Fm14 Deal or No Deal thread: Please use when asking if you should buy player x or y

  • Thread starter Thread starter Raikan007
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 717
  • Views Views 357K
Player: Alex Sandro
Team you are managing: Man city
Team who are selling: Porto
Offer: ?42.5m
Year: 2015

Need a world class Lb i couldn't get any bids accepted so i activated his release clause (i've tried alaba and alba too)

I know Man.City have a pile of money, but I can't justify spending this amount of money on a LB. I would try maybe looking deeper into the market, and spend a max of 20-25m!

Although, that's just my view on it.
 
Player: Alex Sandro
Team you are managing: Man city
Team who are selling: Porto
Offer: ?42.5m
Year: 2015

Need a world class Lb i couldn't get any bids accepted so i activated his release clause (i've tried alaba and alba too)

Well, Luke Shaw grows to be excellent. But probably another cheaper option is Alex Sandro.
 
Player: Tom Ince
Team you're managing: Southampton
Team who is buying: Manchester United
Year: 2017
Offer: 50 Million $

I have Nicusor Stanciu and Januzaj on the left, and Chamberlain and Sinclair on the right, so don't really need him. Still, league rival. Deal?

View attachment 436280
 
I know Man.City have a pile of money, but I can't justify spending this amount of money on a LB. I would try maybe looking deeper into the market, and spend a max of 20-25m!

Although, that's just my view on it.

I agree with you couldn't make myself spend that much just on a left back, went with a much cheaper option
 
Player: Olivier Giroud
Team you are managing: Arsenal
Team who are buying: Chelsea
Offer: 19m pound + 10 after 10 goals
Year: 2015
[FONT=Tahoma, Calibri, Verdana, Geneva, sans-serif]summer window [/FONT]
 
Player: Ryan Preene (regen)
Team you are managing: Arsenal
Team who are selling: Cardiff
Offer: ?15m upfront with ?15m over 48 months
Year: 2018/19

Managed Cardiff for 3 years prior to moving to Arsenal, this lad was a stand out performer. 5* PA, plus only 20 and already a good Premier League RB/LB. Shaw is at City, Digne at champions Newcastle, both would cost upwards of ?50m. Welsh, so HG too. Money no real object, Arsenal got a takeover last season.

View attachment 436271

(SS from before Arsenal contract)
 
Player: Tom Ince
Team you're managing: Southampton
Team who is buying: Manchester United
Year: 2017
Offer: 50 Million $

I have Nicusor Stanciu and Januzaj on the left, and Chamberlain and Sinclair on the right, so don't really need him. Still, league rival. Deal?

View attachment 462297
what currency are you using? i wouldnt sell for less than 65m in the currency you're using, especially to a rival.
Player: Olivier Giroud
Team you are managing: Arsenal
Team who are buying: Chelsea
Offer: 19m pound + 10 after 10 goals
Year: 2015
summer window
deal and replace him with mitrovic / viktor fischer / lacina traore / vitinho / leandro damiao
Player: Ryan Preene (regen)
Team you are managing: Arsenal
Team who are selling: Cardiff
Offer: ?15m upfront with ?15m over 48 months
Year: 2018/19

Managed Cardiff for 3 years prior to moving to Arsenal, this lad was a stand out performer. 5* PA, plus only 20 and already a good Premier League RB/LB. Shaw is at City, Digne at champions Newcastle, both would cost upwards of ?50m. Welsh, so HG too. Money no real object, Arsenal got a takeover last season.

View attachment 462313

(SS from before Arsenal contract)
i'm sure he'll improve even further in the coming years if developed well. no deal.
 
what currency are you using? i wouldnt sell for less than 65m in the currency you're using, especially to a rival.
It's USD. =P I find it more comfortable to use USD in comparision to Pounds. They again bid with 60 Million, which I accepted. I have good replacements, and United seem to have horrible AI, so I'm guessing it'll work out. They just bought another winger too..

i'm sure he'll improve even further in the coming years if developed well. no deal.
[/quote]
Actually, he was asking if he should buy, not sell =P
 
It's USD. =P I find it more comfortable to use USD in comparision to Pounds. They again bid with 60 Million, which I accepted. I have good replacements, and United seem to have horrible AI, so I'm guessing it'll work out. They just bought another winger too..
Actually, he was asking if he should buy, not sell =P
well, it was close to 1am in the morning here since i posted that so guess i must have been too sleepy lol. anyway, i'd suggest negotiating the price lower to about 20m if possible, though personally i wont mind paying 30m if money isnt an issue. :)
 
Player: Julian draxler
Team managing: Manchester United
selling: schalke
season: start of 2nd
price: ?38.5m transfer 42.5(incl agent)
had a big clear out and in need of a good aml inside forward to share the (both) wings with januzaj zaha and Shaqiri hefty wage for age at 90k


player: quintero
managing: Manchester united
selling: fc porto
season: start of 2nd
price: ?28 mil including agents etc
sold kagawa and need someone to play at Amc as either advanced playmaker or trenquista and help with some goals

overall I have 110m but need to sign a winger/if (draxler) and probably 2 Amc's and possibly another deep midfielder but these are the only deals on the radar ATM
 
Player: Julian draxler
Team managing: Manchester United
selling: schalke
season: start of 2nd
price: ?38.5m transfer 42.5(incl agent)
had a big clear out and in need of a good aml inside forward to share the (both) wings with januzaj zaha and Shaqiri hefty wage for age at 90k


player: quintero
managing: Manchester united
selling: fc porto
season: start of 2nd
price: ?28 mil including agents etc
sold kagawa and need someone to play at Amc as either advanced playmaker or trenquista and help with some goals

overall I have 110m but need to sign a winger/if (draxler) and probably 2 Amc's and possibly another deep midfielder but these are the only deals on the radar ATM

For AMC try to see how much you can get Halilovic for from Dinamo. Even after 2 years of rotting at Madrid he's still a 5* rating in an Arsenal team containing Wilshere, Aguero, Pastore and Ozil on my save.

