Testing Tactic Thread

I think this will be a better test if all player's Consistency attribute is set to 20 otherwise the random factor will be too big especially for Hull City and Southampton. Good job and good luck mate.
 
Howdy namesake! When you have the time, please test Duke's tactic, the park the bus one, I am 99% certain that it will have the best results from all.

TheDuke
http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/shar...0-park-bus-wba-win-epl-solid-performance.html
http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/atta...rk-bus-wba-win-epl-solid-performance-5230.fmf

If you will have more time in the future, it would be great if you could also test 2 more tactics which are tweaks of the Duke.
Pastino Trump's Freedom
http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/shar...ark-bus-wba-win-epl-solid-performance-18.html
http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/atta...edom_c1965316-fa26-49b5-87f2-6a444301c1c3.fmf


Martino Tweak
http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/shar...ark-bus-wba-win-epl-solid-performance-18.html
https://www.mediafire.com/?c64g1aptcd5oet4

Thank you very much! The other testing thread of Mr. L went dead pretty fast, so it's awesome you can do this! And I like your approach better than his, because he was creating a fake environment from scratch, while you just freeze attributes.
 
dginola said:
I think this will be a better test if all player's Consistency attribute is set to 20 otherwise the random factor will be too big especially for Hull City and Southampton. Good job and good luck mate.
Click to expand...

Hi mate,

are you using the pregame editor to create testing leagues? I do, but for some reason, when I finish to create a testing league (removing all but english leagues) and save editor data and trying to create new game it crashes. Anyone else facing the same?
 
dginola said:
I think this will be a better test if all player's Consistency attribute is set to 20 otherwise the random factor will be too big especially for Hull City and Southampton. Good job and good luck mate.
Click to expand...
So far the teams have been pretty consistent. Also, that would remove the FM effect on the tactics. Either way, with or without consistency issues, the 3 seasons method will round it out in the end I think.

Either way, here it is the 343 v3 1st test:
 
Lewisboo said:
Hi mate,

are you using the pregame editor to create testing leagues? I do, but for some reason, when I finish to create a testing league (removing all but english leagues) and save editor data and trying to create new game it crashes. Anyone else facing the same?
Click to expand...

Yes. Your crash is probably due to that you have added something against the game rules, in the editor there is a menu option to verify your changes if you can pass that it should be no problem.
 
dginola said:
Yes. Your crash is probably due to that you have added something against the game rules, in the editor there is a menu option to verify your changes if you can pass that it should be no problem.
Click to expand...

Actually I am always veryfing the changes and it passes there. Weird thing is that I have used MR L's testing league, it was working and I've even modified it without any problem. Now when I start a new game with the same (original) database file from MR L, the game crashes during game setup. As I read over various forums others are facing the same issue but SI don't know the exact answer for this...
 
StefanoPT said:
So far the teams have been pretty consistent. Also, that would remove the FM effect on the tactics. Either way, with or without consistency issues, the 3 seasons method will round it out in the end I think.

Either way, here it is the 343 v3 1st test:
Click to expand...

Most of the Man City players have pretty good Consistency attribute and their CA is too high that it could overcome any tactic's weakness so they will be fine just like what your test shown. Let's see what you got for the lower team.

Anyway, even without changing the Consistency attribute your test will still be very useful, it could identify bad tactics and good tactics but it will not be able to accurately identify the better tactics among the good tactics due to the randomness.
 
Lewisboo said:
Actually I am always veryfing the changes and it passes there. Weird thing is that I have used MR L's testing league, it was working and I've even modified it without any problem. Now when I start a new game with the same (original) database file from MR L, the game crashes during game setup. As I read over various forums others are facing the same issue but SI don't know the exact answer for this...
Click to expand...

That's weird, maybe try with a new FM installation in another PC?
 
Larslunde90 said:
Maybe you can post every test result like this? With the player stats. Its kinda fun to see XD
Click to expand...
I was thinking which version would be the best one, but this way you can't see the goals scored and conceded
 
StefanoPT said:
Sure man! You have to wait on the queue tho
Click to expand...

Do you need me to make an online excel and prepare it so you can add results? So we can easily compare results? You would just need to write in it.

I would also be very interested in CCs per game, corner goals, etc. We can inspire from Mr. L table and just add what he is missing.
 
StefanCP said:
Do you need me to make an online excel and prepare it so you can add results? So we can easily compare results? You would just need to write in it.

I would also be very interested in CCs per game, corner goals, etc. We can inspire from Mr. L table and just add what he is missing.
Click to expand...
Sure! I can upload all the saves as well as well!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Top