I could not find a more appropriate thread for this. So here goes.
I have a GK, Fernando Henriques who has excellent GK and physical attributes but is slightly weak mentally. My Assistant Moura (JCA/JPA 16/16) rates him as a 2.5-3 star player. Basically, a fairly good to good player for the EPL.
Now, according to my scout Hamilton (JCA/JPA 20/19), G Ochoa is an excellent player and would be a leading star for most EPL teams. So far so good.
However, when I look at the two players' attributes, I think these opinions are wrong. Ochoa might be slightly better, but surely enough not THAT good? Here's a screenshot:
I don't see the difference. In fact, the GK attributes of Henrique might even be better. So, I decided to go to the Genie scout. It concurred with my scouts.
So where have I got it wrong? And is the difference really that much or only a bit?
Edit: I got the answer. It's the mental attribute. If anybody wants it, I will post the detailed analysis here. The scouts were absolutely right!