As for Draxler? He's going to be worth that much easy, but it's a lot for a young player.
 
Player: Julian draxler
Team managing: Manchester United
selling: schalke
season: start of 2nd
price: ?38.5m transfer 42.5(incl agent)
had a big clear out and in need of a good aml inside forward to share the (both) wings with januzaj zaha and Shaqiri hefty wage for age at 90k


player: quintero
managing: Manchester united
selling: fc porto
season: start of 2nd
price: ?28 mil including agents etc
sold kagawa and need someone to play at Amc as either advanced playmaker or trenquista and help with some goals

overall I have 110m but need to sign a winger/if (draxler) and probably 2 Amc's and possibly another deep midfielder but these are the only deals on the radar ATM

Deal for Draxler, along with El Shaarawy, he' one of the best AML ingame, and he doesn't get injured as much as Shaarawy does.

As for Quintero, he definitely grows to be beastly ingame, no doubt. Check and see Nicusor Stanciu, if he's developed well. He turns out excellent! Try looking at Will Hughes and James Ward-Prowse too. Ward-Prowse is an excellent DLP, and Will Hughes is brilliant at both CM/ACM.
 
Player: Julian draxler
Team managing: Manchester United
selling: schalke
season: start of 2nd
price: ?38.5m transfer 42.5(incl agent)
had a big clear out and in need of a good aml inside forward to share the (both) wings with januzaj zaha and Shaqiri hefty wage for age at 90k


player: quintero
managing: Manchester united
selling: fc porto
season: start of 2nd
price: ?28 mil including agents etc
sold kagawa and need someone to play at Amc as either advanced playmaker or trenquista and help with some goals

overall I have 110m but need to sign a winger/if (draxler) and probably 2 Amc's and possibly another deep midfielder but these are the only deals on the radar ATM

I think it was the start of my 2nd season when I got Vitinho from CSKA on a free. Sold him one year later for 31mil (pound) to Dortmund plus Real and Barca were bidding up there. He has good stats for a 20yr old but not amazing but it's the way he plays, he likes to take on the full backs down the wing and he can cut in or deliver a deep cross, only negative is sometimes he made a great dribble down to the corner, knocks the ball out in front of his opponent only to hold on to it too long. Have a look at him. Season 2 he was my starting AML over Young Januzaj Nani or Kagawa.

PS- Lamela is a gun, more for the right but easily plays on the left better than almost anyone
 
Player: Hervin Ongenda
Team you are managing: Olympiakos
Team who are buying: Benfica
Offer: 25.7M Euros
Year: 2017/2018
 
Player: Fabio
Team you are managing: Bayer Leverkusen
Team who are selling: Manchester United
Offer: 5.75M pounds
Year: 2013/2014


I need a pacey left back. Only have about 8M pounds to spend. The good thing about Fabio is that he can cover both LB/RB. His poor stamina worries me though.

View attachment 435544
 
Player: Fabio
Team you are managing: Bayer Leverkusen
Team who are selling: Manchester United
Offer: 5.75M pounds
Year: 2013/2014


I need a pacey left back. Only have about 8M pounds to spend. The good thing about Fabio is that he can cover both LB/RB. His poor stamina worries me though.

Sell, and buy Alex Sandro.
 
Sell, and buy Alex Sandro.

He's asking whether or not to buy him, since he is Leverkusen.


Player: Fabio
Team you are managing: Bayer Leverkusen
Team who are selling: Manchester United
Offer: 5.75M pounds
Year: 2013/2014


I need a pacey left back. Only have about 8M pounds to spend. The good thing about Fabio is that he can cover both LB/RB. His poor stamina worries me though.

View attachment 463991

Fabio is surprisingly good ingame, inspite of his stats. You could probably try getting him, and sell him for a profit after a couple of years. I've had quite a few offers for him when I was managing United. I assume the usual suspects (Davies, Sandro, Silva) are out of reach?
 
Fabio is surprisingly good ingame, inspite of his stats. You could probably try getting him, and sell him for a profit after a couple of years. I've had quite a few offers for him when I was managing United. I assume the usual suspects (Davies, Sandro, Silva) are out of reach?

Yes, sadly they are out of reach. I was hoping to get Dodo from Roma, but they demand 10m for him, which is just over my budget. Can't really see anyone I could sell to afford him either. The squad is pretty thin and I'd like to evaluate the players for at least half a season before offloading anyone. A pacey left back is urgently needed though.

I have to say I'm tempted to go for Fabio since I'm getting him pretty cheap and his wages are reasonable.

Thanks for the quick response, Sherkey!
 
Yes, sadly they are out of reach. I was hoping to get Dodo from Roma, but they demand 10m for him, which is just over my budget. Can't really see anyone I could sell to afford him either. The squad is pretty thin and I'd like to evaluate the players for at least half a season before offloading anyone. A pacey left back is urgently needed though.

I have to say I'm tempted to go for Fabio since I'm getting him pretty cheap and his wages are reasonable.

Thanks for the quick response, Sherkey!

What about Buttner?
 
Back
Top