September
Pinder's third month at the club started brilliantlly. He managed to score twice against Oxford in a 3-0 win and managed to get a perfect 10.0 for his rating. He played well again in the matches against Chester and Hincley before scoring once more, when he scored the equaliser in a 1-1 draw with Gloucester. The next game saw the youngster break two records in the 2nd Qualifying round of the FA Cup. He scored first in a 3-1 win over Eastwood which saw him become the youngest goalscorer and youngest player to play in the competition at 14 years 171 days. The month ended with a 1-1 draw with Histon, with Pinder having no impact.
October
This was the worst period in the young englishman's career, with him getting multiple poor ratings and some reaching as low as 5.6. During this time the striker rejected a contract with Halifax stating salary to be the main stumbling block. At the end of the month, there was some consolation. Despite being dropped, he came on to score a penalty which inspired Halifax to a 2-0 win and returning to playing to the high standards he set earlier in the season.
November
Pinder continued his refound form as he scored in the very next game, a 2-1 win v Guisley. He again impressed in the FA Trophy as he set up both goals in a 2-0 win against Chorley. He also became the youngest player to play in the FA Trophy. He then followed this up with two solid performances against Droylsden and Boreham Wood in the FA Trophy.
December
He then continued his form in the replay against Boreham Wood, putting in a Player of the Match performance and getting an assist to put his team through in the cup. The goals continued to flow as he got another against Solihull Moors. This was then followed by a drop in form for three games consecutively followed by another rejected contract. However, he recovered to score 4 in the last 3 games of the month, including a hatrick against Corby.