Should I remove all tactics tested by their creator from the leaderboard?


  • Total voters
    163
<
TACTICFORMATIONPLDWONDRNLSTFORAGGDPTSYELREDGFCAPPG%GFC
Sir Goalalot - 16.2 - Final v2 (Calamity Corner)4-2-3-1 Wide6044106159551041421325172.3710.69
MAHLUK v3 (Tweebler Corners V2)4-2-3-1 Wide1208819133321222102832604302.369.04
JABDEF4-2-4 Wide604488155451101401194132.338.39
2233 very fluid attacking4-3-3 WB6043107187761111391359192.3210.16
FM16.2OXFORD4-1-2-2-1 DM6042117152431091371240212.2813.82
TFF DEVASTATOR V94-1-4-1 DM604389150451051371128162.2810.67
XMAS TREE FM164.5.16042108150501001361081142.279.33
calamity's best4-1-4-1 DM604110911643731331223222.2218.97
FM16.24132app4-4-1-1 DM Asymmetric AM (CR)6042612178581201321174162.208.99
FM16.2Knap4231Control4-2-3-1 Wide603914715162891311396182.1811.92
TFF DEVASTATOR V114-1-3-1-1 DM604011914051891311132142.1810.00
V1 Fast Counter Beast! (SirGoalalot Twk)4.4.2603914713243891311243152.1811.36
Sir Goalalot - 16.2 - Final v24-2-3-1 Wide6040101013361721301331072.175.26
MAHLUK V44-2-3-1 Wide604081214057831281524112.137.86
MAHLUK v34-2-3-1 Wide60381391465591127143752.123.42
V6 Evolution - ChristianEriksen4-1-2-3 DM Wide603812101235469126813152.1012.20
FM16.2The Dam Buster4-1-4-1 DM Asymmetric AM (CR)603981313565701251385142.0810.37
Diamond Control4-4-2 Diamond Wide603971417191801241312142.078.19
Denial4-3-3 Wide6037131012452721241236142.0711.29
Domination v14-3-3 DM Narrow60389131476087123971112.057.48
The Impregnenator4-1-2-3 DM603711181668383122844112.036.63
Bantons Diamond4-4-2 Diamond Wide6037111213874641221107102.037.25
TFF DEVASTATOR V64-1-3-1-1 DM Asymmetric ST (CR)60388141185563122122692.037.63
Suk Sam - vanco4-3-3 Narrow603613111518566121694162.0210.60
FM16.2Knap4514-1-2-3 DM Wide603516911650661211012192.0216.38
Vive La France4-1-2-3-0 DM WB60379141386573120742152.0010.87
Devilznight4-2-3-1 Wide603781512070501191325151.9812.50
Mahluk Taktik v14-2-3-1 Wide603691514370731171244161.9511.19
Ballista4-4-1-1 DM Asymmetic ST (CL)603511141307951116941211.9316.15
Gatling Project update4-2-3-1 Wide603410161478562112512141.879.52
Storm4-1-2-3-0 DM WB6033121514475691111195171.8511.81
TFF DEVASTATOR V74-1-3-1-1 DM Asymmetric ST (CR)60348181206555110111641.833.33
4-1-1-3-1 20164-1-4-1 DM Asymmetric M (CL)603213151146054109260101.828.77
GLADIATOR - THE 16.2 BATTLE4-1-2-3 DM Wide60339181055550108951111.8010.48
Strikerless 3-4-3-03-4-3-060241121117122-587821121.4510.26
 
