Its a tough one, this is my first comment on this by the way.
Glad to have you here ^^. I'm going have to disagree with you on a few things though.
Now onto the subject of Torres. We had one patch in which he scored goals, against Genk and West Ham. West Ham he looked on fire then he got sent off. Since then i personally have not seen him at his best, however against Sunderland he got MoM but didn't carry that over to Carrow Road. Missing an awful chance.
He's not finishing the chances that he gets but to be fair he's not getting many chances. He's taking an average shots of 2.2 shots per game which is alright but a little low considering that he should be the end point of most of our attacks. The real problem is that chances created for him are primarily coming down the flanks, so he's feeding off of a lot of crosses and squared balls where his natural abilities suit through balls and more defence splitting passes. That's why we're slowly shifting to a 4-2-3-1: that gives Torres a natural playmaker just behind, feeding him with the kind of passes he needs. Our current 4-3-3 is great but it has 2 massive problems:
1.There's no diagonal balls, it's all straight forwards, sideways or backwards. United showed at the start of the season exactly what you can do with a fast striker and players that are capable of playing incisive, diagonal passes from deep.
2. We have neither a passer or a creator in it. In the established 4-3-3, the 2 man midfield of the 4-4-2 (creator, destroyer) is expanded with the addition of the passer. There's a lot written about this and I'm not going to bore you if you already know it (if not, just say and I'll post some links) but it's pretty clear that Ramires is more of a shuttler (endless energy, takes care of a lot of the transition between attack and defend) whilst Meireles and Lampard are both box to box types. Whenever you watch us play 4-3-3 there's no staggered line there's no
Creator
------------------------------------------------------------------Creator--------------Passer
.............................Passer-----------------
Instead it's
..........Destroyer------------------------------------------------------------Destroyer
Lampard has said in the past that he's uncomfortable playing in the hole and I've never seen Meireles push up to assume that role. So we end up with this fairly tight little midfield trio and a massive gap between the Striker and the Midfield, with the result being that we're very reliant on our wide men to link up play. Ramires does offer some help in this regard but he's not got the final pass in him to really give Torres enough support. The problem with relying on your wide men was mentioned earlier- Torres needs central support much more than he needs width- but there's another issue with it aswell: we're not actually using proper wide men on either flank atm: Mata is expected to stay forward and fill the AMC slot as well as his own and Sturridge is a wide striker. The vast majority of the pressure for width is therefore placed on the FullBacks, who have both been found wanting this year. Bosingwa is, I believe, not suited to playing a complete FB role, he lacks the discipline and positional awareness to do so but Cole has been taking a lot of flak this year, most of which I think is undeserved because as I mentioned he's being asked to do a huge amount. It's no coincidence that the times where we've worked best this year have been the times in which the DM has fallen back in a CB position, effectively giving us a back 3 with 2 wingbacks, alleviating a lot of the stress on the FBs.
So, the balance of the team is pretty shot because of this fundamental issue with the midfield. With a complete forward like Drogba at the helm, a trio of destroyer, shuttle and box to box would be magic because he has the raw physicality to thrive off the supply from the flanks whilst being able to hold the ball up long enough for the box to box and shuttle to get forward. We don't have the Drogba of 5 years ago though, we have Torres, a predatory striker who excels at working the channels, slipping in through defences, dribbling his man and finishing the chance. If we want him to perform, we either need an AMC or we need a real creator to play in the middle three, someone who will push up the field.
AVB does have a future, but needs to get his tactics finalized and sign a few key players.
Hopefully I've shown why his tactics are a bit haphazard (badum tsh), he's trying to force a round peg into a square hole and until we get the tools for him to work with, he can't do a great deal other than try and hold the two styles together as best as he can until the transition is over. A lot of people have called on him to abandon Torres for a while and focus on results but that's not possible either because the way we got results before can't really be returned to unless Drogba finds some hidden burst of vitality or Lukaku matures instantly (he needs 3/4 years before he can really be excellent imo)
Gotze
Hazard
Cavani
Di Maria
All these players are cup tied for the CL and AVB has, quite rightly, said that whoever we buy has to be able to contribute to the CL campaign. I'd also suggest that we don't need a new first choice striker but a creative midfielder/left winger (although if you go back 15 pages or so, GC makes a good case for playing Sturridge on the left) Hazard/Di Maria on the left, Mata in the Middle or Mata on the left, Gotze in the middle would be awesome but again I can't see it until the summer (I can't see Real let Di Maria go at all tbh)
Someone like Scott Parker or Modric
Parker is more of what we already have. Modric I don't know about, I'd like to say yes but I think the team would be more balanced in a 4-2-3-1 than a 4-3-3 and I think Modric is more suited to playing the slightly deeper creative role of the 4-3-3.