Robert Green
Jose Bosingwa
Darjio Srna (he's good on FM but...)
Christoph Metzelder
Kyragkios (or what it's spelt - Greek guy for Liverpool)
Maxi Rodriguez (one goal in WC 06 - otherwise...)
Juan Manuel Mata
Michael Carrick
Wesley Sneijder
Carlton Cole
Mario Gomez

Just my thoughts

Krygy?! :O:'( He's been awesome D:
Is there an under-rated team thread coming?

 

[Andrew37]

Kyrgy shouldn't even be on this list because he isn't even rated!!!

Casilas is over rated. He makes too many blunders and his positioning is one of the worst I have seen from the top keepers.

 

[eddlad]

How is Bale overated hes amazing oO)

Read the earlier posts on the thread, I have explained already but if you want it spoon fed, here you go;

I included Bale at LB as he is gash there, but has been played there quite a lot at Spurs and they paid quite a decent sum for him, hence him being overrated and included on my list.
Admittedly he has played well recently but that is in a more advanced position. Does that explain it well enough?

How about producing your own list before you go picking up on others selections?

 

[Ride The Walrus]

Kyrgy shouldn't even be on this list because he isn't even rated!!!

Casilas is over rated. He makes too many blunders and his positioning is one of the worst I have seen from the top keepers.

Oh he's rated by Liverpool fans :wubH)

 

[Deleted member 79730]

I like Kyrgiakos, i think hes a very good player

 

[ecfc2810]

Why vidic, evra and nani they were all 3 relatively unheard of players and yet have proved to be some of the best signings in recent years

how an you say that Liverpool have no overrated players when most of their team is overatted

 

[Ben]

Kyrgi is a proper old fashioned defender. Since his mistake against Lyon to knock us out of the Champions League he has been our most consistent performer, a really good defender, if only he was ten years younger...

 

[Deleted member 79730]

Why vidic, evra and nani they were all 3 relatively unheard of players and yet have proved to be some of the best signings in recent years

how an you say that Liverpool have no overrated players when most of their team is overatted

you would say that as a utd fan

 

[Frank]

Mannone

Ramos;Alex;Pique;Bosingwa

Wright-Phillips;Diaby;Busquets;Modric

Defoe;Eduardo​

 

[Ben]

Why vidic, evra and nani they were all 3 relatively unheard of players and yet have proved to be some of the best signings in recent years

how an you say that Liverpool have no overrated players when most of their team is overatted

I have tried to be unbiased as possible in this thread, opting for Cech over Van Der Sar and David Silva over Nani tbh. No-one has said Liverpool have no overrated players, I reckon Babel and Benayoun are often overrated. As much as I think Benayoun is a great player he can often be too weak and lose the ball easily. Babel is a decent player also but a lot of people reckon he is going to be a great player, he hasn't got enough about him IMO.

 

[FuzzyDunlop]

wow people are really hype about over-rated players lol. I think stevie G and Carrick are over rated dont like carrick much

 

[Ben]

I'm a Liverpool fan and I think Carrick is a very good player :S

 

[Ride The Walrus]

Why vidic, evra and nani they were all 3 relatively unheard of players and yet have proved to be some of the best signings in recent years

how an you say that Liverpool have no overrated players when most of their team is overatted

Firstly,as said above you're a UTD fan,so...
Liverpool have been slated all year, so really none of their players are over-rated...

 

[Alex]

Van Der Sar

Ramos
R. Ferdinand
Meltzelder
Bosingwa

Diaby
Anderson
Gago

Robinho
Ibrahimovic
Eto'o

 

[Ride The Walrus]

Wow, i cannot believe Mascherano has been called over-rated D: Don't watch much Liverpool i guess

 

[Andrew37]

Kyrgi is a proper old fashioned defender. Since his mistake against Lyon to knock us out of the Champions League he has been our most consistent performer, a really good defender, if only he was ten years younger...

If he was 10 years younger, I don't think he will be stupid enough to go to Liverpool.