The Deal or No Deal Fm13 thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Raikan007
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 2K
  • Views Views 409K
IMO sell lewandowski and keep cisse and bony up together. Cisse is a goal machine for united at the minute, and it's 2017 for me. He won the top scorer award 2 seasons in a row.

Though as for your question, if you're going to sell one i'd say cisse over bony due to age
 
miroslav3121 said:
Player: Papiss Cisse
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying: Man. City
Offer: 29.5 m. euro
Year: July '14.
Other Info: I have W. Bony and R. Lewandowski
or
Player: W. Bony
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are buying: Bayern M.
Offer: 19.5 m. euro
Year: July '14.
Other Info: and keep Papiss Cisse and R. Lewandowski
Click to expand...

Sell Cisse. It's a better offer for him and I think he's quite a bit older.
 
Player: Gustavo Russo
Team managing: Nottingham Forest
Team buying: Chelsea
Season: Summer 2020
Fee: £23mln
Info: Regen I bought a few years back from Velez from £3mln, Chelsea are offering £23mln upfront
View attachment 327826
 
EternalStan said:
Player: Gustavo Russo
Team managing: Nottingham Forest
Team buying: Chelsea
Season: Summer 2020
Fee: £23mln
Info: Regen I bought a few years back from Velez from £3mln, Chelsea are offering £23mln upfront
View attachment 327826
Click to expand...

It depends if you're in the Championship or Prem. If you're in the Champs, deal, because its better use that money to build a squad that can get into and compete in the top flight. But if you're already in the Premiership, and you're not in need of the cash, then no deal. The player must have a shed load of potential.
 
Gabriel Sutton said:
It depends if you're in the Championship or Prem. If you're in the Champs, deal, because its better use that money to build a squad that can get into and compete in the top flight. But if you're already in the Premiership, and you're not in need of the cash, then no deal. The player must have a shed load of potential.
Click to expand...
He is in the premiership, you can see on the bar on the top of the screenshot :)

And yeah, I agree with Gabriel
 
Gabriel Sutton said:
It depends if you're in the Championship or Prem. If you're in the Champs, deal, because its better use that money to build a squad that can get into and compete in the top flight. But if you're already in the Premiership, and you're not in need of the cash, then no deal. The player must have a shed load of potential.
Click to expand...

Thanks, and yeah, I'm in the Champions League right now :)
 
Yeah, was looking on my phone so didn't see. Only realized straight after I'd posted it! If you're in the Champions League then definitely no deal.
 
Just started a new game with United and sold Valencia, Nani, Anderson and bought Fellaini, Sandro and James Rodriguez and still have 18m left over. I dont really like RVP in game and im thinking about selling him if I did who would be the best replacement? Also the new striker will be playing AF if that helps you decide.

Player: Neymar
Team you are managing: Man Utd
Team who are Selling: Santos
Offer: 61 m pounds
Year: July 13
Other Info: Can keep RVP instead
or

Player: Cavani
Team you are managing: Man Utd
Team who are Selling: Napoli
Offer: 55 m pounds
Year: July 13
Other Info: Can keep RVP instead
or

Player: Lewandowski
Team you are managing: Man Utd
Team who are Selling: Dortmund
Offer: 35-45 m pounds
Year: July 13
Other Info: Can keep RVP instead

My team is currently this
------------- RVP
Rodirguez Rooney Kagawa
Evra Fellaini Sandro Rafael
------ Vidic Ferdinand
----------- De Gea
 
or
Player: Falcao
Team you are managing: Man Utd
Team who are Selling: A Madrid
Offer: 52 m pounds
Year: July 13
Other Info: Can keep RVP instead
 
poweriess said:
Just started a new game with United and sold Valencia, Nani, Anderson and bought Fellaini, Sandro and James Rodriguez and still have 18m left over. I dont really like RVP in game and im thinking about selling him if I did who would be the best replacement? Also the new striker will be playing AF if that helps you decide.

