LFCMarshall's FM14 update suggestion thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Also Bayern and Real have agreed terms with Alonso, Should happen in the next few days.

Spurs signed Fazio
 
Warnock to Palace. Jadon Puncheon must be buzzing.....

And the Bale and Sterling analagy which was used earlier. Sterling at his age is the most exciting talent i have seen who is English since maybe Micheal Owen and Rooney. In 2014 he has become the player people were on about when he was 14. Development been off the chart. I was talking to a mate the other day and could actually see him becoming a ST. But we will see about that. 6 months ago nobody would have said he could have been an AMC. Now look at him. Looking forward to seeing him in the diamond behind Balotelli and Sturridge tho. And compared to Bale at his age he is way way ahead in his development.

Remember this ....

View attachment 678750

Being well-ahead in development doesn't mean he's more talented.

Bale didn't deserve to have 186 PA when he was still playing at left back, but looking at him now, I highly doubt Sterling will ever get to that level. He doesn't have the power or the ball striking technique & I doubt he ever will, just a very good, clean speed & dribbling game which only really warrants about 176 PA; around the Di Maria/Reus level. His stats will still be very good on FM, just not as good as Robben or Ribery & that's how it should be unless he starts showing signs he can do amazing stuff like this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oN5AL6cdza8
 
Last edited:
Take a look in some south american players:

everton ribeiro and ricardo goulart ( cruzeiro ) the both was called from brazil, ricardo goulart is the brazilian serie a top goal scorer and everton ribeiro is the best offensive midfield. Ricardo Goulart deserver improvement is his CA and PA abilities.

Diego tardelli ( atletico mineiro ) deserves 15 in finishing and 17 por acceleration and pace. Now is called from Brazil

Hector Villalba ( San lorenzo) needs improvement, made a very good Libertadores, very fast player ( Deservers Higher PA

Glil ( corinthians ) very good defender, was called from Brazl, deserves 17 in marking and 16 in tackling. For two years the best defender in brazilian football

Elias ( corinthians ) deserve higher CA,

ganso ( são Paulo) deserves 18 from passing and 19 from techinique. very very talented player, his passing and techinique is amazing

pato ( são Paulo) finishing 14 and dribling 15

ralf ( corinthians ) 18 in marking. His marking abilities is amazing, for years the best marker in brazilian football

-Luciano Acosta (He is a good player IRL, in FM14 he is a very bad player, i mean he is young but his PA is really low, good dribbler, pacy and with good long shots, he was on the starting 11 of Boca Juniors in his first season) i saw that in other topic and i agreed with him

hernane ( al nasser ex flamengo) brazilian top goal scorer in previous season. deserves 16 in finishing
 
Just curious on this one. How's Munir el Hadaddi (FC Barcelona) in your latest version?
 
Being well-ahead in development doesn't mean he's more talented.

Bale didn't deserve to have 186 PA when he was still playing at left back, but looking at him now, I highly doubt Sterling will ever get to that level. He doesn't have the power or the ball striking technique & I doubt he ever will, just a very good, clean speed & dribbling game which only really warrants about 176 PA; around the Di Maria/Reus level. His stats will still be very good on FM, just not as good as Robben or Ribery & that's how it should be unless he starts showing signs he can do amazing stuff like this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oN5AL6cdza8

By that logic, no players under 20 would have a fixed PA of 170+, and thats ridiculous
 
Being well-ahead in development doesn't mean he's more talented.

Bale didn't deserve to have 186 PA when he was still playing at left back, but looking at him now, I highly doubt Sterling will ever get to that level. He doesn't have the power or the ball striking technique & I doubt he ever will, just a very good, clean speed & dribbling game which only really warrants about 176 PA; around the Di Maria/Reus level. His stats will still be very good on FM, just not as good as Robben or Ribery & that's how it should be unless he starts showing signs he can do amazing stuff like this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oN5AL6cdza8
I just think using that logic then no youngster would have a high fixed potential - you are comparing 18/19 year olds saying they need to do stuff like Robben/Ribery - two of the best players on the planet in their positions

for now it's staying the same
Take a look in some south american players:

everton ribeiro and ricardo goulart ( cruzeiro ) the both was called from brazil, ricardo goulart is the brazilian serie a top goal scorer and everton ribeiro is the best offensive midfield. Ricardo Goulart deserver improvement is his CA and PA abilities.