<
TACTICFORMATIONPLDWONDRNLSTFORAGGDPTSYELREDGFCAPPG%GFC
Sir Goalalot - 16.2 - Final v2 (Calamity Corner)4-2-3-1 Wide6044106159551041421325172.3710.69
MAHLUK v3 (Tweebler Corners V2)4-2-3-1 Wide1208819133321222102832604302.369.04
JABDEF4-2-4 Wide604488155451101401194132.338.39
2233 very fluid attacking4-3-3 WB6043107187761111391359192.3210.16
FM16.2OXFORD4-1-2-2-1 DM6042117152431091371240212.2813.82
TFF DEVASTATOR V94-1-4-1 DM604389150451051371128162.2810.67
XMAS TREE FM164.5.16042108150501001361081142.279.33
calamity's best4-1-4-1 DM604110911643731331223222.2218.97
FM16.24132app4-4-1-1 DM Asymmetric AM (CR)6042612178581201321174162.208.99
FM16.2Knap4231Control4-2-3-1 Wide603914715162891311396182.1811.92
TFF DEVASTATOR V114-1-3-1-1 DM604011914051891311132142.1810.00
V1 Fast Counter Beast! (SirGoalalot Twk)4.4.2603914713243891311243152.1811.36
Sir Goalalot - 16.2 - Final v24-2-3-1 Wide6040101013361721301331072.175.26
MAHLUK V44-2-3-1 Wide604081214057831281524112.137.86
MAHLUK v34-2-3-1 Wide60381391465591127143752.123.42
V6 Evolution - ChristianEriksen4-1-2-3 DM Wide603812101235469126813152.1012.20
FM16.2The Dam Buster4-1-4-1 DM Asymmetric AM (CR)603981313565701251385142.0810.37
Diamond Control4-4-2 Diamond Wide603971417191801241312142.078.19
Denial4-3-3 Wide6037131012452721241236142.0711.29
Domination v14-3-3 DM Narrow60389131476087123971112.057.48
The Impregnenator4-1-2-3 DM603711181668383122844112.036.63
Bantons Diamond4-4-2 Diamond Wide6037111213874641221107102.037.25
TFF DEVASTATOR V64-1-3-1-1 DM Asymmetric ST (CR)60388141185563122122692.037.63
Suk Sam - vanco4-3-3 Narrow603613111518566121694162.0210.60
FM16.2Knap4514-1-2-3 DM Wide603516911650661211012192.0216.38
Vive La France4-1-2-3-0 DM WB60379141386573120742152.0010.87
Devilznight4-2-3-1 Wide603781512070501191325151.9812.50
Mahluk Taktik v14-2-3-1 Wide603691514370731171244161.9511.19
Sir Goalalot - 16.2 - Final v44-2-3-1 Wide6034151112462621171516101.958.06
Ballista4-4-1-1 DM Asymmetic ST (CL)603511141307951116941211.9316.15
Gatling Project update4-2-3-1 Wide603410161478562112512141.879.52
Storm4-1-2-3-0 DM WB6033121514475691111195171.8511.81
TFF DEVASTATOR V74-1-3-1-1 DM Asymmetric ST (CR)60348181206555110111641.833.33
4-1-1-3-1 20164-1-4-1 DM Asymmetric M (CL)603213151146054109260101.828.77
GLADIATOR - THE 16.2 BATTLE4-1-2-3 DM Wide60339181055550108951111.8010.48
Strikerless 3-4-3-03-4-3-060241121117122-587821121.4510.26
 
@Will1981 hello m8. nice work! thank you for all test..
I want to you test devastator v10! please ;)


and I wanna ask, what is your favourite tactic? which one you use?

(sorry my bad english)
 
Last edited:
Would you like to test this tactic.

I Don't know if anyone has posted this tactic yet, but on SI Games forum is excellent tactic called 1-2-2-3-3 Tweebier plug and play great results. I used it on two saved test games in Holland & France where I started unemployed and I've taken a job with bottom half league club in the second tier of that country between October/December of 2015. And won promotion to the top tier, plus second tier league title in the first season without buying in any new players and just working with one's I have.

It's worth a go at the tactic, there's two tactics: for a strong team use attacking tactic and for a weaker team use control tactic.



Created by Tweebier

1-2-2-3-3 Tweebier plug and play great results
 
Last edited:
Hi Will what has been your favourite tactic you have tested............ it better be my one JABDEF lol
 
sorry really busy is someone wants to do it for me they are very welcome. ive only put a few tactics up over the years. Xavi passing was one pf my best ones, first person to get over 100 passes (think it was FM11)
no I dont think so the author keeps saying he is going to make one though.
 
its in the table as 2233 very fluid attacking
Would you like to test this tactic.

