Tactics Tested *new Patch*

  • Thread starter Thread starter goldenalex
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 106
  • Views Views 38K
Coach Carter said:
You can't test a tactic by holidaying!
Click to expand...

To give each tactic the same chance of proving how good it is, you have to try and find something where as less random factors are included.
When testing a tactic in holiday mode, you take away one important factor -> Human

It's also the quickest way to test a tactic a whole season.


Now i'm going to restart the testing, but sinds the data base i a bit different i'm going to start from scratch.


So if anyone would like to get their tactic tested just let me know in a PM and i'll give it a go.
I'm going to start with my brother's tactic (Duvels from thedugout). Cause i found it a rather good tactic.


Ranking: will be based on points, then Goal difference, then goals made and the shots on target

Waiting list: none so far
When their is no request when the previous tactic is tested, I will go down the list of most downloaded tactics

Now being tested: YA 4-5-1 Duvels v2.3

---------- Post added at 12:46 AM ---------- Previous post was yesterday at 09:40 PM ----------

Well here is the first result, i think it will be a good aiming point for other tactics to come


Tactic: YA 4-5-1 Duvels v2.3

Points: 78,33
Goal Difference: 15,67
Goals for: 72,00
Shots on Target: 223,00
Clean sheets: 18,00

naamloosbx.png
http://img543.imageshack.us/i/naamloosbx.png/

Ranking:
1. YA 4-5-1 Duvels v2.3: 78,33

now being tested: Goals Galore 2011 v5 (koflok)
 
Last edited:
will do first thing tomorrow, i've already started koflok's

and i have to go to work at 10PM and it's already 8PM now :-)

Waiting list: mvp93's who needs wingers


EDIT: as you may have noticed in the results of Duvels tactic, team 3 did a lot worse then the other 2 teams. If this keeps happening i'll drop playing as team 3 and only test with 2 teams, for now all tests will be done with the 3 teams.
All results will be kept, if desided to go to 2 teams, all previous results will be recalculated to the results of team 1 and 2
 
Last edited:
Ok it has been adjusted in the waiting list, you'll be up after koflok
 
Last edited:
I never thaught asking for testing, but I am really courious about this. If you have time, take a look at mine. I believe it's the best tactic I've ever made. You cand post the feedback at my tactic's page or send me a PM, even here. Thanks in advance. :D
 
Tactic tested: Goals Galore v5 (koflok)

Points: 86,00
Goal Difference: 21,67
Goals for: 78,67
Shots on Target: 239,33
Clean sheets: 17,33

http://img839.imageshack.us/i/koflok.png/

Ranking:

1. Goals Galore v5 (koflok) 86,00
2. YA 4-5-1 Duvels v2.3 78,33

Now being tested:

Who needs wingers (mvp93)

Waiting list:

Fluid (Foster13)
Il Devasto (SATOROX)
SebastianRO's tactic
Inside Attack 4-3-3 (eric54)
 
Last edited:
OmegaKnight said:
Tactic tested: Goals Galore v5 (koflok)

Points: 86,00
Goal Difference: 21,67
Goals for: 78,67
Shots on Target: 239,33
Clean sheets: 17,33

http://img839.imageshack.us/i/koflok.png/

Ranking:

1. Goals Galore v5 (koflok) 86,00
2. YA 4-5-1 Duvels v2.3 78,33

Now being tested:

Who needs wingers (mvp93)

Waiting list:

Fluid (Foster13)
Il Devasto (Pearsie)
SebastianRO's tactic
Inside Attack 4-3-3 (eric54)
Click to expand...
omega..."il devasto" is a my tactic ;)
 
Tactic tested: Who needs wingers (mvp93)

Points: 83,67
Goal Difference: 34,00
Goals for: 85,67
Shots on Target: 270,67
Clean sheets: 20,00

http://img831.imageshack.us/i/whoneedswingers.png/

Ranking:

1. Goals Galore v5 (koflok) 86,00
2. Who needs wingers (mvp93) 83,67
3. YA 4-5-1 Duvels v2.3 78,33

Now being tested:

Fluid (Foster13)

Waiting list:

Il Devasto (SATOROX)
SebastianRO's tactic
Inside Attack 4-3-3 (eric54)
 
My tactic did quite well don't you think:P

can i ask how u do your points system
 
mvp93 said:
My tactic did quite well don't you think:P

can i ask how u do your points system
Click to expand...


points are just the average points of the 3 teams.

If points were to be equal the ranking will be based as follows

1. Points
2. Goal difference
3. Goals Scored
4. Shots on Target (the more shots on target the better)
5. Clean sheets ( a good tactic begins with a good defence)

I will always take the average of the 3 teams, so if one does really bad your average will drop fast.
This is for example what happened with Duvel's tactic
 
goldenalex said:
As Will1981 decided to not create a Tactic Fully Tested Thread for the new Patch i thought
i start a new one.

You can find teh old thread here
http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/f103/fm11-tactics-fully-tested-t51408.html

I will be using Will1981s Database additional i added another 2 Teams with Similiar strength to the 1st one.

So in Short i will test the tactic with 3teams with similiar strength over 1 Season in Holiday mode. At the end of the Season i will add up the Results of those Teams and calculate the average .

I hope this way the Result will be more Realistic.
And Feel free to to request your tactic here i will try to test it as soon as possible...
pls link the tactic here if you request it to be tested...

and sorry for my English :P


Current Ranking
ranoj.jpg
86227726.jpg


​
tactics.jpg
Click to expand...
I can't see the ranking picture
 
I think the new ranking made by omegaknight is here
Ranking:

1. Goals Galore v5 (koflok) 86,00
2. Who needs wingers (mvp93) 83,67
3. YA 4-5-1 Duvels v2.3 78,33
 
Waiting list:

Il Devasto (SATOROX)
SebastianRO's tactic
Inside Attack 4-3-3 (eric54)
442deepbothflank (rennomillo)
Great tactic for LLM lovers (rennomillo)


If someone gets in a request befor 'Great tactic for LLM lovers' it will be tested first. This because i don't think it's fair to test 2 tactics of one person back-to-back.
Otherwise people might take advantage and just ask other people to post them here so they can get their tactics tested faster then others.

From now on the minimum number of tactics between 2 tactics of the same person must be 15.
Unless their are no other requests befor i start testing the tactic. (once i start a tactic a finish it and don't restart)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top