Diego tardelli ( atletico mineiro ) deserves 15 in finishing and 17 por acceleration and pace. Now is called from Brazil

Hector Villalba ( San lorenzo) needs improvement, made a very good Libertadores, very fast player ( Deservers Higher PA

Glil ( corinthians ) very good defender, was called from Brazl, deserves 17 in marking and 16 in tackling. For two years the best defender in brazilian football

Elias ( corinthians ) deserve higher CA,

ganso ( são Paulo) deserves 18 from passing and 19 from techinique. very very talented player, his passing and techinique is amazing

pato ( são Paulo) finishing 14 and dribling 15

ralf ( corinthians ) 18 in marking. His marking abilities is amazing, for years the best marker in brazilian football

-Luciano Acosta (He is a good player IRL, in FM14 he is a very bad player, i mean he is young but his PA is really low, good dribbler, pacy and with good long shots, he was on the starting 11 of Boca Juniors in his first season) i saw that in other topic and i agreed with him

hernane ( al nasser ex flamengo) brazilian top goal scorer in previous season. deserves 16 in finishing
ill take a look
Just curious on this one. How's Munir el Hadaddi (FC Barcelona) in your latest version?
Not updated on the update released but has been upgraded for the next update
By that logic, no players under 20 would have a fixed PA of 170+, and thats ridiculous

completely agree.
 
Transfers:
Kristoffer Peterson from Liverpool to FC Utrech. ( 4 year contract.)
Nenad Milijas from Red Star to Manisaspor. ( 2 year contract.)
Lukasz Teodorczyk from Lech Poznan to Dynamo Kiev. ( 5 year contract.)
Roberto from Tosno to Arouca. ( 3 year contract.)
Mubarak Wakaso from Rubin Kazan to Celtic. ( 3 year contract.)
Timothy Derijck from PSV Eindhoven to ADO Den Haag. ( 2 year contract.)
Quincy Owusu-Abeyie from Free Transfer to Boavista.
Kirill Kombarov from Spartak Moscow to Torpedo Moscow. ( On loan to the end of the season.)
Filip Holosko from Besiktas to Rizespor. (On loan to the end of the season.)
Ivan Carril from Olympiacos Volos to Hospitalet.
Artur Miranyan from Shakhtar Donetsk to Vardar.
 
Being well-ahead in development doesn't mean he's more talented.

Bale didn't deserve to have 186 PA when he was still playing at left back, but looking at him now, I highly doubt Sterling will ever get to that level. He doesn't have the power or the ball striking technique & I doubt he ever will, just a very good, clean speed & dribbling game which only really warrants about 176 PA; around the Di Maria/Reus level. His stats will still be very good on FM, just not as good as Robben or Ribery & that's how it should be unless he starts showing signs he can do amazing stuff like this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oN5AL6cdza8

What do you mean "He doesn't have the power or the ball striking technique & I doubt he ever will"
he does have that now actually mate
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hzn6hgK1xgE
 
idk if you seen this one, but allione from velez in now on palmeiras in brazil
 
By that logic, no players under 20 would have a fixed PA of 170+, and thats ridiculous

No it's not. This is one of the problems with PA values in the editor; it's impossible to objectively argue why any teenager deserves 180+ PA or -10.

There should be more random variables for instances like these. EG: X=150-190.

In Sterling's case, whilst I would give him 175 in the current system (which I'm going to do in my personally modified version of this update), a random variable ranging from 169-185 would be more appropriate.
What do you mean "He doesn't have the power or the ball striking technique & I doubt he ever will"
he does have that now actually mate
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hzn6hgK1xgE

I've seen the videos, you're kidding yourself if you think he's got Robben's power & ball striking.
 
Last edited:
Steven Naismith's finishing should really be higher. Most Everton fans agree that he's probably the best one-on-one finisher at the club.
 
Transfers:
Kristoffer Peterson from Liverpool to FC Utrech. ( 4 year contract.)
Nenad Milijas from Red Star to Manisaspor. ( 2 year contract.)
Lukasz Teodorczyk from Lech Poznan to Dynamo Kiev. ( 5 year contract.)
Roberto from Tosno to Arouca. ( 3 year contract.)
Mubarak Wakaso from Rubin Kazan to Celtic. ( 3 year contract.)
Timothy Derijck from PSV Eindhoven to ADO Den Haag. ( 2 year contract.)
Quincy Owusu-Abeyie from Free Transfer to Boavista.
Kirill Kombarov from Spartak Moscow to Torpedo Moscow. ( On loan to the end of the season.)
Filip Holosko from Besiktas to Rizespor. (On loan to the end of the season.)
Ivan Carril from Olympiacos Volos to Hospitalet.
Artur Miranyan from Shakhtar Donetsk to Vardar.
yep
idk if you seen this one, but allione from velez in now on palmeiras in brazil
okay
No it's not. This is one of the problems with PA values in the editor; it's impossible to objectively argue why any teenager deserves 180+ PA or -10.

There should be more random variables for instances like these. EG: X=150-190.

In Sterling's case, whilst I would give him 175 in the current system (which I'm going to do in my personally modified version of this update), a random variable ranging from 169-185 would be more appropriate.


I've seen the videos, you're kidding yourself if you think he's got Robben's power & ball striking.
I do agree the potentials could be a little closer together instead of so varied like they are now with the minus'
Steven Naismith's finishing should really be higher. Most Everton fans agree that he's probably the best one-on-one finisher at the club.

agreed
 
About Angel Correa, he does the training and recovery with Atletico, i think he must be in that team
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top