Tactic Testing League v1

nubbe · Dec 6, 2022

Will1981 said:
Who is the best AI manager on FM23?

All teams have identical squads.

Lmao that's a fun test. Looking forward to the results!

Have you tried the 4-3-3 haaland no wingers from brokensjnf8ewhce8.com?

Will1981 · Dec 6, 2022

Round 1 - Results

PS not one of the managers were sacked during the season, I had to replace Ferguson with Lopetegui as he would retire mid season.

MANAGER	ROUND 1
SARRI	172
PIOLI	168
LOPETEGUI	163
FAVRE	160
GERETS	154
DESCHAMPS	149
ANCELOTTI	149
RODGERS	143
SIMEONE	142
VALVERDE	141
TEN HAG	139
ZIDANE	139
SANTOS	139
INZAGHI	136
NAGELSMANN	134
POCHETTINO	129
BIELSA	126
BENITEZ	124
MANCINI	122
GUARDIOLA	121
LUIS ENRIQUE	121
MOURINHO	121
CONTE	120
KLOPP	118
TUCHEL	118
SPALLETTI	108

Will1981 · Dec 6, 2022

Round 2 - Results

MANAGER	ROUND 1	ROUND 2	TOTAL
GERETS	154	168	322
SARRI	172	146	318
FAVRE	160	156	316
DESCHAMPS	149	165	314
PIOLI	168	137	305
LOPETEGUI	163	132	295
SIMEONE	142	146	288
TEN HAG	139	148	287
ZIDANE	139	148	287
ANCELOTTI	149	137	286
RODGERS	143	136	279
SANTOS	139	139	278
VALVERDE	141	130	271
POCHETTINO	129	142	271
BENITEZ	124	146	270
GUARDIOLA	121	148	269
NAGELSMANN	134	131	265
KLOPP	118	143	261
INZAGHI	136	123	259
LUIS ENRIQUE	121	133	254
CONTE	120	127	247
MANCINI	122	124	246
BIELSA	126	110	236
MOURINHO	121	109	230
TUCHEL	118	103	221
SPALLETTI	108	110	218

Will1981 · Dec 6, 2022

Round 3 - Results

MANAGER	ROUND 1	ROUND 2	ROUND 3	TOTAL
FAVRE	160	156	171	487
GERETS	154	168	137	459
PIOLI	168	137	143	448
SANTOS	139	139	161	439
DESCHAMPS	149	165	124	438
SARRI	172	146	118	436
ZIDANE	139	148	142	429
SIMEONE	142	146	140	428
TEN HAG	139	148	135	422
LOPETEGUI	163	132	126	421
ANCELOTTI	149	137	126	412
BENITEZ	124	146	142	412
VALVERDE	141	130	139	410
POCHETTINO	129	142	136	407
NAGELSMANN	134	131	142	407
LUIS ENRIQUE	121	133	152	406
GUARDIOLA	121	148	136	405
RODGERS	143	136	118	397
KLOPP	118	143	135	396
INZAGHI	136	123	132	391
MANCINI	122	124	143	389
CONTE	120	127	127	374
BIELSA	126	110	137	373
MOURINHO	121	109	129	359
SPALLETTI	108	110	130	348
TUCHEL	118	103	120	341

Will1981 · Dec 6, 2022

Round 4 - Results

MANAGER	ROUND 1	ROUND 2	ROUND 3	ROUND 4	TOTAL
GERETS	154	168	137	168	627
PIOLI	168	137	143	157	605
FAVRE	160	156	171	113	600
DESCHAMPS	149	165	124	150	588
SANTOS	139	139	161	137	576
ZIDANE	139	148	142	146	575
LOPETEGUI	163	132	126	154	575
SARRI	172	146	118	133	569
SIMEONE	142	146	140	141	569
KLOPP	118	143	135	171	567
LUIS ENRIQUE	121	133	152	153	559
VALVERDE	141	130	139	138	548
NAGELSMANN	134	131	142	136	543
TEN HAG	139	148	135	120	542
GUARDIOLA	121	148	136	132	537
BENITEZ	124	146	142	122	534
ANCELOTTI	149	137	126	115	527
POCHETTINO	129	142	136	120	527
RODGERS	143	136	118	130	527
INZAGHI	136	123	132	134	525
MANCINI	122	124	143	132	521
BIELSA	126	110	137	132	505
CONTE	120	127	127	124	498
MOURINHO	121	109	129	138	497
SPALLETTI	108	110	130	136	484
TUCHEL	118	103	120	137	478

