Fm14 Deal or No Deal thread: Please use when asking if you should buy player x or y

  • Thread starter Thread starter Raikan007
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 715
  • Views Views 385K
Polo1 said:
Player: Lars Bender
Team you are managing: Manchester United
Team who are buying/selling: Real Madrid
Offer: ?42 million
Year: 2015/16

Note: already have Fellaini and wanyama, and a few 5 star regens that are close. Loaned out ward-prowse already
Click to expand...

No deal. Both Fellaini and Wanyama are adept at B2B/BWM. You'll have to throw one out to keep Bender, so I'd say skip it.

Edit: Lol, mention if the club is buying or selling :\. Edit that template to suit your question, ok? If that's pounds or Euros, Deal. Sell him. If you're buying, then Dont.
 
Player: Wayne Rooney
Team Managing: Liverpool
Team Selling: Manchester United
Price: ?6million
Year: 2014/2015 January

Transfer listed by request.... Will he move to Liverpool though???​




 
1jakebrown said:
Player: Wayne Rooney
Team Managing: Liverpool
Team Selling: Manchester United
Price: ?6million
Year: 2014/2015 January

Transfer listed by request.... Will he move to Liverpool though???​
Click to expand...

As a Manchester United fan, I loathe that possibility. But coming to your case, why don't you try to find out? Although, you probably won't be able to afford his wages/agent fee..
 
Player: Andrea Poli
Team you are managing: A.C. Milan
Team who are buying: Arsenal
Offer: 15,25 M (14,5 M + 725 m / 12 months)
Year: 2015/16 pre-season

 
1jakebrown said:
Player: Wayne Rooney
Team Managing: Liverpool
Team Selling: Manchester United
Price: ?6million
Year: 2014/2015 January

Transfer listed by request.... Will he move to Liverpool though???​
Click to expand...

The transfer fee is peanuts for a player of his class. However expect to pay a large loyalty bonus/agent fee and expect exorbitant weekly wages. A definite buy if you can afford his wages though.
 
Player: David Alaba
Team Managing: Arsenal
Team Selling: FC Bayern
Price: 24 million euro
Year: 2013/2014

Player: Natxo Monreal
Team Managing: Arsenal
Team Buying: Shakhtar
Price: 10 million euro
Year: 2013/2014
 
Rafiomcnick said:
Player: David Alaba
Team Managing: Arsenal
Team Selling: FC Bayern
Price: 24 million euro
Year: 2013/2014

Player: Natxo Monreal
Team Managing: Arsenal
Team Buying: Shakhtar
Price: 10 million euro
Year: 2013/2014
Click to expand...

Deal for both.
 
vjcsmoke said:
The transfer fee is peanuts for a player of his class. However expect to pay a large loyalty bonus/agent fee and expect exorbitant weekly wages. A definite buy if you can afford his wages though.
Click to expand...

He didnt want to enter contract talks anyway.... Surprisingly no one else came in for him and hes rotting on Utds bench
 
Player: (regen) Deren Day
Team Managing: Arsenal
Team Buying: Stoke City
Price: 54 million pounds (6.25M initial, 40.5M over 36 months, 7.75 after 10 league goals)
Year: 2017/2018
Here's his screenshot, I thought this might be helpful haha: View attachment 410310
 
Player:Lucas Leiva
Team Managing: Liverpool
Team Buying: PSG
Price: 31.5 million pounds
Year: 2013/14

I accepted and brought Wanyama as his replacement. was I right?
 
Logorex said:
Player: (regen) Deren Day
Team Managing: Arsenal
Team Buying: Stoke City
Price: 54 million pounds (6.25M initial, 40.5M over 36 months, 7.75 after 10 league goals)
Year: 2017/2018
Here's his screenshot, I thought this might be helpful haha: View attachment 521512
Click to expand...

If you need the money, then yes sell. He looks like he is going to be a beast but you could buy 2-3 really good players for that amount of money. If you don't need the money to buy new players then keep him.
 
im currently lyon, in 2020

just been offered 65m for benzia , do I sell or keep?
scoring around 15 a season in the league and 25 including cups ect..

really not sure to sell or keep?
 
vjcsmoke said:
If you need the money, then yes sell. He looks like he is going to be a beast but you could buy 2-3 really good players for that amount of money. If you don't need the money to buy new players then keep him.
Click to expand...

Yeah, my transfer budget's already 123 mil, so I don't really need the money.
It's just SO MUCH offered, that I'm tempted to accept.
 
Player: Marco Reus
Team Managing: Chelsea
Team Selling: Dortmund
Price: 29.5 million pounds (buy-out clause)
Year: July 2013/2014

or

Player: Diego Costa
Team Managing: Chelsea
Team Selling: Atletico Madrid
Price: 32 million pounds (buy-out clause)
Year: July 2013/2014

or

Player: Jese
Team Managing: Chelsea
Team Selling: Real Madrid
Price: 29.5 million pounds (buy-out clause)
Year: July 2013/2014

Need a striker first season who is adaptable and can develop with enough money to buy a DLP. 50m budget with 170k p/w wage budget. I know Jese turns into a monster but how is Reus?
 
stugreig27 said:
im currently lyon, in 2020

just been offered 65m for benzia , do I sell or keep?
scoring around 15 a season in the league and 25 including cups ect..

really not sure to sell or keep?
Click to expand...

Sell, and get regens.
 
louiscfc said:
Player: Marco Reus
Team Managing: Chelsea
Team Selling: Dortmund
Price: 29.5 million pounds (buy-out clause)
Year: July 2013/2014

or

Player: Diego Costa
Team Managing: Chelsea
Team Selling: Atletico Madrid
Price: 32 million pounds (buy-out clause)
Year: July 2013/2014

or

Player: Jese
Team Managing: Chelsea
Team Selling: Real Madrid
Price: 29.5 million pounds (buy-out clause)
Year: July 2013/2014

Need a striker first season who is adaptable and can develop with enough money to buy a DLP. 50m budget with 170k p/w wage budget. I know Jese turns into a monster but how is Reus?
Click to expand...

You can get Jese for cheaper if you try to loan him back. But even otherwise, Costa wasn't that good ingame;; Between Reus and Jese, Reus won't want to join, so yeah Jese.
 
Sherkey said:
You can get Jese for cheaper if you try to loan him back. But even otherwise, Costa wasn't that good ingame;; Between Reus and Jese, Reus won't want to join, so yeah Jese.
Click to expand...

I'm playing after the update and Costa has had a boost. Is he still bad? Also Reus does want to join (again, on the update, before he never did) and its actually Jese who doesn't want to join but i'll try and loan him back. I've never had Reus, is he good as a striker?
 
louiscfc said:
I'm playing after the update and Costa has had a boost. Is he still bad? Also Reus does want to join (again, on the update, before he never did) and its actually Jese who doesn't want to join but i'll try and loan him back. I've never had Reus, is he good as a striker?
Click to expand...

Reus is an excellent winger/IF, but as a striker, but I haven't been playing with the new database, so I can't say.. If Costa has had a boost, you can get him;; I've rarely seen Costa successful in Human Management pre-update;; Maybe that's changed post-update.
 
Forget about Reus and Jese. Buy Robert Lewandowski, if he is willing to sign you won't regret it. He is banging in goals for fun for Real Madrid in my save. I manage Liverpool and unfortunately he doesn't want to switch sides.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top