Fm14 Deal or No Deal thread: Please use when asking if you should buy player x or y

  • Thread starter Thread starter Raikan007
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 717
  • Views Views 357K
does any one have any tips on wheeling and dealing when trying to sign players
 
Akinfeev

Player: Igor Akinfeev
Team you are managing: Cardiff City
Team who is "selling": CSKA Moscow
Price: Free
Year: 2014/15

Came 4th in the first season with Cardiff, so needed world class keeper to Champions League.
The wage demand is the issue

82k a month
900k loyal bonus
1 mil k agent fee

Are the demands to much?
 
Pitski said:
Player: Igor Akinfeev
Team you are managing: Cardiff City
Team who is "selling": CSKA Moscow
Price: Free
Year: 2014/15

Came 4th in the first season with Cardiff, so needed world class keeper to Champions League.
The wage demand is the issue

82k a month
900k loyal bonus
1 mil k agent fee

Are the demands to much?
Click to expand...
No deal due to the wage demands. ter stegen often gets transfer listed after a season so you might want to try getting him instead.
 
Player: Kevin de Bruyne
Team you are managing: Cardiff City
Team who is selling: Chelsea
Price: 7 million
Year: 2014/15

OR

Player: Lewis Holtby
Team you are managing: Cardiff City
Team who is selling: Tottenham
Price: 3.6 million
Year: 2014/15

Looking for an AP in the AMC spot.
 
Player; Luke shaw
My team; liverpool
Team selling; southampton
Price; 20M
Year; June 2015

Or

Player; Lucas digne
My team; liverpool
Team selling; PSG
Price; 20M
Year; June 2015

Need a LB to train into my team and become a worldie!
just had digne on loan for a season and he was epic, averaged 7.2 a game and got 8 goals but shaw is HG and 2 years younger, they're equal for most tech and mental stats but digne appears to be the better athlete at the moment physical wise but shaw must get better in a few years with training, basically the question is stick with what I know or get shaw who's HG


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Player: Bernard
My Team: Arsenal
Selling: Shahktar
Price: 22 + 13.5 (for 30% form agent)
Salary: 49K/week
Year: Summer 2nd Year

OR

Player: Draxler
My Team: Arsenal
Selling: Schalke
Price: 42.5 (25 paid over 4 years)
Salary: 130k/week
Year: Summer 2nd Year

Who should i go with?!
 
Lukaku
managing southampton
selling Chelsea
price 22million (incl agents)
summer 2014
i have mitrovic jay Rodriquez damaio guidetti play one striker but jay can provide cover at Amcrl damaio spent the latter half of last season on loan same with guidetti, I'm in champions league so want to strengthen but should I just rely on mitrovic

shaqiri
Managung southampton
selling bayern
price 26mil (incl agent)
summer 14
habe Lallana ince gaitan and mcmanaman on the wings so is he worth it



(prices in pounds on a slightly edited database where I got rid of everyone I didn't want pre game -osvaldo lambertetc- and fairly compensated myself)
 
Pitski said:
Player: Kevin de Bruyne
Team you are managing: Cardiff City
Team who is selling: Chelsea
Price: 7 million
Year: 2014/15

OR

Player: Lewis Holtby
Team you are managing: Cardiff City
Team who is selling: Tottenham
Price: 3.6 million
Year: 2014/15

Looking for an AP in the AMC spot.
Click to expand...
Deal for de bruyne.
jonesbilly194 said:
Player; Luke shaw
My team; liverpool
Team selling; southampton
Price; 20M
Year; June 2015

Or

Player; Lucas digne
My team; liverpool
Team selling; PSG
Price; 20M
Year; June 2015

Need a LB to train into my team and become a worldie!
just had digne on loan for a season and he was epic, averaged 7.2 a game and got 8 goals but shaw is HG and 2 years younger, they're equal for most tech and mental stats but digne appears to be the better athlete at the moment physical wise but shaw must get better in a few years with training, basically the question is stick with what I know or get shaw who's HG


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
20m for shaw is a bargain. Moreover, he's home grown and easily becomes one of the best lbs in the game. Deal.
CaptainCroatia said:
Player: Bernard
My Team: Arsenal
Selling: Shahktar
Price: 22 + 13.5 (for 30% form agent)
Salary: 49K/week
Year: Summer 2nd Year

OR

Player: Draxler
My Team: Arsenal
Selling: Schalke
Price: 42.5 (25 paid over 4 years)
Salary: 130k/week
Year: Summer 2nd Year

Who should i go with?!
Click to expand...
Both are pretty costly imo so no deal for either.
mjm98 said:
Lukaku
managing southampton
selling Chelsea
price 22million (incl agents)
summer 2014
i have mitrovic jay Rodriquez damaio guidetti play one striker but jay can provide cover at Amcrl damaio spent the latter half of last season on loan same with guidetti, I'm in champions league so want to strengthen but should I just rely on mitrovic

shaqiri
Managung southampton
selling bayern
price 26mil (incl agent)
summer 14
habe Lallana ince gaitan and mcmanaman on the wings so is he worth it



(prices in pounds on a slightly edited database where I got rid of everyone I didn't want pre game -osvaldo lambertetc- and fairly compensated myself)
Click to expand...
Deal for lukaku.
 
