Should I remove all tactics tested by their creator from the leaderboard?


  • Total voters
    163
are you doing 2233 again?
Storm Re-Tested

I have re-tested Storm as I feel the results looked far too good to be true and it turns out they were.

From now on any tactic tested with results that seem too unrealistic will be re-tested by me and if the final points score has a difference of more than 20 I will replace the test with my own in the leaderboard.


<
TACTICPLDWONDRNLSTFORAGGDPTSYELREDGFC
2233 very fluid attacking6052531503711316196318
FM16.2Knap4516045961353010514417
FM16.24132app60449713533102141511
Domination v160421261545995138117314
Qetesh & Ladly tweak by Tuff 4112260437101364591136124710
Bantons 3 Ts6042991356789135101313
Impregnenator60419101707595132612
Rogers Reborn2603616810242601249947
343 stable v56038913125725312355111
4-2-3-1 for patch 16.260406141156946123112614
TFF DEVASTATOR V66038814118556312212269
GivingItLaldy - DM's high tempo603514111417170119107212
Mahluk Taktik v160369151437073117124416
Gatling Project update60341016147856211251214
Storm603312151447569111119517
 
Storm Re-Tested

I have re-tested Storm as I feel the results looked far too good to be true and it turns out they were.

From now on any tactic tested with results that seem too unrealistic will be re-tested by me and if the final points score has a difference of more than 20 I will replace the test with my own in the leaderboard.

HAHAHAHAHAHA :)

Will, you are naive like 5 years old kid :)

It's obvious for everyone that all results in the table expect those that were tested by you are fake… people just saved and loaded matches to put their tactics or tactics that they like higher in the table…

From now they'll be a bit smarter and not replay too many matches in in order not to look suspicious and have result close to reality when you retest their tactics... :)

As you can see all tactics show very close performance on 60 matches distance and if you replay only 2-3 matches then you can put even a very average tactic on the top place… and that's exactly what people are going to do! :p
 
Last edited:
You could consider having two tabels - one with summited results and one with your own?
Then you can always re-run the best from the summited yourself?! :)
 
<
TACTICPLDWONDRNLSTFORAGGDPTSYELREDGFC
FM16.2Knap4516045961353010514417
FM16.24132app60449713533102141511
2233 very fluid attacking604310718776111139135519
Domination v160421261545995138117314
Qetesh & Ladly tweak by Tuff 4112260437101364591136124710
Bantons 3 Ts6042991356789135101313
Impregnenator60419101707595132612
Rogers Reborn2603616810242601249947
343 stable v56038913125725312355111
4-2-3-1 for patch 16.260406141156946123112614
TFF DEVASTATOR V66038814118556312212269
GivingItLaldy - DM's high tempo603514111417170119107212
Mahluk Taktik v160369151437073117124416
Gatling Project update60341016147856211251214
Storm603312151447569111119517
 
You could consider having two tabels - one with summited results and one with your own?
Then you can always re-run the best from the summited yourself?! :)

added a tested by column in leaderboard:
<
TACTICTESTED BYPLDWONDRNLSTFORAGGDPTSYELREDGFC
FM16.2Knap451Knap6045961353010514417
FM16.24132appKnap60449713533102141511
2233 very fluid attackingWill1981604310718776111139135519
Domination v1Eth0160421261545995138117314
Qetesh & Ladly tweak by Tuff 41122tuffboy60437101364591136124710
Bantons 3 Tsbantons6042991356789135101313
ImpregnenatorLillen8160419101707595132612
Rogers Reborn2tuffboy603616810242601249947
343 stable v5Raid on6038913125725312355111
4-2-3-1 for patch 16.2tuffboy60406141156946123112614
TFF DEVASTATOR V6Will19816038814118556312212269
GivingItLaldy - DM's high tempotuffboy603514111417170119107212
Mahluk Taktik v1Will198160369151437073117124416
Gatling Project updateWill198160341016147856211251214
StormWill1981603312151447569111119517
 
I think there is a screen with the number of saves for a game, so just show a screenshot of that as well as results.
 
I think there is a screen with the number of saves for a game, so just show a screenshot of that as well as results.
yes this one but I am not sure that if someone has used FMRTE it will show on here.
 
yes this one but I am not sure that if someone has used FMRTE it will show on here.
If u want, i can test again all tatics that i have tested, with that screenshot in the finale of each season, but i only can do this after midnight
 
yes this one but I am not sure that if someone has used FMRTE it will show on here.

Hehe... of course, it won't show that you used FMRTE :p and you can just by one click boost the attributes and morale of your players... :)

Btw, anyway you don't have to replay every match just few of matches because on the 60 matches distance all tactics show very similar performance... and if you replay just 3-4 matches then it'll be enough to put any average tactic at the top of table. :)
 
If u want, i can test again all tatics that i have tested, with that screenshot in the finale of each season, but i only can do this after midnight
no your ok mate, I have no issues with your tests the only 2 I had issues with have been re-tested.
 
no your ok mate, I have no issues with your tests the only 2 I had issues with have been re-tested.
Ok mate tonight i will test more tatics and post :) is some way to add u on steam or something else, just to know what tatic are u testing or u want to test ? just to both os us dont test same tatics and "lose" our time
 
Ok mate tonight i will test more tatics and post :) is some way to add u on steam or something else, just to know what tatic are u testing or u want to test ? just to both os us dont test same tatics and "lose" our time
I dont mind if we both test the same tactic's as I will add them both to the leaderboard as it will be interesting to see how much randomness there is in the test.
 
no your ok mate, I have no issues with your tests the only 2 I had issues with have been re-tested.

Heh... I re-tested Knap's 451 and by some mysterious way got much worse result than he posted… ;)

Ohh… I'm sure that it's just randomness and he didn't replay matches to get slightly better results for his tactics... but I can't understand why the similar happens when I re-test other tactics that were tested by their authors from the table? :p

That's a big mystery! :p

View attachment 197816View attachment 197814View attachment 197813View attachment 197815
 
Last edited:
I dont mind if we both test the same tactic's as I will add them both to the leaderboard as it will be interesting to see how much randomness there is in the test.
ok :) so tonight i thonk i am gonna try devastator v7 and maluk v3...and i will see waht knap tatics have been tested...and if some tatic of his thread wasnt tested i will test too
 
Top