Rate My Kit Thread - *Please Read Rules Before Posting*

[jmoser]

wow/10, seriously all gorgeous. also, whats the template?

Cheers Mal. Nice to see a lot of the old KoTW regulars like yourself posting kits again.


The template has no name, it's just something I made a while back. One of my favorites from my little collection I have. PM me if you want a download link

 

[levigu]

^Arsenal H/A: 10/10, looks perfect.
Chelsea: 8.5/10, club badge looks like it's peeling off or something

Harchester United
H/A/3/Euro

My first kits, please rate.

 

[Sparxx]

Very nice kits!

Home: Great colours, purple looks really good when used correctly, and you've done it very well. The white trim looks nice as well - I generally dont like trims and pipings, but the two white stripes on the left looks nice. 8/10.

Away: Same goes for orange as with purple - when used well, it looks nice (I can NEVER pull off a good kit with orange). The weaving white and purple side trims look very nice. 7/10.

Alternate: Very nice. The grey diagonal pipes add a feature to the kits, and thats good to see. Alternate kits allow you experiment a bit more. Not sure if the portioning between purple and white is good - maybe bringing the purple a bit more into the torso would even it up a bit. 8/10.

4th: Looks good. Simple, nice, effective. Not sure if black is the right colour for the sponsor logo. Maybe add a white stroke. 6/10


DYNAMO SPARTA FC (fantasy team)
Home/Away/Alternate/Fourth
View attachment 218296View attachment 218297View attachment 218298View attachment 218299

 

[Malarkey]

Cheers Mal. Nice to see a lot of the old KoTW regulars like yourself posting kits again.


The template has no name, it's just something I made a while back. One of my favorites from my little collection I have. PM me if you want a download link

I havent really had the time but Im back now, and Ill be doing KoTW soon enough. I will PM you, thank you very much

EDIT: great kits Sparxx! they all look really good, the 2nd one is my favourite and the 3rd is my least favourite, but I still like them all.
8.5/10 9.10 8/10 8.5/10

 

[Malarkey]

not sure if I have posted these before but oh well...
shakhtar fantasy kits:

 

[Canesdude]

Those kits are seriously amazing. When I get around to downloading a Kitpack I'm definitely gonna use those as Shakhtar's kits.

Seychelles FF and Marshall Islands (they're the only sovereign nation to not have a national football team, thanks Wikipedia)
View attachment 219148View attachment 219149

 

[Superwolf]

Loving the Marshall Islands kit there, like the detail around the swoosh. Great idea for Seychelles too! Here are my first kits: York City!

View attachment 219728View attachment 219729View attachment 219730View attachment 219731

 

[StuW]

Loving the Marshall Islands kit there, like the detail around the swoosh. Great idea for Seychelles too! Here are my first kits: York City!

View attachment 219728View attachment 219729View attachment 219730View attachment 219731

Good first kits.

1st - Good, colours need work
2nd - Sponsor and collar look out of place because of colour
3rd - Decent, although only one sleeve has a cuff
4th - Nice, but the hummel logo should be white, and the sonsor looks too big/out of place.



Some Newcastle kits for my career -

 

[StuW]

Niger ACN Home -

Botswana ACN Home -

 

[Kevnaylor]

Newcastle - 10 for all. cant fault them
Niger - 10 really like the design
Botswana - 9 i like what you were doing with the design but just something about it makes it a 9

I need an opinion on 2 textures for my 3d template

Old/new

 

[Steve*]

I need an opinion on 2 textures for my 3d template

Old/new

I prefer the old. 9/10. Very good.
New 8/10...the texture is just a bit too much.

Ignored KBChan's one as he didnt rate the kits above.

My KotW entries(Thanks to jmoser for the base template)

View attachment 220648View attachment 220649

 

[StuW]

Newcastle - 10 for all. cant fault them
Niger - 10 really like the design
Botswana - 9 i like what you were doing with the design but just something about it makes it a 9

I need an opinion on 2 textures for my 3d template

Old/new

v1 for me, much cleaner look a little too much on v2. Still not 100% convinced on the template if I am totally honest, KUTGW though

Also, the Niger and Botswana kits are their current ACN kits, if you knew how long it took me to get that to look right....

 

[StuW]

I prefer the old. 9/10. Very good.


My KotW entries(Thanks to jmoser for the base template)

View attachment 220648View attachment 220649

I like the home, 9/10, but not sure about the away TBH, maybe if that had been white, I would have preferred it...7/10

Scotland's current kit -

Namibia ACN Kit -

Guinea CAN kit -

Morocco ACN kit -

Zambia ACN kit -

Libya ACN Kit-

 

[Iaq]

What should I say? I don't see any mistakes. Top quality! 10/10

 

[Kevnaylor]

great kit laq 10/10

A new 3D template

 

[Mike]

Where do you get all these templates from? 10/10, can't fault either of them.

 

[Steve*]

great kit laq 10/10

A new 3D template

9/10 from me, the club badge still looks a little off for me. But other than that great kits and template

View attachment 221743View attachment 221744

Fowler inspired LFC kits

 

[Epsxe95]

i really like the home kit, not too sure about the away for my liking. 8/10

well, back after some time off making kits

Flamengo H/A/A v2

 

[StuW]

i really like the home kit, not too sure about the away for my liking. 8/10

well, back after some time off making kits

Flamengo H/A/A v2

All nice, but I just can't imagine Flamengo playing in anything other than Red and Black stripes. 7/10 all

 

[Mike]

i really like the home kit, not too sure about the away for my liking. 8/10

well, back after some time off making kits

Flamengo H/A/A v2

Don't think Nescafé is a good sponsor, and I agree with Stu. Like the third kit out of the lot. 5/10, 6/10, 7/10.

Incorporating a design made by myself onto new kits (original with FB kits, re-made it on R'11 and then again on Kev's Alpha template) Still need to improve my perspective ability (logos etc.)

​