Pitski said:
Player: Kevin de Bruyne
Team you are managing: Cardiff City
Team who is selling: Chelsea
Price: 7 million
Year: 2014/15

OR

Player: Lewis Holtby
Team you are managing: Cardiff City
Team who is selling: Tottenham
Price: 3.6 million
Year: 2014/15

Looking for an AP in the AMC spot.
Click to expand...

I'd personally go with de Bruyne. Maybe more expensive, but he's definitely worth it, and is on a different class altogether.
 
Player: Barbosa
Team you are managing: Cardiff City
Team who is selling: Santos
Price: 11 million
Year: 2014/15

OR

Player: Saleh
Team you are managing: Cardiff City
Team who is selling: Basel
Price: 6 million
Year: 2014/15

AND

Player: Holtby
Team you are managing: Cardiff City
Team who is selling: Tottenham
Price: 4 million
Year: 2014/15

Should I splash the cash on future mega star or should I spend it on two excellent players?
 
Last edited:
Holtby never did anything for me when I signed him for LFC in 14/15. Barbosa is proving excellent in 16/17. Salah goes on to be one of the coverted players in the game so defo go for him and maybe Jordan Rhodes who will ALWAYS score goals.
 
Player: Ruben Pardo
My team: PSV
Team selling: Real Sociedad
Price: ?5.5M
Year: 2015/2016

(Loads of other teams bidded for him aswell)

&

Player: Paulo Dybala
My team: PSV
Team selling: Palermo
Price: ?1.7M
Year: 2015/2016

(Seems a bargain to me)
 
Player: Sami Khedira
Team you are managing: Real Madrid
Team who are buying/selling: PSG
Offer: ?40million
Year: 2014/15
 
Player: Fabio Coentrao
Team you are managing: Man Utd
Team who are buying/selling: Real Madrid
Offer: 7mil
Year: June 2013
Other Info: Just shelled out 18mil for Luke Shaw, Not sure if to offer Evra a new contract or sell him on and bring in Coentrao.

Quick replies would be great. Thanx in advance
 
craiglowerson1984 said:
Player: Fabio Coentrao
Team you are managing: Man Utd
Team who are buying/selling: Real Madrid
Offer: 7mil
Year: June 2013
Other Info: Just shelled out 18mil for Luke Shaw, Not sure if to offer Evra a new contract or sell him on and bring in Coentrao.


Quick replies would be great. Thanx in advance
Click to expand...

No deal
If you have Shaw you might as well offer Evra a new contract who can then tutor Shaw. He should be your number one LB for 10-12 seasons.
 
Liverpool January First season - Budget: 36m pounds Wages: 388k p/w. Need a ST/Winger.

1. Julian Draxler (38.5m buy-out clause)
2. Andre Ayew (10m upfront, 6m over 12 months)
3. Bernard (15m)
4. Lorenzo Insigne (15m upfront, 10m over 12 months)
5. Maximilian Meyer (15m upfront, 10m over 12 months)
6. Javier Pastore (16m upfront, 4.5m over 12 months)
7. Cristian Tello (15m)
8. Fernando (Porto-end of contract)

Could you please recommend one from the first 7. Want a young player who can play or be trained as a striker.
Should I sign Fernando on a free even though I have Lucas and Romero? Is he worth it?
 
louiscfc said:
Liverpool January First season - Budget: 36m pounds Wages: 388k p/w. Need a ST/Winger.

1. Julian Draxler (38.5m buy-out clause)
2. Andre Ayew (10m upfront, 6m over 12 months)
3. Bernard (15m)
4. Lorenzo Insigne (15m upfront, 10m over 12 months)
5. Maximilian Meyer (15m upfront, 10m over 12 months)
6. Javier Pastore (16m upfront, 4.5m over 12 months)
7. Cristian Tello (15m)
8. Fernando (Porto-end of contract)

Could you please recommend one from the first 7. Want a young player who can play or be trained as a striker.
Should I sign Fernando on a free even though I have Lucas and Romero? Is he worth it?
Click to expand...

Cristian Tello should only cost 8 million? He's good.
The best of the lot is Draxler, although he's more an IF, probably shouldn't be played as a striker.

Striker/Winger look at Mitrovic, or Berardi.
 
FootballManagerG0D said:
Cristian Tello should only cost 8 million? He's good.
The best of the lot is Draxler, although he's more an IF, probably shouldn't be played as a striker.

Striker/Winger look at Mitrovic, or Berardi.
Click to expand...

Thanks for the reply :)

Sorry, I didn't make myself clear enough. Sturridge got a long injury so I want a good winger/IF who can play up top as back-up to Suarez but mainly plays out wide if that makes sense.

Do you recommend Draxler then or Tello if I can get the fee down to 8mill? 1st in league so need someone to offer the team something right away.

Berardi joined Barcelona and I don't really need Mitrovic as I have Suarez and Sturridge, but want a winger who can play up top if they have to.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top