Tactic Premier League 16.2 (Testers Welcome)

[Ethan88]

[TD="class: et6, width: 59"]14.17[/TD]
[/TR]
[/TABLE]

Would you mind testing Ballista?
http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/share-download-fm-16-tactics/352631-ballista-16-2-a.html

I'm getting better results with it than JABDEF, and I can't tell if it's really better or just fm randomness.

 

[zyndar]

You guys do realise that if you play in the FM Touch mode it pretty much has tactical familiarity at max etc and you get a great idea of how a tactic works. I don't test mine in the game etc as too many factors can influence it, whereas in the streamlined version of the game all you have to worry about is morale and fitness.

I agree with you Chrissy. In addition I do not think that OI's are meaning too much this year.

 

[crusho79]

I agree with you Chrissy. In addition I do not think that OI's are meaning too much this year.

To be honest, i get better result without OIs, they get out of position alot when i use them.

 

[bantons]

with only 3 points between both runs of the test it shows how accurate the testing is.

Dont know if it is a mistake or not, but the tactic on top is the same as the one in the bottom?

 

[Will1981]

Dont know if it is a mistake or not, but the tactic on top is the same as the one in the bottom?

yes but not tested by me see if you can see the pattern at the bottom.

 

[bantons]

yes but not tested by me see if you can see the pattern at the bottom.

would it not make the most sence it only you do the testing if you are gonna divide the results up? It is kind of saying you dont trust other testers 100%. This is not meant in a negative way at all just to make it less confusing

 

[Will1981]

would it not make the most sence it only you do the testing if you are gonna divide the results up? It is kind of saying you dont trust other testers 100%. This is not meant in a negative way at all just to make it less confusing

I trust some of them but I have a theory about one of them which I am about 90% sure of which you may see if you look at the pattern.

 

[bantons]

I trust some of them but I have a theory about one of them which I am about 90% sure of which you may see if you look at the pattern.

Why not make a team of those you trust 100% and then only use results from them

 

[pl3rious]

Why not make a team of those you trust 100% and then only use results from them

approved!!

remove amateur tester, you can see clearly the rate/derate pattern
use dedicated tester

note: if you remove amateur tester, expect 1 star rate like FM15

 

[Will1981]

<

TACTIC	TESTED BY	PLD	WON	DRN	LST	FOR	AG	GD	PTS	YEL	RED	GFC	APPG	%GFC
Sir Goalalot - 16.2 - Final v2 (Calamity Corner)	Will1981	60	44	10	6	159	55	104	142	132	5	17	2.37	10.69
MAHLUK v3 (Tweebler Corners V2)	Will1981	120	88	19	13	332	122	210	283	260	4	30	2.36	9.04
JABDEF	Will1981	60	44	8	8	155	45	110	140	119	4	13	2.33	8.39
2233 very fluid attacking	Will1981	60	43	10	7	187	76	111	139	135	9	19	2.32	10.16
FM16.2OXFORD	Will1981	60	42	11	7	152	43	109	137	124	0	21	2.28	13.82
TFF DEVASTATOR V9	Will1981	60	43	8	9	150	45	105	137	112	8	16	2.28	10.67
XMAS TREE FM16	Will1981	60	42	10	8	150	50	100	136	108	1	14	2.27	9.33
calamity's best	Will1981	60	41	10	9	116	43	73	133	122	3	22	2.22	18.97
FM16.24132app	Will1981	60	42	6	12	178	58	120	132	117	4	16	2.20	8.99
Sir Goalalot - 16.2 - Final v2	Will1981	60	40	10	10	133	61	72	130	133	10	7	2.17	5.26
MAHLUK v3	Will1981	60	38	13	9	146	55	91	127	143	7	5	2.12	3.42
V6 Evolution - ChristianEriksen	Will1981	60	38	12	10	123	54	69	126	81	3	15	2.10	12.20
FM16.2The Dam Buster	Will1981	60	39	8	13	135	65	70	125	138	5	14	2.08	10.37
Denial	Will1981	60	37	13	10	124	52	72	124	123	6	14	2.07	11.29
Domination v1	Will1981	60	38	9	13	147	60	87	123	97	1	11	2.05	7.48
The Impregnenator	Will1981	60	37	11	18	166	83	83	122	84	4	11	2.03	6.63
TFF DEVASTATOR V6	Will1981	60	38	8	14	118	55	63	122	122	6	9	2.03	7.63
Suk Sam - vanco	Will1981	60	36	13	11	151	85	66	121	69	4	16	2.02	10.60
FM16.2Knap451	Will1981	60	35	16	9	116	50	66	121	101	2	19	2.02	16.38
Vive La France	Will1981	60	37	9	14	138	65	73	120	74	2	15	2.00	10.87
Devilznight	Will1981	60	37	8	15	120	70	50	119	132	5	15	1.98	12.50
Mahluk Taktik v1	Will1981	60	36	9	15	143	70	73	117	124	4	16	1.95	11.19
Gatling Project update	Will1981	60	34	10	16	147	85	62	112	51	2	14	1.87	9.52
Storm	Will1981	60	33	12	15	144	75	69	111	119	5	17	1.85	11.81
TFF DEVASTATOR V7	Will1981	60	34	8	18	120	65	55	110	111	6	4	1.83	3.33
4-1-1-3-1 2016	Will1981	60	32	13	15	114	60	54	109	26	0	10	1.82	8.77
GLADIATOR - THE 16.2 BATTLE	Will1981	60	33	9	18	105	55	50	108	95	1	11	1.80	10.48
Strikerless 3-4-3-0	Will1981	60	24	11	21	117	122	-5	87	82	1	12	1.45	10.26