Will1981 · Dec 6, 2022

Round 5 - Results

MANAGER	ROUND 1	ROUND 2	ROUND 3	ROUND 4	ROUND 5	TOTAL
GERETS	154	168	137	168	134	761
PIOLI	168	137	143	157	156	761
FAVRE	160	156	171	113	144	744
ZIDANE	139	148	142	146	157	732
LOPETEGUI	163	132	126	154	138	713
NAGELSMANN	134	131	142	136	169	712
KLOPP	118	143	135	171	141	708
DESCHAMPS	149	165	124	150	117	705
SIMEONE	142	146	140	141	134	703
SANTOS	139	139	161	137	124	700
SARRI	172	146	118	133	128	697
LUIS ENRIQUE	121	133	152	153	138	697
TEN HAG	139	148	135	120	153	695
VALVERDE	141	130	139	138	142	690
POCHETTINO	129	142	136	120	152	679
RODGERS	143	136	118	130	144	671
BENITEZ	124	146	142	122	136	670
ANCELOTTI	149	137	126	115	142	669
MANCINI	122	124	143	132	144	665
GUARDIOLA	121	148	136	132	122	659
INZAGHI	136	123	132	134	130	655
SPALLETTI	108	110	130	136	135	619
BIELSA	126	110	137	132	109	614
CONTE	120	127	127	124	111	609
TUCHEL	118	103	120	137	129	607
MOURINHO	121	109	129	138	105	602

Will1981 · Dec 6, 2022

Round 6 - Results

MANAGER	R1	R2	R3	R4	R5	R6	TOTAL
PIOLI	168	137	143	157	156	159	920
GERETS	154	168	137	168	134	156	917
FAVRE	160	156	171	113	144	147	891
ZIDANE	139	148	142	146	157	144	876
VALVERDE	141	130	139	138	142	175	865
LOPETEGUI	163	132	126	154	138	141	854
SARRI	172	146	118	133	128	146	843
NAGELSMANN	134	131	142	136	169	130	842
DESCHAMPS	149	165	124	150	117	136	841
KLOPP	118	143	135	171	141	132	840
SIMEONE	142	146	140	141	134	128	831
SANTOS	139	139	161	137	124	131	831
RODGERS	143	136	118	130	144	159	830
LUIS ENRIQUE	121	133	152	153	138	123	820
ANCELOTTI	149	137	126	115	142	144	813
BENITEZ	124	146	142	122	136	137	807
TEN HAG	139	148	135	120	153	106	801
GUARDIOLA	121	148	136	132	122	137	796
POCHETTINO	129	142	136	120	152	112	791
MANCINI	122	124	143	132	144	105	770
INZAGHI	136	123	132	134	130	114	769
SPALLETTI	108	110	130	136	135	139	758
CONTE	120	127	127	124	111	148	757
BIELSA	126	110	137	132	109	142	756
MOURINHO	121	109	129	138	105	129	731
TUCHEL	118	103	120	137	129	113	720

Will1981 · Dec 6, 2022

Round 7 - Results

MANAGER	R1	R2	R3	R4	R5	R6	R7	TOTAL
PIOLI	168	137	143	157	156	159	147	1067
GERETS	154	168	137	168	134	156	116	1033
FAVRE	160	156	171	113	144	147	120	1011
ZIDANE	139	148	142	146	157	144	122	998
SARRI	172	146	118	133	128	146	144	987
SIMEONE	142	146	140	141	134	128	152	983
DESCHAMPS	149	165	124	150	117	136	140	981
KLOPP	118	143	135	171	141	132	140	980
LOPETEGUI	163	132	126	154	138	141	125	979
VALVERDE	141	130	139	138	142	175	105	970
NAGELSMANN	134	131	142	136	169	130	124	966
RODGERS	143	136	118	130	144	159	135	965
SANTOS	139	139	161	137	124	131	133	964
LUIS ENRIQUE	121	133	152	153	138	123	143	963
ANCELOTTI	149	137	126	115	142	144	143	956
GUARDIOLA	121	148	136	132	122	137	143	939
BENITEZ	124	146	142	122	136	137	128	935
TEN HAG	139	148	135	120	153	106	131	932
POCHETTINO	129	142	136	120	152	112	129	920
MANCINI	122	124	143	132	144	105	143	913
SPALLETTI	108	110	130	136	135	139	145	903
INZAGHI	136	123	132	134	130	114	126	895
BIELSA	126	110	137	132	109	142	134	890
CONTE	120	127	127	124	111	148	125	882
TUCHEL	118	103	120	137	129	113	140	860
MOURINHO	121	109	129	138	105	129	128	859

