You were impartial, I was just joking.
I'm Benfica fan and I also think that (by now) Renato is overrated.
Even though, it is also true that Benfica's good form is mostly due to his sudden appearence this season.
I think, he is fairly rated for the system I think it's the system that has a problem. The increases in attributes doesn't represent real life and I think that's where the problem lies. But he is very highly rated and the probability of him becoming a top player is quite high. Therefore it is maybe a fair representation.