I wanted originally to compare Anderson with Scholes, but was informed by a few people (including Mike.) to use Cleverley instead. So I'll be comparing Scholes with Cleverley and Giggs with Welbeck in the final 2 parts. Considered doing Cole/Hernandez comparison but decided against it in the end.
I gave **** a 7/10 for his positioning which is high. Gave Anderson an 8 as he is better positionally offensively as well as defensively. **** was never really known for his offensive play and wasn't the best going forward - but Anderson began as an offensive player and has turned into a more rounded central midfielder, capable of doing both attacking and defending.
Starting to think I should have gone with my initial feeling of comparing Anderson and Scholes as both started their careers as more attacking players but transformed their game for one reason or another into more of a deep playmaker with a knack of scoring a few goals a season, while Cleverley and **** are more box-to-box (not saying they are, but are closer to it than Anderson and Scholes are).
Ah well, what's done is done.