Fm14 Deal or No Deal thread: Please use when asking if you should buy player x or y

  • Thread starter Thread starter Raikan007
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 715
  • Views Views 385K
Player: Johnathan Silva
Team managing: Newcastle
Team buying: Barcelona
Fee: 24 m
Date: July 2018
Database: 14.3

I already have Shaw, I signed him 3rd season, I'm wondering if I should bother keeping Silva, or just start looking for a young regen to take his place as a rotation option.
 
Strolla said:
Player: Johnathan Silva
Team managing: Newcastle
Team buying: Barcelona
Fee: 24 m
Date: July 2018
Database: 14.3

I already have Shaw, I signed him 3rd season, I'm wondering if I should bother keeping Silva, or just start looking for a young regen to take his place as a rotation option.
Click to expand...

Deal. Like you said, look for a regen as he probably will be playing back-up to Shaw.
 
Rafiomcnick said:
Player: Yaya Toure
Team managing: Arsenal
Team selling: Man City
Fee: 1,5 m
Wage: 132 k
Date: July 2016
Database: 14.3

He's still very good (his CA is 161) and he's unhappy because he wants to play the Champions League. In my current midfield i have Wilshere,Ramsey,Bender and Sergi Samper ( who looks like a beast). I'm playing with 2 only MC and 5 five players for 2 places seem too much (also he's asking a big wage and he wants to be a key player).
Sorry mates but i have this huge doubt and any advice is very appreciated. Thanks in advance
Click to expand...

No deal. The wages he is asking for along with the key player will cause hassle. You won't need him with that midfield and I'm sure with injuries you will have other players that can play there so there is no need for him. Plus I would play a lot of those players ahead of him.
 
Player: Adam Lallana
Team managing: Southampton
Team buying: Liverpool
Fee: 30m
Date: August 2014
Database: 14.3

He has been on fire for me last season and was in the BPL Team of the Year as well as earning Supporters POTY. Help!
 
Player: Angelo Henriquez
Team you are managing: Man United
Team who are buying: Dortmund
Offer: ?20M + 15% Profit of next transfer
Year: 2017
 
lewie100 said:
Player: Adam Lallana
Team managing: Southampton
Team buying: Liverpool
Fee: 30m
Date: August 2014
Database: 14.3

He has been on fire for me last season and was in the BPL Team of the Year as well as earning Supporters POTY. Help!
Click to expand...

Only deal if his value is lower than 20m otherwise you can probably get more from him
 
Player: Sven Bender
Team managing: Dortmund
Team buying: AS Monaco
Fee: 35m pounds
Date: August 2014
Database: 14.3
Just to note, its transfer deadline day so I wouldn't be able to replace; I have Nuri Sahin, Gundogan, Kehl and Jojic should Bender leave.
 
Last edited:
Player: Jan Vertoghen
Team you are managing: Tottenahm
Team who are buying: Real Madrid
Offer: ?34.5m upfront, 5.5 over 12 months
Year: June 2014

P.s I would go for caulker to replace at ?7m
 
NatGowdy said:
Player: Jan Vertoghen
Team you are managing: Tottenahm
Team who are buying: Real Madrid
Offer: ?34.5m upfront, 5.5 over 12 months
Year: June 2014

P.s I would go for caulker to replace at ?7m
Click to expand...

If you have Caulker lined up and ready as a replacement, do it for that price. Easy.
 
Liverpool FC

Player: Adam Lallana
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are buying/selling: Southampton
Offer: 15.25M
Year: 2013/14

Player: Mohamed Sissoko
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are buying/selling: Levante
Offer: 850K
Year: 2013/14

Player: Sam Byram
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are buying/selling: Leeds
Offer: 3M
Year: 2013/14

OR

Player: Kyle Naughton
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are buying/selling: Tottenham
Offer: 4M
Year: 2013/14


 
Player: Mattia De Sciglio
Team managing: Arsenal
Team selling: Milan
Fee: 32 m
Wage: 110 k
Date: January 2017
Database: 14.3

or

Player: Gino Peruzzi
Team managing: Arsenal
Team selling: Psg
Fee: 27 m
Wage: 110 k
Date:January 2017
Database: 14.3

Both are unhappy and Sagna is 33 and his contract is going to expire at the end of the season, i need a new FB (WB-A or CWB). Thanks in advance
 
Last edited:
Player: Koke
Team managing: Atletico Madrid
Team Buying: PSG
Fee: 30m
Date: July 2013
 
Last edited:
England66 said:
Player: Koke
Team managing: Atletico Madrid
Team Buying: PSG
Fee: 30m
Date: July 2013
Click to expand...

No deal, get him on form and his value will rise to that in a season or two, and then you can sell him for 40+
 
Player: Robert Lewandowski
Team managing: FC Bayern
Team Buying: Real Madrid
Fee: ?60 million
Date: Aug 2017
Info: Who can i buy to replace
 
I'm thinking of selling Robin van Persie for 60 Million $, and getting Kevin Volland. I'm not renewing Rooney's contract, so Volland will be my main F9 in a year's time, while Barbosa/Henriquez will be my Poacher/Advanced Forward. That sounds like a good deal, or should I go ahead with this regen, and keep van Persie?

View attachment 391010View attachment 391009
 
Player: Rene Adler
Team managing: HSV
Team Buying: Man City
Fee: 16m upfront 4.75m addons
Date: 10 Dec 2014
Info: He's an amazing professional and a true leader... who could possibly replace him?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top