fair enough.. my bad... Anyway as I statted this in not the issue here..
As I said I need advice to incorporate his ability as we know it now that we have seen him play in PL...
I will start with my suggestions just to discuss him.. I might overrate him because I really enjoy watching him play, or even underrate him because of my fear to not overrate him...
As a sidenote I will reffer to FM mobile values a lot since Mike statted that SI 3 more months to scout him and judging from his progress from this time I usually raise 1 point. Also I rate him compared to other players of AFC beause I never miss a game of this team and thus I know their players better. This is what I believe in comparison with the others:
1) He is the second best (if not the best) player in AFC now in dealing with his marker (I have to give Gervinho the first spot, he played more games. Although I believe the directness, ability to change direction/speed and dribbling is the quality that unlocked AFC offence)
2) He showed he has the second best first touch in AFC now (first of cource RVP).
3) He seemed the second most dangerous player of AFC outside the box (Personally I think he is just unlucky but Arteta has more Long shots in so he must be our No1)
4) He seemed the 2nd quicker AFC player in both pace and bursts of speed (walcott must take this)
So here we go:
Corners 7
Crossing 13 (original value, can get 1p higher but..)
Dribbling 15 (mobile got him on 14, I would also If it wasnt to much to change his agility to 17-18)
Finishing 12 (1 less than mobile in a effort to not overrate him)
First Touch 15 (sublime first touch in most occasions.. look for examples against ManU before his assist and the slight streched touch at his first goal yesterday could be higher)
Free Kick 7
Heading 7
Long Shots 12(I honestly believe that this sould go drastically up especially if you see his first goal with AFC the shot panteleimon saved vs city and his long shot training while u20s and many more, but...)
Long Throws 5
Marking 4
Passing 12 (mobile value, I wont go astray about his passing, he seems like he is better in hard passes than beeing just consistent in short ones thus the high creativity)
Penalty 8
Tackling 7 (some good tackles)
Technique 15
Aggression 11 (he seems bossy)
Anticipation 13 (along with creativity, decisions and flair represents vision and what we call football brain)
Bravery 11
Composure 13 (decently cold blooded in any oportunity he had to score. Check him vs olympiakos and vs Blackburn)
Concentration 10 (at his first apps he seemed a bit distracted defencively sometimes)
Creativity 14 (He got the vision!)
Decisions 13 (same as above, mobile value)
Determination 14 (He broke into the first team rather quick, didnt he?)
Flair 16 (I heard it represents the unpredictability factor so he must have it high, right? Also I heard that it is not a att that changes easily)
Influence 3
Off The Ball 14 (mobile value, some great runs he does)
Positioning 8 (mobile value, although to be fair, along with consentration wasnt displayed in his first apps.. maybe a 7 can suffice)
Teamwork 12 (not at all selfish but I can go with 11 that it is the mobile value)
Work Rate 14 (I might overrate him here because he wanted to break in the first 11 but he seems like a workhorse)
Acceleration 18 (blistering pace and change of speed... I cant go lower than 17)
Agility 15 (If I was to create his stats from scratch I would make that his best stat along with pace. This kids directness and ability to change speed and direction is his signature asset.. If I didnt feel a 6-7 point raise is too much I will suggested 17-18 and a dribbling drop to 14)
Balance 15 (To emulate him without raising his streangth much he must have a really good balance, look what he did to zabaleta!)
Jumping 8
N.Fitness 15
Pace 18 (again his pace is blistering.. if someone want to lower his speed then touch Acc, pace imo must go to 18)
Stamina 13
Strength 12 (again look how he wont let defenders to cut his pace while throwing the ball forward.. )
Also about PPMs I guess we sould at least consider giving him shoots from distance and knocks ball past opponent.
too high, can assure the Arsenal researcher will not go that high. Remember he has only played 9 games, and he is still learning
My thoughts in bold
Corners 7
Crossing 13 (original value, can get 1p higher but..)
14
Dribbling 15 (mobile got him on 14, I would also If it wasnt to much to change his agility to 17-18)
still 14
Finishing 12 (1 less than mobile in a effort to not overrate him)
12
First Touch 15 (sublime first touch in most occasions.. look for examples against ManU before his assist and the slight streched touch at his first goal yesterday could be higher)
too high, 13 at best
Free Kick 7
Heading 7
Long Shots 12(I honestly believe that this sould go drastically up especially if you see his first goal with AFC the shot panteleimon saved vs city and his long shot training while u20s and many more, but...)
again too high 10
Long Throws 5
Marking 4
Passing 12 (mobile value, I wont go astray about his passing, he seems like he is better in hard passes than beeing just consistent in short ones thus the high creativity)
he is a good passer 12
Penalty 8
Tackling 7 (some good tackles)
Technique 15,
tough one but probably 14
Aggression 11 (he seems bossy)
Anticipation 13 (along with creativity, decisions and flair represents vision and what we call football brain)
12
Bravery 11
Composure 13 (decently cold blooded in any oportunity he had to score. Check him vs olympiakos and vs Blackburn)
12
Concentration 10 (at his first apps he seemed a bit distracted defencively sometimes) agreed
Creativity 14 (He got the vision!)
12
Decisions 13 (same as above, mobile value)
13
Determination 14 (He broke into the first team rather quick, didnt he?)
also agreed
Flair 16 (I heard it represents the unpredictability factor so he must have it high, right? Also I heard that it is not a att that changes easily) too high
14
Influence 3
Off The Ball 14 (mobile value, some great runs he does)
agreed
Positioning 8 (mobile value, although to be fair, along with consentration wasnt displayed in his first apps.. maybe a 7 can suffice)
Teamwork 12 (not at all selfish but I can go with 11 that it is the mobile value)
11
Work Rate 14 (I might overrate him here because he wanted to break in the first 11 but he seems like a workhorse)
Acceleration 18 (blistering pace and change of speed... I cant go lower than 17)
17
Agility 15 (If I was to create his stats from scratch I would make that his best stat along with pace. This kids directness and ability to change speed and direction is his signature asset.. If I didnt feel a 6-7 point raise is too much I will suggested 17-18 and a dribbling drop to 14) again this too high,
13-14
Balance 15 (To emulate him without raising his streangth much he must have a really good balance, look what he did to zabaleta!)
also too high, 13
Jumping 8
N.Fitness 15
12
Pace 18 (again his pace is blistering.. if someone want to lower his speed then touch Acc, pace imo must go to 18)
16
Stamina 13
Strength 12 (again look how he wont let defenders to cut his pace while throwing the ball forward.. )
11
Also about PPMs I guess we sould at least consider giving him shoots from distance and knocks ball past opponent.
Runs with ball often,
Knocks ball pass opponent
Remember he isnt the finished article, so dont rate him so high. give him room to develop
i would give him 168 PA
) I got them to change his stats via FMARTE to make him more relistic...