I Don't know if anyone has posted this tactic yet, but on SI Games forum is excellent tactic called 1-2-2-3-3 Tweebier plug and play great results. I used it on two saved test games in Holland & France where I started unemployed and I've taken a job with bottom half league club in the second tier of that country between October/December of 2015. And won promotion to the top tier, plus second tier league title in the first season without buying in any new players and just working with one's I have.

It's worth a go at the tactic, there's two tactics: for a strong team use attacking tactic and for a weaker team use control tactic.



Created by Tweebier

1-2-2-3-3 Tweebier plug and play great results
 
its in the table as 2233 very fluid attacking
I'm currently using the control tactic one, but depends on what team you test the tactic with. Because the control tactic works better on a weaker team. So if you test it a bigger club you probably won't get as good results than if tested it on a small club. And of course it depends on the human manager if he/she is any good as manager on the game and not put it on holiday or instant result to get better results.
 
Last edited:
Hi Will,

are you testing just fm-base tactics ? Or can i send you a tactic to test ?

(sorry for my poor english :/)
no I only test tactics with proven results.

@Will1981 hello m8. nice work! thank you for all test..
I want to you test devastator v10! please ;)


and I wanna ask, what is your favourite tactic? which one you use?

(sorry my bad english)
no I cant test V10 as it is not plug and play and requires specific man marking setting before each game.

Hi Will what has been your favourite tactic you have tested............ it better be my one JABDEF lol
none not played a real save yet.

sorry really busy is someone wants to do it for me they are very welcome. ive only put a few tactics up over the years. Xavi passing was one pf my best ones, first person to get over 100 passes (think it was FM11)
I will put one up for you.
 
New Testing Database

I have removed all the players from the England team and replaced them with 30x english players with a current ability of between 127 and 136.

All players in the test team have had their PPM's removed and their injury proneness set to 1.

England now have a media prediction of 16th out of the 16 teams with title odds of 2000/1.

This test will show which tactic is best for underdogs.

TPL (Underdog)

 
<
TACTICFORMATIONPLDWONDRNLSTFORAGGDPTSYELREDGFC%GFC
Sir Goalalot - 16.2 - Final v2 (Calamity Corner)4-2-3-1 Wide60301317113912210315551311.5
 
New Testing Database

I have removed all the players from the England team and replaced them with 30x english players with a current ability of between 127 and 136.

All players in the test team have had their PPM's removed and their injury proneness set to 1.

England now have a media prediction of 16th out of the 16 teams with title odds of 2000/1.

This test will show which tactic is best for underdogs.

TPL (Underdog)


is that the database download? ive downloaded it and put it in my files but its not showning up.
 
New Testing Database

I have removed all the players from the England team and replaced them with 30x english players with a current ability of between 127 and 136.

All players in the test team have had their PPM's removed and their injury proneness set to 1.

England now have a media prediction of 16th out of the 16 teams with title odds of 2000/1.

This test will show which tactic is best for underdogs.

TPL (Underdog)


That's great! Try Tweebier please.
 
<
TACTICFORMATIONPLDWONDRNLSTFORAGGDPTSYELREDGFC%GFC
Sir Goalalot - 16.2 - Final v2 (Calamity Corner)4-2-3-1 Wide60301317113912210315551311.5
MAHLUK v3 (Tweebler Corners V2)4-2-3-1 Wide602517181119219921409119.9
 
<
TACTICFORMATIONPLDWONDRNLSTFORAGGDPTSYELREDGFC%GFC
Sir Goalalot - 16.2 - Final v2 (Calamity Corner)4-2-3-1 Wide60301317113912210315551311.5
JABDEF4-2-4 Wide6030624111852696132943.6
MAHLUK v3 (Tweebler Corners V2)4-2-3-1 Wide602517181119219921409119.9
 
<
TACTICFORMATIONPLDWONDRNLSTFORAGGDPTSYELREDGFC%GFC
Sir Goalalot - 16.2 - Final v2 (Calamity Corner)4-2-3-1 Wide60301317113912210315551311.5
JABDEF4-2-4 Wide6030624111852696132943.6
2233 very fluid attacking4-3-3 WB602617171521173595161874.6
MAHLUK v3 (Tweebler Corners V2)4-2-3-1 Wide602517181119219921409119.9
 
Top