Fm14 Deal or No Deal thread: Please use when asking if you should buy player x or y

  • Thread starter Thread starter Raikan007
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 717
  • Views Views 357K
louiscfc said:
Thanks for the reply :)

Sorry, I didn't make myself clear enough. Sturridge got a long injury so I want a good winger/IF who can play up top as back-up to Suarez but mainly plays out wide if that makes sense.

Do you recommend Draxler then or Tello if I can get the fee down to 8mill? 1st in league so need someone to offer the team something right away.

Berardi joined Barcelona and I don't really need Mitrovic as I have Suarez and Sturridge, but want a winger who can play up top if they have to.
Click to expand...

as an IF then Draxler is probably the best youth in the game. Tello is a good pickup if he still has his minimum fee release clause.
 
Man Utd only need 2 of the following 3 players to play anchorman/ ball winner in dmc position. Matic 12.5m, Fernando 6m or Matuidi 5m. Which 2 should I go for???
 
Player: Lucas Romero
Team who are buying: Bar?a/Real/whoever
Team who are selling: Feyenoord (me)
Year: 2017/18
Offer: I believe that they can get to offer something like 28-30m
Other: Both Spanish giants are battling for him, constantly offering big money. I've always refused so far, but since my midfield is already strong (Vilhena, Clasie, Nainggolan, Honda, Vormer, Kara) I was thinking about selling him next summer. However, even if he never was a first choice for me because of his average performances, my staff rate him as my best CM and I was actually planning to let him become a key player next season, selling the 30-yr old Honda.


Opinions? Here's a ss btw, sorry for the language...I hope you'll understand his attributes:
 
Last edited:
DarklinkCL said:
Player: Lucas Romero
Team who are buying: Bar?a/Real/whoever
Team who are selling: Feyenoord (me)
Year: 2017/18
Offer: I believe that they can get to offer something like 28-30m
Other: Both Spanish giants are battling for him, constantly offering big money. I've always refused so far, but since my midfield is already strong (Vilhena, Clasie, Nainggolan, Honda, Vormer, Kara) I was thinking about selling him next summer. However, even if he never was a first choice for me because of his average performances, my staff rate him as my best CM and I was actually planning to let him become a key player next season, selling the 30-yr old Honda.


Opinions? Here's a ss btw, sorry for the language...I hope you'll understand his attributes:
Click to expand...
no deal and sell honda instead.
 
Player: Wellington Nem
Team Buying/managing: Wiagn
Team Selling: Shakthar
Year: 2016/2017
Price: 10-12m
Other: I need a new AMR, I'm in November of my fourth season with Wigan, sitting top of the league with Newcastle 7 points behind me. After cup success i got bought out and bought some great players like Coutinho, Januzaj etc. However, Barcelona bought Callum McMannaman from me for 20m and I didn't get a sufficent replacement for him. Money isn't a problem as i've got a minimum budget of 22m. I've also looked at Rodrigo Gomez and Nani (7.5m). If anyone has any alternative suggestions as well I would be grateful. Oh yeah, back on topic, deal or no deal?
 
MUFC FOR LIF3 said:
Player: Wellington Nem
Team Buying/managing: Wiagn
Team Selling: Shakthar
Year: 2016/2017
Price: 10-12m
Other: I need a new AMR, I'm in November of my fourth season with Wigan, sitting top of the league with Newcastle 7 points behind me. After cup success i got bought out and bought some great players like Coutinho, Januzaj etc. However, Barcelona bought Callum McMannaman from me for 20m and I didn't get a sufficent replacement for him. Money isn't a problem as i've got a minimum budget of 22m. I've also looked at Rodrigo Gomez and Nani (7.5m). If anyone has any alternative suggestions as well I would be grateful. Oh yeah, back on topic, deal or no deal?
Click to expand...
deal. massimo bruno's pretty good as well. thought you might also want to scout for regens instead.
 
Player: Cristiano Ronaldo
Team you are managing: Arsenal
Team who is selling: Real Madrid
Offer: ?50 mil - ish, perhaps ?30m + Lucas Moura
Year: 2017/18
Other: I know he's 32, but last season for Madrid he was still really good. Below are screenshots for him. At the moment I only have Lucas and Ozil for the right. But I want to sell Lucas after falling out with him.

View attachment 419223View attachment 419224

EDIT: There aren't any other players I want to buy, and I have plenty of spare money after clearing out alot of fringe players. So money isn't an issue.
 
Last edited:
Player: Douglas Costa
Team Buying/managing: Leeds
Team Selling: Shakthar
Year: 2016/2017
Price: 7.5m

Looked to me a bargain. Problem is, can he play in Premiere League or not? He's pretty lightweight. His bravery is only 4, balance is 5. Technically he's gifted but physically I'm not sure if he can handle PL???

Any experience with him in Premiere League would be welcomed.
 
Scotty98TR said:
Player: Cristiano Ronaldo
Team you are managing: Arsenal
Team who is selling: Real Madrid
Offer: ?50 mil - ish, perhaps ?30m + Lucas Moura
Year: 2017/18
Other: I know he's 32, but last season for Madrid he was still really good. Below are screenshots for him. At the moment I only have Lucas and Ozil for the right. But I want to sell Lucas after falling out with him.

View attachment 501811View attachment 501808

EDIT: There aren't any other players I want to buy, and I have plenty of spare money after clearing out alot of fringe players. So money isn't an issue.
Click to expand...

I signed him when he was 33 and he was shocking and I couldn't get rid of him despite him playing well for Madrid before but if you have tons of cash then deal. His stats are still good.
 