 

[DoubleR]

<

TACTIC	TESTED BY	PLD	WON	DRN	LST	FOR	AG	GD	PTS	YEL	RED	GFC	APPG	%GFC
Sir Goalalot - 16.2 - Final v2 (Calamity Corner)	Will1981	60	44	10	6	159	55	104	142	132	5	17	2.37	10.69
MAHLUK v3 (Tweebler Corners V2)	Will1981	120	88	19	13	332	122	210	283	260	4	30	2.36	9.04
JABDEF	Will1981	60	44	8	8	155	45	110	140	119	4	13	2.33	8.39
2233 very fluid attacking	Will1981	60	43	10	7	187	76	111	139	135	9	19	2.32	10.16
FM16.2OXFORD	Will1981	60	42	11	7	152	43	109	137	124	0	21	2.28	13.82
TFF DEVASTATOR V9	Will1981	60	43	8	9	150	45	105	137	112	8	16	2.28	10.67
XMAS TREE FM16	Will1981	60	42	10	8	150	50	100	136	108	1	14	2.27	9.33
calamity's best	Will1981	60	41	10	9	116	43	73	133	122	3	22	2.22	18.97
FM16.24132app	Will1981	60	42	6	12	178	58	120	132	117	4	16	2.20	8.99
Sir Goalalot - 16.2 - Final v2	Will1981	60	40	10	10	133	61	72	130	133	10	7	2.17	5.26
MAHLUK v3	Will1981	60	38	13	9	146	55	91	127	143	7	5	2.12	3.42
V6 Evolution - ChristianEriksen	Will1981	60	38	12	10	123	54	69	126	81	3	15	2.10	12.20
FM16.2The Dam Buster	Will1981	60	39	8	13	135	65	70	125	138	5	14	2.08	10.37
Denial	Will1981	60	37	13	10	124	52	72	124	123	6	14	2.07	11.29
Domination v1	Will1981	60	38	9	13	147	60	87	123	97	1	11	2.05	7.48
The Impregnenator	Will1981	60	37	11	18	166	83	83	122	84	4	11	2.03	6.63
TFF DEVASTATOR V6	Will1981	60	38	8	14	118	55	63	122	122	6	9	2.03	7.63
Suk Sam - vanco	Will1981	60	36	13	11	151	85	66	121	69	4	16	2.02	10.60
FM16.2Knap451	Will1981	60	35	16	9	116	50	66	121	101	2	19	2.02	16.38
Vive La France	Will1981	60	37	9	14	138	65	73	120	74	2	15	2.00	10.87
Devilznight	Will1981	60	37	8	15	120	70	50	119	132	5	15	1.98	12.50
Mahluk Taktik v1	Will1981	60	36	9	15	143	70	73	117	124	4	16	1.95	11.19
Gatling Project update	Will1981	60	34	10	16	147	85	62	112	51	2	14	1.87	9.52
Storm	Will1981	60	33	12	15	144	75	69	111	119	5	17	1.85	11.81
TFF DEVASTATOR V7	Will1981	60	34	8	18	120	65	55	110	111	6	4	1.83	3.33
4-1-1-3-1 2016	Will1981	60	32	13	15	114	60	54	109	26	0	10	1.82	8.77
GLADIATOR - THE 16.2 BATTLE	Will1981	60	33	9	18	105	55	50	108	95	1	11	1.80	10.48
Strikerless 3-4-3-0	Will1981	60	24	11	21	117	122	-5	87	82	1	12	1.45	10.26

Now its a table we can trust way to go will!