Will1981 · Dec 6, 2022

Round 8 - Results

MANAGER	R1	R2	R3	R4	R5	R6	R7	R8	TOTAL
PIOLI	168	137	143	157	156	159	147	141	1208
GERETS	154	168	137	168	134	156	116	160	1193
FAVRE	160	156	171	113	144	147	120	144	1155
SIMEONE	142	146	140	141	134	128	152	152	1135
ZIDANE	139	148	142	146	157	144	122	136	1134
ANCELOTTI	149	137	126	115	142	144	143	169	1125
KLOPP	118	143	135	171	141	132	140	144	1124
SANTOS	139	139	161	137	124	131	133	151	1115
LOPETEGUI	163	132	126	154	138	141	125	134	1113
DESCHAMPS	149	165	124	150	117	136	140	129	1110
SARRI	172	146	118	133	128	146	144	119	1106
LUIS ENRIQUE	121	133	152	153	138	123	143	136	1099
NAGELSMANN	134	131	142	136	169	130	124	129	1095
TEN HAG	139	148	135	120	153	106	131	158	1090
BENITEZ	124	146	142	122	136	137	128	149	1084
VALVERDE	141	130	139	138	142	175	105	114	1084
GUARDIOLA	121	148	136	132	122	137	143	143	1082
RODGERS	143	136	118	130	144	159	135	116	1081
POCHETTINO	129	142	136	120	152	112	129	136	1056
INZAGHI	136	123	132	134	130	114	126	142	1037
SPALLETTI	108	110	130	136	135	139	145	133	1036
MANCINI	122	124	143	132	144	105	143	118	1031
CONTE	120	127	127	124	111	148	125	138	1020
BIELSA	126	110	137	132	109	142	134	112	1002
MOURINHO	121	109	129	138	105	129	128	124	983
TUCHEL	118	103	120	137	129	113	140	120	980

norsemenxx · Dec 9, 2022

Deleted

Will1981 · Dec 9, 2022

English Testing League

Will1981 · Dec 9, 2022

casas55 said:
Is it possible to get the exact tactic from the best coach? I mean the positions/roles/instructions

no it is not.

Will1981 · Dec 9, 2022

The Corsair by Chocorelo19

Corsair IF 👉TOP RATED TACTIC

fm-base.co.uk

TACTIC	PLD	WON	DRN	LST	FOR	AG	GD	PTS	YEL	RED	xGF	xGA	xPTS
The Corsair	60	34	6	20	153	116	37	108	170	4	143.1	110.8	96.5

Will1981 · Dec 9, 2022

Colossus by Chocorelo19

Tactical Breakdown Colossus: 4-2-4 NO DMs

fm-base.co.uk

TACTIC	PLD	WON	DRN	LST	FOR	AG	GD	PTS	YEL	RED	xGF	xGA	xPTS
The Corsair	60	34	6	20	153	116	37	108	170	4	143.1	110.8	96.5
Colossus	60	30	11	19	161	121	40	101	163	3	129.7	110.2	92.9

Will1981 · Dec 9, 2022

4-3-3 ZdaneK - BEST TACTICS-WORKS IN UNDERDOG - PARIS 13 Atletico. Lots of chances and goals. STROG!

ZdaneK uploaded 4-3-3 ZdaneK - BEST TACTICS-WORKS IN UNDERDOG - PARIS 13 Atletico. Lots of chances and goals. STROG! Leave feedback below.

fm-base.co.uk

TACTIC	PLD	WON	DRN	LST	FOR	AG	GD	PTS	YEL	RED	xGF	xGA	xPTS
The Corsair	60	34	6	20	153	116	37	108	170	4	143.1	110.8	96.5
Colossus	60	30	11	19	161	121	40	101	163	3	129.7	110.2	92.9
4-3-3 ZdaneK v2	60	21	14	25	109	110	-1	77	169	6	106.6	98.4	87.3

Will1981 · Dec 9, 2022

4222 w/ Volante

Sigismund uploaded 4222 w/ Volante Leave feedback below.

fm-base.co.uk

TACTIC	PLD	WON	DRN	LST	FOR	AG	GD	PTS	YEL	RED	xGF	xGA	xPTS
The Corsair	60	34	6	20	153	116	37	108	170	4	143.1	110.8	96.5
Colossus	60	30	11	19	161	121	40	101	163	3	129.7	110.2	92.9
ULTIMATE 4222	60	28	7	25	151	131	20	91	187	3	143	110.8	98.3
4-3-3 ZdaneK v2	60	21	14	25	109	110	-1	77	169	6	106.6	98.4	87.3

Will1981 · Dec 9, 2022

wold of best tactic (Will1981 Tweak)

I recently tested a Tactic I found here https://fm-base.co.uk/threads/tactics-from-around-the-world.179487/ #76 which was originally from FM Korea, It performed pretty well in my test but on closer inspection of the tactic I noticed it was a...

fm-base.co.uk

TACTIC	PLD	WON	DRN	LST	FOR	AG	GD	PTS	YEL	RED	xGF	xGA	xPTS
The Corsair	60	34	6	20	153	116	37	108	170	4	143.1	110.8	96.5
Colossus	60	30	11	19	161	121	40	101	163	3	129.7	110.2	92.9
wold of best tactic (Will1981)	60	28	14	18	123	97	26	98	172	5	129.9	88.8	103.0
ULTIMATE 4222	60	28	7	25	151	131	20	91	187	3	143	110.8	98.3
4-3-3 ZdaneK v2	60	21	14	25	109	110	-1	77	169	6	106.6	98.4	87.3

FMR · Dec 9, 2022

Which tactic test are we on atm? the save i have is 88 games long

Chandlermou · Dec 9, 2022

FMR said:
Which tactic test are we on atm? the save i have is 88 games long