Your Overrated Premiership XI

[thpfc]

GK: Foster

RB: Hutton
LB: Shorey
CB: Turner
CB: Lescott

RM: Walcott
LM: Downing
CM: Anderson
CM: Lampard

ST: Ashton
ST: Bendtner

 

[Adzter018]

GK: Van der sar
rb: hutton
cb:lescott
cb:carragher
lb: cole
rm: lennon
lm:downing
cm:anderson
cm:ballack
st:drogba
st:bendtner

 

[HarryinHD]

GK: Fabianski

RB: Bardsley
LB: Shorey
CB: Dunne
CB: Alex

RM: Kalou
LM: Nani
CM: Bowyer
CM: Mascherano

ST: Pavlyuvchenko (spelling?)
ST: Beattie

 

[njengamn]

reina

lescott
bridge
terry
carragher

carrick
bentley
downing
hargreaves

robinho
bellamy

 

[19-11-08]

Van Der Sar
Eboue Gallas C.Davies A.Cole
Valencia Lucas Anderson Diouf
Elmander Zamora

You *******.

Bent Cole
Babel Richardson Palacios Eboue
Carragher A.Ferdinand Terry Ramos
Reina

i really stuggled to think of 11. i don't even think some of these players are overated

 

[Billy]

Palacios!?

"You *******."

 

[19-11-08]

sorry. i think he's good. but i saw at least one person put him in their prem best 11 and that is taking it too far.

 

[ohmygawdzz]

sorry. i think he's good. but i saw at least one person put him in their prem best 11 and that is taking it too far.

How is Reina overrated..finally because hes started to get some praise after 4 years of being completely solid does not make him overrated, hes fantastic

 

[Jeffers]

GK: Foster

RB: Carragher
LB: A.Cole
CB: Toure
CB: Lescott

RM: Bentley
LM: Downing
CM: Lucas
CM: Hargreaves

ST: Bellamy
ST: Robinho
<!-- / message --> <!-- sig -->

 

[NeedHelpOnFm09]

Cech

Aurelio Terry Lescott Richards


Babel Ballack Anderson Joe Cole


Robinho Keane

 

[19-11-08]

The point of this thread is to post, in your opinion, the most overrated players you can think of, in a starting XI list.

I'll start off, with:

Goalkeeper: Foster

Right-Back: Neill
Centre-Back: Lescott
Centre-Back: Carragher
Left-Back: Aurelio

Right-Mid: Lennon
Centre-Mid: Bentley
Centre-Mid: Hargreaves
Left-Mid: Downing

Striker: Heskey
Striker: Agbonlahor

Don't bash people's opinions in this thread please, just post your own.

You *******.

Bent Cole
Babel Richardson Palacios Eboue
Carragher A.Ferdinand Terry Ramos
Reina

i really stuggled to think of 11. i don't even think some of these players are overated

How is Reina overrated..finally because hes started to get some praise after 4 years of being completely solid does not make him overrated, hes fantastic

:''( stop bashing my opinion:'(

i was struggling for a keeper who is over rated and just put him down

 

[morton fc]

i definetly wouldnt say reina is overrated or even underated but for a liverpool keeper you would expect abit more

 

[twilson7]

GK: Foster
DL: Aurelio
DR: Zabaleta
DC: Carvalho
DC: Anton Ferdinand
ML: Downing, without question
MR: Walcott
MC: Obi Mikel
MC: Nigel De Jong (maybe thats just over valued, but £18 million for him??)
ST: Agbonlahor
ST: Berbatov

 

[Jamie F]

GK: Anyone from the "Big 4"
RB: Luke Young
CB: Anton Ferdinand
CB: Ledley King
LB: Leighton Baines
CM: Anderson (sorry 19-11-08 but he hasn't really done anything notable)
CM: Jimmy Bullard
LM: Joe Cole(I know he usually plays up the middle or the right but he has played on the left)
ST: Darren Bent
ST: Roman Pavlyuchenko

 

[Tom_7]

GK: Cech
RB: G. Neville
CB: Rio Ferdinand
CB: Bassong
LB: A.Cole
RM: Wright-Phillips
CM: Mascherano
CM: Huddlestone
LM: Downing
ST: Agbonlahor
ST: Berbatov

 

[FulhamFan101]

Van Der Sar
Eboue Gallas C.Davies A.Cole
Valencia Lucas Anderson Diouf
Elmander Zamora

Who rates Zamora? I think he is pretty much the worst striker in the league!
Also, i'm not sure about Andy Johnson being over rated either. Might just be me.
I'm come up with my own list shorty, just to contribute

 

[Billy]

GK: Anyone from the "Big 4"
RB: Luke Young
CB: Anton Ferdinand
CB: Ledley King
LB: Leighton Baines
CM: Anderson (sorry 19-11-08 but he hasn't really done anything notable)
CM: Jimmy Bullard
LM: Joe Cole(I know he usually plays up the middle or the right but he has played on the left)
ST: Darren Bent
ST: Roman Pavlyuchenko

Ledley King? Come on.

The man doesn't even train, yet he outperforms almost every other centre-back in the country.

Pfft.

 

[PaddyK94]

seriously guys. if anything downing is under-rated

 

[Kris]

what happened to no bashing

 

[Kris]

seriously guys. if anything downing is under-rated

lol take your boro goggles off.