 

[bantons]

TACTIC	TESTED BY	PLD	WON	DRN	LST	FOR	AG	GD	PTS	YEL	RED	GFC	APPG	%GFC
Sir Goalalot - 16.2 - Final v2 (Calamity Corner)		60	44	7	9	142	41	101	139	133	5	19	2.32	7,47

I know my results wont be used in the chart but still very close to your test Will. Seems like a really decent tactic! 31 clean sheets!! I would actually like if you would add Clean sheets, conceded from corner, conceded from IFKs as it also tell a lot about the tactic

 

[Deleted member 91052]

Minor update on The Dam Busters tactic

 

[bantons]

Minor update on The Dam Busters tactic

Hey man, I think you made the same mistake I did and got the database from the OP.
You need to get the save from post 2 so it will have the same schedule as Will is tesing for all tactics to get a more fair result

 

[bantons]

TACTIC	TESTED BY	PLD	WON	DRN	LST	FOR	AG	GD	PTS	YEL	RED	GFC	APPG	%GFC
		60	45	10	5	157	54	103	145	98	6	10	2.42	6,37

Will, would you be so kind to confirm the results I got? If you get the same kind of results I will make a thread

 

[galego25]

Will, would you be so kind to confirm the results I got? If you get the same kind of results I will make a thread

Lots of wide diamond tactics appearing lately, never saw that in other versions. It seems that this formation is strong in this patch.

 

[Will1981]

<

TACTIC	TESTED BY	PLD	WON	DRN	LST	FOR	AG	GD	PTS	YEL	RED	GFC	APPG	%GFC
Sir Goalalot - 16.2 - Final v2 (Calamity Corner)	Will1981	60	44	10	6	159	55	104	142	132	5	17	2.37	10.69
MAHLUK v3 (Tweebler Corners V2)	Will1981	120	88	19	13	332	122	210	283	260	4	30	2.36	9.04
JABDEF	Will1981	60	44	8	8	155	45	110	140	119	4	13	2.33	8.39
2233 very fluid attacking	Will1981	60	43	10	7	187	76	111	139	135	9	19	2.32	10.16
FM16.2OXFORD	Will1981	60	42	11	7	152	43	109	137	124	0	21	2.28	13.82
TFF DEVASTATOR V9	Will1981	60	43	8	9	150	45	105	137	112	8	16	2.28	10.67
XMAS TREE FM16	Will1981	60	42	10	8	150	50	100	136	108	1	14	2.27	9.33
calamity's best	Will1981	60	41	10	9	116	43	73	133	122	3	22	2.22	18.97
FM16.24132app	Will1981	60	42	6	12	178	58	120	132	117	4	16	2.20	8.99
Sir Goalalot - 16.2 - Final v2	Will1981	60	40	10	10	133	61	72	130	133	10	7	2.17	5.26
MAHLUK v3	Will1981	60	38	13	9	146	55	91	127	143	7	5	2.12	3.42
V6 Evolution - ChristianEriksen	Will1981	60	38	12	10	123	54	69	126	81	3	15	2.10	12.20
FM16.2The Dam Buster	Will1981	60	39	8	13	135	65	70	125	138	5	14	2.08	10.37
Denial	Will1981	60	37	13	10	124	52	72	124	123	6	14	2.07	11.29
Domination v1	Will1981	60	38	9	13	147	60	87	123	97	1	11	2.05	7.48
The Impregnenator	Will1981	60	37	11	18	166	83	83	122	84	4	11	2.03	6.63
TFF DEVASTATOR V6	Will1981	60	38	8	14	118	55	63	122	122	6	9	2.03	7.63
Suk Sam - vanco	Will1981	60	36	13	11	151	85	66	121	69	4	16	2.02	10.60
FM16.2Knap451	Will1981	60	35	16	9	116	50	66	121	101	2	19	2.02	16.38
Vive La France	Will1981	60	37	9	14	138	65	73	120	74	2	15	2.00	10.87
Devilznight	Will1981	60	37	8	15	120	70	50	119	132	5	15	1.98	12.50
Mahluk Taktik v1	Will1981	60	36	9	15	143	70	73	117	124	4	16	1.95	11.19
Ballista	Will1981	60	35	11	14	130	79	51	116	94	1	21	1.93	16.15
Gatling Project update	Will1981	60	34	10	16	147	85	62	112	51	2	14	1.87	9.52
Storm	Will1981	60	33	12	15	144	75	69	111	119	5	17	1.85	11.81
TFF DEVASTATOR V7	Will1981	60	34	8	18	120	65	55	110	111	6	4	1.83	3.33
4-1-1-3-1 2016	Will1981	60	32	13	15	114	60	54	109	26	0	10	1.82	8.77
GLADIATOR - THE 16.2 BATTLE	Will1981	60	33	9	18	105	55	50	108	95	1	11	1.80	10.48
Strikerless 3-4-3-0	Will1981	60	24	11	21	117	122	-5	87	82	1	12	1.45	10.26

