Fm14 Deal or No Deal thread: Please use when asking if you should buy player x or y

  • Thread starter Thread starter Raikan007
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 717
  • Views Views 357K
Scotty98TR said:
Player: Gwendal Le Bras - Regen - See screenshot
Team you are managing: Arsenal
Team who are Selling: Real Madrid
Offer: ?43m (Release Clause
Year: Summer 16/17
Other: This kid looks like he'll become amazing. But he isn't fantastic yet, and has yet to play a senior match. After selling alot of players, I have ?60m to spend, and ?200k a week spare, but I can't find anyone to spend it on. So should I blow it all on this 17 year old?

Screenshot: View attachment 450120
Click to expand...

Based on that screenshot, he'll become amazing.. Plus, I think he can also be retrained to function well on the wings.. But I'd still say No Deal. 43 Million is a lot of cash to spend on the player. I think you'd be better off to wait a while, and see his injury progress, since he has slightly lower Natural Fitness. Since he has a Release Clause, and contract expiry is in 3 years, think you can afford to wait a year and evaluate.
 
Sherkey said:
Based on that screenshot, he'll become amazing.. Plus, I think he can also be retrained to function well on the wings.. But I'd still say No Deal. 43 Million is a lot of cash to spend on the player. I think you'd be better off to wait a while, and see his injury progress, since he has slightly lower Natural Fitness. Since he has a Release Clause, and contract expiry is in 3 years, think you can afford to wait a year and evaluate.
Click to expand...

My plan would be to train him as a either a ML or MR. My scouts haven't mentioned anything about injury proneness, but to be safe I will leave it a year or two. My only worry is that my rep (Arsenal's) may fall, because at that moment I just won the Champions League, so it is at it's highest

EDIT: Just noticed my scouts do say his weakness is consistency, so definitely not gonna spend ?43m on him at the moment! :)
 
Sherkey said:
Do you have good replacements lined up for him? Oxlade is amongst the best players on the Right, and as such I'd say No Deal. But if you've good regens lined up to take over from him, go ahead..
Click to expand...

I have a great regen AMR winger, but still 16 yrs old.. Lamela takes the right side IF.. Griezmann(W)/Bernard(IF) usually on the left.. And oxlade is the occasional versatile winger..But now, Bernard, is injured for 4 freaking months.. so oxlade have the chance
 
I bought him start of 3rd season with Man Utd for 7mil up front and 9mil over 24months. Has beast of stats. I reckon he's worth 23. As you see though he's with PSG in your save as is valued at 50, can you actually get him for 23? When these players go to the big clubs there price ****** rises
 
View attachment 441274View attachment 441273
Player: Alex SANDRO
Team you are managing: Man Utd
Team who are Selling: FCP
Offer: approx 10mil
Year: June 2015
Other: EVRA is gone, I'm left with Fabio who is a decent backup and Alvarez BALANTA who is a gun of a CB who played LB all year for me but VIDIC is old and BALANTA will move to CB. Fabio is valued at 17mil.

Question - Should I sign SANDRO for 10mil or stick with Fabio???
 
Jden86 said:
View attachment 450464View attachment 450467
Player: Alex SANDRO
Team you are managing: Man Utd
Team who are Selling: FCP
Offer: approx 10mil
Year: June 2015
Other: EVRA is gone, I'm left with Fabio who is a decent backup and Alvarez BALANTA who is a gun of a CB who played LB all year for me but VIDIC is old and BALANTA will move to CB. Fabio is valued at 17mil.

Question - Should I sign SANDRO for 10mil or stick with Fabio???
Click to expand...
deal for alex sandro. definitely one of the best lbs in the game.
 
Player: Gundogan
Team you are managing: Dortmund
Team who are buying: Real Madrid
Offer: ?38.5M straight up+ 3.5M over 12 months
Year: 2014/15 (2nd Season)
 
so your selling! He's the perfect age, very solid all round, good creative and technical skills. 38's a lot of $$$ but if you were to replace him with some1 equal you'd be paying that much for them. I'd keep him unless he's unhappy or sell him and buy Wanyama who you could probably get for 20mil and he is already a beast but becomes more awesome as time goes on
 
Jden86 said:
so your selling! He's the perfect age, very solid all round, good creative and technical skills. 38's a lot of $$$ but if you were to replace him with some1 equal you'd be paying that much for them. I'd keep him unless he's unhappy or sell him and buy Wanyama who you could probably get for 20mil and he is already a beast but becomes more awesome as time goes on
Click to expand...
Why Wanyama btw? Wanyama is best as a BWM. Gundogan is better as a BTB..
 
AMC dilemma

Hey so I just took over at Valencia in 2018 and I am having a AMC dilemma.

I'm happy with my current players in the position but one of my key players, Sergio Canales wants a new challenge, refuses to talk to me and is generally being a pain in the ***.

Here are his stats:
View attachment 440757

I wasn't really planning on doing anything about but then I found Josue who is available for 5.75m-8m;
View attachment 440758


I also found Denis Suarez who I can get for 5m-6,75m
View attachment 440759

So my question is should I;

A) Keep Canales and ride his attitude out (he did great in the 1st game of the season)

B) Get Josue

C) Get Denis Suarez

Thanks guys
 
The Icelander said:
Hey so I just took over at Valencia in 2018 and I am having a AMC dilemma.