Player: Neymar
Team you are managing: Man Utd
Team who are Selling: Santos
Offer: 61 m pounds
Year: July 13
Other Info: Can keep RVP instead
or

Player: Cavani
Team you are managing: Man Utd
Team who are Selling: Napoli
Offer: 55 m pounds
Year: July 13
Other Info: Can keep RVP instead
or

Player: Lewandowski
Team you are managing: Man Utd
Team who are Selling: Dortmund
Offer: 35-45 m pounds
Year: July 13
Other Info: Can keep RVP instead

My team is currently this
------------- RVP
Rodirguez Rooney Kagawa
Evra Fellaini Sandro Rafael
------ Vidic Ferdinand
----------- De Gea
Click to expand...

poweriess said:
or
Player: Falcao
Team you are managing: Man Utd
Team who are Selling: A Madrid
Offer: 52 m pounds
Year: July 13
Other Info: Can keep RVP instead
Click to expand...

None of them, you are ridiculously over-paying for all of them!
 
poweriess said:
Just started a new game with United and sold Valencia, Nani, Anderson and bought Fellaini, Sandro and James Rodriguez and still have 18m left over. I dont really like RVP in game and im thinking about selling him if I did who would be the best replacement? Also the new striker will be playing AF if that helps you decide.

Player: Neymar
Team you are managing: Man Utd
Team who are Selling: Santos
Offer: 61 m pounds
Year: July 13
Other Info: Can keep RVP instead
or

Player: Cavani
Team you are managing: Man Utd
Team who are Selling: Napoli
Offer: 55 m pounds
Year: July 13
Other Info: Can keep RVP instead
or

Player: Lewandowski
Team you are managing: Man Utd
Team who are Selling: Dortmund
Offer: 35-45 m pounds
Year: July 13
Other Info: Can keep RVP instead

My team is currently this
------------- RVP
Rodirguez Rooney Kagawa
Evra Fellaini Sandro Rafael
------ Vidic Ferdinand
----------- De Gea
Click to expand...

Agree with Scott, it's way too much for all of them. Considering you've got to get out of debt, too many transfers in/out can disrupt the balance of squad and RVP is still a quality striker, I would no deal.
 
Player: Markus Henrikson
Team managing: Wigan
Team selling: AZ
Offer: £6m
Year: August 2013
Other Info: Need an attacking midfielder to replace aging Lampard, was voted young player of year and top assister in Dutch League. Will play Advanced Playmaker behind striker. But heard some bad reviews about him on here.
 
Player: Leandro Paredes
Team you are managing: St. Pauli
Team who are Selling: Boca
Offer: €6 million
Year: July 2014
Other Info: Had him on loan last season and he ripped the Bundesliga to shreds

Or

Player: Tomas Martinez
Team you are managing: St. Pauli
Team who are Selling: River
Offer: €7 million
Year: July 2014
Other Info: Has higher potential than Paredes

I want one of them, I know Paredes will perform because I had him on loan the season prior but Martinez has the higher potential. They're both very similar but Paredes is a threat from set pieces and Martinez is faster and more intelligent.
 
MWEST94 said:
Player: Markus Henrikson
Team managing: Wigan
Team selling: AZ
Offer: £6m
Year: August 2013
Other Info: Need an attacking midfielder to replace aging Lampard, was voted young player of year and top assister in Dutch League. Will play Advanced Playmaker behind striker. But heard some bad reviews about him on here.
Click to expand...

He did okay for my Luton team, but that was in 2017 and he broke his leg after just over a season. Out of interest, how did you manage to get and be able to afford Lampard in 1 season?
 
Player: Charlie Austin. Last season's Premier League top scorer with 28, firing Burnley to 12th in the table after they got promoted (predicted finish 19th). In the two seasons before that in the Championship he scored 23 and 27.
Team managing: Norwich.
Team selling: Burnley, and they ain't. He's in the last month of his contract. He's in negotiations for a new one, but having taken a sneak peek at 'Approach to Sign', I can cut in if I offer to treble his wages to about £50k a week.
Year: June 2015.

Other info: My top priority ATM is a quality striker to replace Grant Holt, and I can get the Premier League's top scorer for free. But he's a poacher who thrives on crosses into the box (I watched six of his goals from three games and every single one was a cross or a corner), I use a 4-2-3-1 and need someone who can operate as a lone frontman. My scout reckons he's merely 'good' and my fear is that it's a gamble assuming he'll be just as effective at a different club. And I've got £20m to spend so I don't exactly need to look for bargains. Thoughts? Anyone noticed how his career tends to go outside Burnley in their own saves?
 