 

[SilverSpy]

MAHLUK v4 , test please.

 

[Will1981]

MAHLUK v4 , test please.

I have told you I cant download from that dodgy site.

 

[Will1981]

<

TACTIC	TESTED BY	PLD	WON	DRN	LST	FOR	AG	GD	PTS	YEL	RED	GFC	APPG	%GFC
Sir Goalalot - 16.2 - Final v2 (Calamity Corner)	Will1981	60	44	10	6	159	55	104	142	132	5	17	2.37	10.69
MAHLUK v3 (Tweebler Corners V2)	Will1981	120	88	19	13	332	122	210	283	260	4	30	2.36	9.04
JABDEF	Will1981	60	44	8	8	155	45	110	140	119	4	13	2.33	8.39
2233 very fluid attacking	Will1981	60	43	10	7	187	76	111	139	135	9	19	2.32	10.16
FM16.2OXFORD	Will1981	60	42	11	7	152	43	109	137	124	0	21	2.28	13.82
TFF DEVASTATOR V9	Will1981	60	43	8	9	150	45	105	137	112	8	16	2.28	10.67
XMAS TREE FM16	Will1981	60	42	10	8	150	50	100	136	108	1	14	2.27	9.33
calamity's best	Will1981	60	41	10	9	116	43	73	133	122	3	22	2.22	18.97
FM16.24132app	Will1981	60	42	6	12	178	58	120	132	117	4	16	2.20	8.99
Sir Goalalot - 16.2 - Final v2	Will1981	60	40	10	10	133	61	72	130	133	10	7	2.17	5.26
MAHLUK v3	Will1981	60	38	13	9	146	55	91	127	143	7	5	2.12	3.42
V6 Evolution - ChristianEriksen	Will1981	60	38	12	10	123	54	69	126	81	3	15	2.10	12.20
FM16.2The Dam Buster	Will1981	60	39	8	13	135	65	70	125	138	5	14	2.08	10.37
Denial	Will1981	60	37	13	10	124	52	72	124	123	6	14	2.07	11.29
Domination v1	Will1981	60	38	9	13	147	60	87	123	97	1	11	2.05	7.48
The Impregnenator	Will1981	60	37	11	18	166	83	83	122	84	4	11	2.03	6.63
Bantons Diamond	Will1981	60	37	11	12	138	74	64	122	110	7	10	2.03	7.25
TFF DEVASTATOR V6	Will1981	60	38	8	14	118	55	63	122	122	6	9	2.03	7.63
Suk Sam - vanco	Will1981	60	36	13	11	151	85	66	121	69	4	16	2.02	10.60
FM16.2Knap451	Will1981	60	35	16	9	116	50	66	121	101	2	19	2.02	16.38
Vive La France	Will1981	60	37	9	14	138	65	73	120	74	2	15	2.00	10.87
Devilznight	Will1981	60	37	8	15	120	70	50	119	132	5	15	1.98	12.50
Mahluk Taktik v1	Will1981	60	36	9	15	143	70	73	117	124	4	16	1.95	11.19
Ballista	Will1981	60	35	11	14	130	79	51	116	94	1	21	1.93	16.15
Gatling Project update	Will1981	60	34	10	16	147	85	62	112	51	2	14	1.87	9.52
Storm	Will1981	60	33	12	15	144	75	69	111	119	5	17	1.85	11.81
TFF DEVASTATOR V7	Will1981	60	34	8	18	120	65	55	110	111	6	4	1.83	3.33
4-1-1-3-1 2016	Will1981	60	32	13	15	114	60	54	109	26	0	10	1.82	8.77
GLADIATOR - THE 16.2 BATTLE	Will1981	60	33	9	18	105	55	50	108	95	1	11	1.80	10.48
Strikerless 3-4-3-0	Will1981	60	24	11	21	117	122	-5	87	82	1	12	1.45	10.26