Tactic Testing League v1

Will1981 · Nov 27, 2022

I am thinking something like this

Tripoligate4 · Nov 27, 2022

i suggest not apply to many testing leagues coz all ur effords will die out...decide to keep one

test out which u think is most accurate results (more stable)

veselyus · Nov 28, 2022

642 Total Points. Btw I deleted 3 files.

vujevic · Nov 28, 2022

657 points 3 at back

I hope today I will release it!

Will1981 · Nov 28, 2022

New Testing League nearly ready

storer_ace99 · Nov 28, 2022

Mr Hough83 said:
Good evening everyone, I have my own Test league consisting of 16 of the best teams in club football, I generally test the tactics 3 times to get a good range of where they are and cuts out any RnG that can happen. I seen this and wanted to test the best tactic i have tested so far on it to see if there's much difference.

The best tactic i have tested so far on this years FM is one of Knaps ME23.0.0.0BEOWULFKnap424IFDMP101FACC

i tested in this scenario and this is the Result i got with the above tactic.

Played: 360
Won: 204
Drawn: 61
Lost: 95
For: 963
Against: 654
Gd: 309
Tot Pts: 673

Not to shabby - I wanted to point out as well that the Prometheus Tactic that has been tested in this Scenario already is the second best tactic tested in my league and the difference is 4 points in that league where in this one the difference is 11 Points so pretty close and it proves to me that Both Tactic testing scenarios work.

Well done and keep up the good work.

View attachment 606986

Where is it possible to find your testing league please?

Will1981 · Nov 28, 2022

Will1981 updated Tactic Testing League v1 with a new update entry:

Tactic Testing League v2

Although I am more than happy with my "Tactic Testing League v1" there were a couple of minor issues that had been bugging me, the issue with people not removing the fake files that made Germany use real players and a very rare bug with the fixtures where some teams did not complete all 120 games so I have been working on the following:

Tactic Testing League v2

Consists of 26 National teams as follows:

1. Germany (163.1 CA)
2. France (163.0 CA)
3. Brazil (161.5 CA)
4...

Read the rest of this update entry...

Will1981 · Nov 28, 2022

Tactic Testing League v2

Although I am more than happy with my "Tactic Testing League v1" there were a couple of minor issues that had been bugging me, the issue with people not removing the fake files that made Germany use real players and a very rare bug with the fixtures where some teams did not complete all 120 games so I have been working on the following:

Tactic Testing League v2

Consists of 26 National teams as follows:

1. Germany (163.1 CA)
2. France (163.0 CA)
3. Brazil (161.5 CA)
4. England (161.5 CA)
5. Tactic 160 (all players 160 CA & PA)
6. Spain (159.2 CA)
7. Portugal (159.0 CA)
8. Argentina (155.3 CA)
9. Tactic 155 (all players 155 CA & PA)
10. Italy (154.4 CA)
11. Holland (153.5 CA)
12. Belgium (152.3 CA)
13. Tactic 150 (all players 150 CA & PA)
14. Uruguay (147.9 CA)
15. Croatia (147.1 CA)
16. Tactic 145 (all players 145 CA & PA)
17. Colombia (143.6 CA)
18. Serbia (143.0 CA)
19. Poland (141.8 CA)
20. Denmark (141.7 CA)
21. Switzerland (141.1 CA)
22. Mexico (140.7 CA)
23. Tactic 140 (all players 140 CA & PA)
24. Austria (139.8 CA)
25. Norway (139.3 CA)
26. Nigeria (138.9 CA)

CA = Current Ability
PA = Potential Ability
National Teams have been ranked by the average Current Ability of there top 17 players
Germany are using Russia's template so fake files will no longer be an issue.

The teams will play each other 4 times (100 games in total) this has fixed the fixture bug and the games always get played on time.

To make the testing as accurate as humanly possible I have made the following changes:

All injuries have been removed and the chances of any new injuries happening have been reduced by 99.99%.

All loans have been removed

All Bans have been removed and players who get sent off will not be banned for next game

Match condition has been frozen.

Instructions:

Make sure "Tactic Testing League v2" is the only editor data file you have enabled

Start a new game

Select Advanced Setup

Select the Nation "Tactic 145"

Select just the Irish Premier League with a small database. (you will not be using this league it just runs in the background for the game start)

Select the following 5 National Teams to manage, Tactic 160, Tactic 155, Tactic 150, Tactic 145 and Tactic 140.

Save your game and turn off auto save.

Load the tactic you wish to test into all 3 tactic slots on all 5 teams.

Holiday the game until 26.12.22 with all 5 teams making sure you tick the box "use current match tactics".

Post a link to the tactic you tested (only tactics from FM-Base please) on here.

Post the following screenshots Tactic Testing League Stages (the one with total goals scored and conceded) and Best XI's for all 5 teams (see post 2).

I hope this is of use to you as it took a lot of time and effort to create.

PS this is not a tactic testing request thread, I will test a few tactics on here from time to time but it is a very time consuming process and my PC is on its last legs.

