Can Barcelona Tactics really be emulated in FM11?

Valdes
Abidal Pique Puyol Alves
Busquets
Xavi Iniesta
Messi Pedro
Villa​

get abidal and alves to support the flanks as messi and pedro in most cases will not track back set busquets as a ball winner, set xavi to give support to busquets when the oppent are going forward and make iniesta a playmaker that rarely tracks back and finnaly set the CB's as automatic also as a instruction put pass into space and also use drill crosses for villa
 
Admitedly I haven't read every post in this thread but i just wondered if anyone had tried deploying busquets as part of a 3 man defence in an attempt to replicate the tactics used against Athletico Madrid a couple of weeks ago. I was thinking a formation something like:

Valdez

-------- Puyol --- Busquets --- Pique --------
Alves ------------------------------------ Maxwell
-------------- Iniesta ------- Xavi ----------------
Messi ----------------------------------- Pedro
---------------------- Bojan -----------------------

With Busquets set as a Ball Playing Defender with his mentality changed to make him more attacking than both Puyol and Pique, and roam from position on so that he drifts out from the defensive line with the ball. Pique/Puyol should also have thier wing play set to 'move into channels' to try and replicate that aspect.

Gonna try and test this later on btw.

---------- Post added at 07:28 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:40 PM ----------



This didn't work too well tbh, I just played the Spanish Super Cup against Athletic and overall won 6-5 but they 2nd leg(home) i lost 4-2.

I used the first leg to test all kinds of things, I didnt go for more than like 5 mins without changing something significant and eventually got it down to something I though worked preety well.
I had to deal with injurys to Messi and Iniesta so Henry and Toure came in. The basic changes were;
- the two wingers came more central, playing behind Bojan.
- Pique and Puyol moved outwards to Full-Back, thier mentallity was set very defensive and generally they behaved well
-Maxwell/Dani Alves moved up beside Xavi/Toure and were set to defensive wingers.

Analysis;
--The shape at the back with Pique and Puyol wide with Busquets dropping in was achieved and worked quite well when I had possesion however it left me quite susceptible to long balls.
-Most of the long bals played however were either cut out by Busquets or cleaned up by Valdez/Pique/Puyol which I was pleasently suprised with.
-However all 4 of thier goals came from balls over the top which Llorente got to first.
-The 4 goals they did score were the only oppurtunities they had which weren't speculative long range efforts though.
-The front 3 were preety innefective going forward but defended well
-Dani Alves/Maxwell were too willing to get down the line and cross the ball, which wasn't likely to come off considering who was playing upfront.

I am going to try and fix this a little bit, If I can get my players to look long less and for Alves/Maxwell to look to pass inside more then I think this may be able to work against lesser teams. I don't think it will work against teams who play 2 strikers or who have very quick wingers though :(.


great analysis mate, as mentioned it is nearly impossible for us to replicate Barcelona due to the limitations of the match engine, we can go close but we will never be able to replicate it fully, thx for for your work mate, certainly it has given many people an in-depth insight
 
What i would really like to see is that when a player swaps position he can adopt a different Role and Duty...for eg. when Messi swaps position with Pedro he becomes an Adv Playmaker instead of being an Inside Forward
I thought that is what happens?? I have Luis Suarez playing as inside foward at AML and Kadlec playing as poacher at ST. If they swap the game makes it impossible for Kadlec to play as poacher at AML.
 
I thought that is what happens?? I have Luis Suarez playing as inside foward at AML and Kadlec playing as poacher at ST. If they swap the game makes it impossible for Kadlec to play as poacher at AML.


You mean something else entirely. like for example when Villa and Messi swap positions and there original roles at AMR and ST respectively is Advanced Playmaker and Advanced Forward then when Messi swaps to become ST and Villa swaps to become AMR then Villa instead of being an Adv Playmaker could be an Inside Forward while Messi instead of being an Advanced Forward could be a DLF
 
Top