I'm happy with my current players in the position but one of my key players, Sergio Canales wants a new challenge, refuses to talk to me and is generally being a pain in the ***.

Here are his stats:
View attachment 451570

I wasn't really planning on doing anything about but then I found Josue who is available for 5.75m-8m;
View attachment 451568


I also found Denis Suarez who I can get for 5m-6,75m
View attachment 451567

So my question is should I;

A) Keep Canales and ride his attitude out (he did great in the 1st game of the season)

B) Get Josue

C) Get Denis Suarez

Thanks guys
Click to expand...
i'd get rid of canales and get denis suarez.
 
Player: Frederico Macheda
Team you're managing: Southampton
Team buying: Sampdoria
Offer: 15 Million $
Season: 3rd Season.

View attachment 440731

Macheda's stats. I use him as a TM. My team is pretty strong in all other aspects. I have Lambert, Mitrovic and a young regen TM coming through. Osvaldo plays as a winger for me. Is the offer low, or should I sell him?
 
I'm looking for a new DM for my Newcastle team in the 2015/16 season, and i've narrowed it down to 4 players.

Player: Tom Huddlestone
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are selling: Norwich
Offer: 6 Million pounds
Year: 2015/16
View attachment 440598
Player: Arijan Ademi
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are selling: Frankfurt
Offer: 9 Million pounds
Year: 2015/16
View attachment 440596
Player: Claudio Yacob
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are selling: Liverpool
Offer: 9 Million pounds
Year: 2015/16
View attachment 440595
Player: Jonathan Dos Santos
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are selling: Southampton
Offer: 7 Million pounds
Year: 2015/16
View attachment 440594

Which of these four do you think i should go for?
 
Sherkey said:
Player: Frederico Macheda
Team you're managing: Southampton
Team buying: Sampdoria
Offer: 15 Million $
Season: 3rd Season.

View attachment 451638

Macheda's stats. I use him as a TM. My team is pretty strong in all other aspects. I have Lambert, Mitrovic and a young regen TM coming through. Osvaldo plays as a winger for me. Is the offer low, or should I sell him?
Click to expand...


Definitely sell, that is way above his value and you can easily replace him.




SFolio said:
I'm looking for a new DM for my Newcastle team in the 2015/16 season, and i've narrowed it down to 4 players.

Player: Tom Huddlestone
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are selling: Norwich
Offer: 6 Million pounds
Year: 2015/16
View attachment 451932
Player: Arijan Ademi
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are selling: Frankfurt
Offer: 9 Million pounds
Year: 2015/16
View attachment 451935
Player: Claudio Yacob
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are selling: Liverpool
Offer: 9 Million pounds
Year: 2015/16
View attachment 451937
Player: Jonathan Dos Santos
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are selling: Southampton
Offer: 7 Million pounds
Year: 2015/16
View attachment 451940

Which of these four do you think i should go for?
Click to expand...


Either Ademi or dos Santos,imo. The other two are both old, so I would only get them as a short term solution. I'd start looking at regens too, there might already be some good ones.
 
Last edited:
Selling to a league rival? Tsk Tsk. =P ;-) More important question, do you have someone good who can replace him. Or a realistic replacement you can buy? If so, sell. Else, I'd keep him. along with Lamela, he's among the best at AMR.
Most other teams, it'd be an easy deal, but you're United, so don't really need the money.
 
Last edited:
SFolio said:
I'm looking for a new DM for my Newcastle team in the 2015/16 season, and i've narrowed it down to 4 players.

Which of these four do you think i should go for?
Click to expand...


Definitely Yacob, great defensively, and pretty good on the ball too.
 
Player: James Rodriguez
Team you are managing: Team who are buying/Manchester united
Offer: ?9.75m
Year: 2016/17

also
Player: j ward Prowse
Team you are managing: Team who are buying/Manchester united
Offer: ? 4.9m
Year: 2016/17

and

Player: Leon goretzka
Team you are managing: Team who are buying/Manchester united
Offer: ?37.75m
Year: 2016/17
 
Last edited:
... And what team are you managing? Are you managing United, or are they buying from you? Latter seems less likely, so I'll go with the former.

If you're buying the players, Ward-Prowse and Rodriguez are worth it, at any given point of time. Goretzka, if you really need him. If you're United, you should already have Powell (if you haven't soold him, and are buying Ward-Prowse, I'd say no to Goretzka)
 
Player: Andre Schurlle
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are buying/selling: Chelsea
Offer: 8mil
Year: 2014/15

this fellow was transfer listed, never even made a single appearance to chelsea, i never used him before, any suggestions? especially on how to used him in his best position?

Player: Victor wanyama
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are buying/selling: southampton
Offer: 10mil + 35mil 48months
Year: 2014/15

i want to have this fellow so bad, i do have matuidi in my team but i could sell him for 33mil cash to City, quite confused whether i made a good deal or not. i want would play in champion league next season, need more depth in the team..
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top