Player: Franco Zuculini
Team you are managing: Mallorca
Team who are buying: Couple Serie A teams
Offer: 11.5€
Year: 2014/15 Pre season

I Got promoted to Liga BBVA with Mallorca and Zuculini was one of the best in my middlefield, played him at CM. I think that he is quite a good atm, but I think that he will not develop so much anymore. Maybe after few years he will be surplus to requirements. I also think that I cant get much more better bid for he in the future...
Who would you recommend to sing to replace him?
 
Scotty98TR said:
Player: Cristiano Ronaldo
Team you are managing: Arsenal
Team who is selling: Real Madrid
Offer: ?50 mil - ish, perhaps ?30m + Lucas Moura
Year: 2017/18
Other: I know he's 32, but last season for Madrid he was still really good. Below are screenshots for him. At the moment I only have Lucas and Ozil for the right. But I want to sell Lucas after falling out with him.

View attachment 501811View attachment 501808

EDIT: There aren't any other players I want to buy, and I have plenty of spare money after clearing out alot of fringe players. So money isn't an issue.
Click to expand...
No deal. His stats don't look very impressive but then again he's 32 so I can understand. I'd look out for regens instead as I've seen quite a bit of players reach his level despite being trained by ai teams.
hedonist said:
Player: Douglas Costa
Team Buying/managing: Leeds
Team Selling: Shakthar
Year: 2016/2017
Price: 7.5m

Looked to me a bargain. Problem is, can he play in Premiere League or not? He's pretty lightweight. His bravery is only 4, balance is 5. Technically he's gifted but physically I'm not sure if he can handle PL???

Any experience with him in Premiere League would be welcomed.
Click to expand...
At 7.5m, I doubt anything much can go wrong so deal.
 
JormaJorma said:
Player: Franco Zuculini
Team you are managing: Mallorca
Team who are buying: Couple Serie A teams
Offer: 11.5€
Year: 2014/15 Pre season

I Got promoted to Liga BBVA with Mallorca and Zuculini was one of the best in my middlefield, played him at CM. I think that he is quite a good atm, but I think that he will not develop so much anymore. Maybe after few years he will be surplus to requirements. I also think that I cant get much more better bid for he in the future...
Who would you recommend to sing to replace him?
Click to expand...
I'd keep him for a season or 2 and by then, I'm sure you'd get a better bid then this. :)
 
Player: Julian Draxler
Team you are managing: Real Madrid
Team who are selling: Schalke
Offer: ?38.5m (buy-out clause)
Year: Jan 2014

or

Player: Stephen El Shaarawy
Team you are managing: Real Madrid
Team who are selling: AC Milan
Offer: ?40m plus 10m over 48 months
Year: Jan 2014
 
Player: Yann M'Vila
Team managing: AS Roma
Team selling: Rubin Kazan
Offer: 2 - 2.5million
Season: 2016/2017

His contract is expiring so could get him on a free but since De Rossi is aging and can't play 2 to 3 matches a week this could be a solution.
 
louiscfc said:
Player: Julian Draxler
Team you are managing: Real Madrid
Team who are selling: Schalke
Offer: ?38.5m (buy-out clause)
Year: Jan 2014

or

Player: Stephen El Shaarawy
Team you are managing: Real Madrid
Team who are selling: AC Milan
Offer: ?40m plus 10m over 48 months
Year: Jan 2014
Click to expand...
No deal for both.
JohnWayve said:
Player: Yann M'Vila
Team managing: AS Roma
Team selling: Rubin Kazan
Offer: 2 - 2.5million
Season: 2016/2017

His contract is expiring so could get him on a free but since De Rossi is aging and can't play 2 to 3 matches a week this could be a solution.
Click to expand...
Try negotiating lower a bit. You might want to look for regens as well.
 
Player: Luis Muriel
Team Managing: Wigan
Team Selling: Marseille
Price: ?22.5-?30million
Year: 2017/2018

Just finished the season with wigan, done brilliantly and won the league. However, Holt (my sub) has retired meaning my only striker is John Guidetti. He had a great season , coming runner up in the golden boot. Clubs are interested in Guidetti, who is now somehow worth ?27m, a player i bought for ?1.1m, and if an offer came i would accept. I'm looking for an Advanced Forward to take his role. If you know of any alternatives I am all ears.
 
Player: Lucas Romero
Team Managing: Newcastle Utd
Team Selling: Velez
Price: 7 Million
Year: 2013/2014
or
Player: Will Hughes
Team Managing: Newcastle Utd
Team Selling: Derby
Price: 8 Million
Year: 2013/2014

Looking for a cabaye replacement and strongly looking in these two, i can get both but i could pick up Doria if i get one! however i have signed Balanta for 9M and have Marquinhos on season loan, what are your recommendations people
 
DxSkYLiNe said:
Player: Lucas Romero
Team Managing: Newcastle Utd
Team Selling: Velez
Price: 7 Million
Year: 2013/2014
or
Player: Will Hughes
Team Managing: Newcastle Utd
Team Selling: Derby
Price: 8 Million
Year: 2013/2014

Looking for a cabaye replacement and strongly looking in these two, i can get both but i could pick up Doria if i get one! however i have signed Balanta for 9M and have Marquinhos on season loan, what are your recommendations people
Click to expand...

I would definitely deal for Romero and would probably get Doria as well.
 
Player: Julian Draxler
Team Managing: Liverpool
Team Selling: Schalke
Price: 60 million
Year: 2014/2015
or
Player: Isco
Team Managing: liverpool
Team Selling: R.mard
Price: 62mil
Year: 2014/2015
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top