My scouts rarely get it right with potential world class players. On my game he has PA of 150 and is still one of the best midfielders in the game(cm slot, advanced playmaker/attack). Maybe it has something to do with where he is playing atm, he starts out in the second or third league in Italy(am I correct??) so theoretically it is a lot easier for him to shine there and the scouts could simply be cautious when rating him. Usually when I sign a young player my staff starts to rate him a lot higher.