the whole thing is real players have attributes based off their real performances, so unless someone is near or has the potential to be perfect for a particle position in real life they likely wont be as good as one of the thousands of randomly generated players that come into the game each year. **** I got a regen once that at age 15 had 8 attributes over 15 (finishing, technique, off the ball, determination, work rate, teamwork, natural fitness, strength) and literally got first team time in Ligue 1 by the time he was 16. The likely hood of a regen having perfect stats for a particular position goes to unity after a year or two in game. Based off their PA regens get random attributes for their prefered positions, its a dice roll but sometimes it works perfectly and players have amazing attributes for the position they want to play, by 3 or 4 seasons into the game I rarely have more than half of my team consisting of real players.