clichy isnt underrated, the mistake he is making are schoolboy, mistakes that he shouldnt be making at his age this consistently. Made a mistake against barca tooWould rather a RB than a LB.
Clichy and Gibbs/Pedro Botelho/Traore (unlikely) should all be fine next season. Clichy is underrated - he makes mistakes occasionally but nothing that can't be fixed by harder training and some help from the man in front of him. You have to remember that a lot of the time he's having to deal with both a winger and a full-back without help from Arshavin (see Barcelona game when he did this brilliantly)