10th November 2010 - Agonising penalty defeat for Newcastle
Liverpool 1 - 1 Newcastle (Carling Cup 4th Rnd.)
Newcastle's hopes of lifting the League Cup for the first time in the club's history were shattered for another year by Liverpool in a tightly contested penalty shoot-out.
Talismanic Dutch striker Klaas Jan-Huntelaar gave Hutchinson's team an early lead, taking Distel Zola's perfectly weighted ball in his stride before calmly placing past the outstretched Pepe Reina.
Newcastle dominated after that, creating no less than 5 chances, unfortunately they couldn't finish them.
Then in the 39th minute, after some terrible defending by wing back Drenthe, Liverpool levelled the game through Spanish front man Fernando Torres.
This is how the game stayed until the very last minute.
In the shoot-out both teams scored all five of their initial five spot kicks, however, in sudden death, Magpies skipper Steven Taylor sliced his kick wide, leaving Peter Crouch to score the winner for Liverpool.
Sean Hutchinson said after the match that had his team taken their chances in the first half, they may just have gone on to win the cup that has eluded them for so many years.