Tripoligate4 · Nov 28, 2022

i wanna ask something.... why we should/ u should / add so many teams? i think 3 overal are ok like the 1st post , top /mid / full underdog... whats the meaning of having so many teams? idk the results will be so unconvincing to be realise if u doing good or not..i belive u should change it to 3 again.. imo always

Will1981 · Nov 28, 2022

Tripoligate4 said:
i wanna ask something.... why we should/ u should / add so many teams? i think 3 overal are ok like the 1st post , top /mid / full underdog... whats the meaning of having so many teams? idk the results will be so unconvincing to be realise if u doing good or not..i belive u should change it to 3 again.. imo always

Like I said in the OP this is more of a thread for tools for other people to test tactics, both editor files are available for you to use so if you prefer to use the 1st one you are more than welcome too.

IMO the more games you test a tactic for the better hence the 5 teams x 100 games.

Tripoligate4 · Nov 28, 2022

i agree with the matches..but the teams are totaly different.. anwyay , i cant follow ur thaught , i wil stick with the 1st one.. last year u made so many testing leagues with no reasons while the old ones where super in consistant. and i was always suprised why u made a new one in a couple of hours or so

anyway good work i really liked the one u made

Will1981 · Nov 28, 2022

Tripoligate4 said:
i agree with the matches..but the teams are totaly different.. anwyay , i cant follow ur thaught , i wil stick with the 1st one.. last year u made so many testing leagues with no reasons while the old ones where super in consistant. and i was always suprised why u made a new one in a couple of hours or so
anyway good work i really liked the one u made

I liked the 1st one too but it had the 2 issues I have explained.

Will1981 · Nov 28, 2022

4-3-3 ZdaneK - BEST TACTICS-WORKS IN UNDERDOG - PARIS 13 Atletico. Lots of chances and goals. STROG!

ZdaneK uploaded 4-3-3 ZdaneK - BEST TACTICS-WORKS IN UNDERDOG - PARIS 13 Atletico. Lots of chances and goals. STROG! Leave feedback below.

fm-base.co.uk

Team	PLD	WON	DRN	LST	FOR	AGG	GD.	PTS
Tactic 160	100	67	20	13	265	106	159	221
Tactic 155	100	59	20	21	214	128	86	197
Tactic 150	100	53	21	26	205	142	63	180
Tactic 145	100	41	19	40	179	162	17	142
Tactic 140	100	35	17	48	147	177	-30	122
Total.	500	255	97	148	1010	715	295	862

DeviAngel · Nov 28, 2022

Will1981 said:
4-3-3 ZdaneK - BEST TACTICS-WORKS IN UNDERDOG - PARIS 13 Atletico. Lots of chances and goals. STROG!

ZdaneK uploaded 4-3-3 ZdaneK - BEST TACTICS-WORKS IN UNDERDOG - PARIS 13 Atletico. Lots of chances and goals. STROG! Leave feedback below.

fm-base.co.uk

Team PLD WON DRN LST FOR AGG GD. PTS
Tactic 160
100
67
20
13
265
106
159
221
Tactic 155
100
59
20
21
214
128
86
197
Tactic 150
100
53
21
26
205
142
63
180
Tactic 145
100
41
19
40
179
162
17
142
Tactic 140
100
35
17
48
147
177
-30
122
Total.
500
255
97
148
1010
715
295
862

Which tactics is Tactic 160 ?

Will1981 · Nov 28, 2022

DeviAngel said:
Which tactics is Tactic 160 ?

all 5 teams used 4-3-3 ZdaneK v1

Fake12397 · Nov 28, 2022

@Will1981 Can u try Corsair IF, please??

Sigismund · Nov 28, 2022

My result:

Team	PLD	WON	DRN	LST	FOR	AGG	GD	PTS
Tactic 160	100	73	13	14	340	154	186	232
Tactic 155	100	55	18	27	256	163	93	183
Tactic 150	100	58	17	25	248	165	83	191
Tactic 145	100	49	23	28	258	183	75	173
Tactic 140	100	31	24	45	200	226	-26	117
Total	500	266	95	139	1302	891	411	896

Will1981 · Nov 28, 2022

Almost Perfect 4-1-2-1-2

Matthew777blue uploaded Almost Perfect 4-1-2-1-2 Leave feedback below.

fm-base.co.uk

Team	PLD	WON	DRN	LST	FOR	AGG	GD.	PTS
Tactic 160	100	62	17	21	257	157	100	203
Tactic 155	100	38	20	42	178	183	-5	134
Tactic 150	100	40	23	37	200	181	19	143
Tactic 145	100	32	22	46	166	213	-47	118
Tactic 140	100	21	15	64	144	253	-109	78
Total.	500	193	97	210	945	987	-42	676

Will1981 · Nov 28, 2022

TACTIC	TESTED BY	LINK	PLD	WON	DRN	LST	FOR	AGG	GD>	PTS
VOLANTE 4222	Sigismund	#79	500	266	95	139	1302	891	411	896
4-3-3 ZdaneK v1	Will	#75	500	255	97	148	1010	715	295	862
ALBATROSS	Will	#80	500	193	97	210	945	987	-42	676

FMR · Nov 29, 2022

firstly, tactic testing is more enjoyable than playing the game
Seondly can someone link the V2 testing

Tactic Testing League v1

Member

Attachments

Member

Member

Attachments

Member

Attachments

Member

Attachments

Member

Member

Member

Attachments

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Attachments

Member

Member

Member

Member

Attachments

Member

Attachments

Member

Member

FMBase

Beta

Resources