Spleen said:
Player: Charlie Austin. Last season's Premier League top scorer with 28, firing Burnley to 12th in the table after they got promoted (predicted finish 19th). In the two seasons before that in the Championship he scored 23 and 27.
Team managing: Norwich.
Team selling: Burnley, and they ain't. He's in the last month of his contract. He's in negotiations for a new one, but having taken a sneak peek at 'Approach to Sign', I can cut in if I offer to treble his wages to about £50k a week.
Year: June 2015.

Other info: My top priority ATM is a quality striker to replace Grant Holt, and I can get the Premier League's top scorer for free. But he's a poacher who thrives on crosses into the box (I watched six of his goals from three games and every single one was a cross or a corner), I use a 4-2-3-1 and need someone who can operate as a lone frontman. My scout reckons he's merely 'good' and my fear is that it's a gamble assuming he'll be just as effective at a different club. And I've got £20m to spend so I don't exactly need to look for bargains. Thoughts? Anyone noticed how his career tends to go outside Burnley in their own saves?
Click to expand...
Try negotiating his wages to about 40k if you can. I'd say deal since you cant really go wrong with a free agent. Besides, he shouldnt take long to settle since he speaks english. Also, you can always sell at a profit if he doesnt work out.
 
Spleen said:
Player: Charlie Austin. Last season's Premier League top scorer with 28, firing Burnley to 12th in the table after they got promoted (predicted finish 19th). In the two seasons before that in the Championship he scored 23 and 27.
Team managing: Norwich.
Team selling: Burnley, and they ain't. He's in the last month of his contract. He's in negotiations for a new one, but having taken a sneak peek at 'Approach to Sign', I can cut in if I offer to treble his wages to about £50k a week.
Year: June 2015.

Other info: My top priority ATM is a quality striker to replace Grant Holt, and I can get the Premier League's top scorer for free. But he's a poacher who thrives on crosses into the box (I watched six of his goals from three games and every single one was a cross or a corner), I use a 4-2-3-1 and need someone who can operate as a lone frontman. My scout reckons he's merely 'good' and my fear is that it's a gamble assuming he'll be just as effective at a different club. And I've got £20m to spend so I don't exactly need to look for bargains. Thoughts? Anyone noticed how his career tends to go outside Burnley in their own saves?
Click to expand...

As CMH said, he isn't costing you a transfer fee, can be sold for profit in a season if he doesn't fit in well with your team, and he even if he can't cut it playing as you want him to, he can provide a different option if your normal tactic isn't working out, and you want to try playing with a faster striker/2 strikers!

I bought him for Luton in 2015 in my first season in the Championship and he got about 18-20 goals mainly from the bench, as I had a regen who would score 2 every game usually. When I sold the regen before my first season in the prem he did really well until January when I then sold him Sunderland (Who were a top 4 club)
 
Thanks for the advice all - the one thing I would say is that I don't think it's a guaranteed profit if he doesn't work out and I sell him. His estimated value is currently £925k, and in my experience estimated value only goes up if a player is playing and playing well. So if I can't find a place for him, it's unlikely I'll make back in transfer fee what he cost in wages given that he wants £2.5m a year plus bonuses.

I doubt I'll be able to negotiate his wages down to £40k as Sunderland and Stoke are also hovering. The identity of the other clubs who want him is another negative against him in my view >:-).
 
I've just finished my second season with Liverpool. in the summer now and have spent my transfer budget, real Madrid have offered to buy holtby, they offered 12 and I negotiated to 23million. he has been good for me and have a 4&1/2 star rating. but in midfield I already own Gerrard, shelvey, poli, wanyama, thiago, verrati, will hughes and two regens who are 4&5 star rated.

should I sell or not?

so just to clarify;
I am Liverpool
real Madrid want to buy holtby for 23million.
deal.. or no deal.
 
Player:Will Hughes
Team you are managing: Blackburn
Team who are buying : City
Offer: £36million
Year: Jan 2018
Other Info: We are sitting at the top of the prem by 10 points, big money offered but he's awesome and English which is a big factor. I have turned him into a world class CM and he's just bitched at me for asking for 40mill. I could replace with Powell from United at £13mill
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top