The Manchester United Thread

My team for next year

De Gea

Rafael/Fabio Rio Vidic Evra

Valencia Diarra Modric/Sneijder Young/Nani

Rooney Chicha
Can see either Nani being used to get Sneijder or Berbatov being used to get Modric​
 
He wouldn't be a back-up player. If he's ready to turn down an £80k deal with Villa, then I'm sure the money at United would be over £100k + our #7 shirt; **** that ****. He can **** off to City, Spurs or Pool.

He turned down 80K at Villa doesn't mean he will get that or more than that here. Sometimes players have to take a pay cut if they want to play for big club. He is not in a position to command 100K and #7. He is not a star player. He wont be a back up player either, he will be a squad player as we rotate our squad often, he will get so many games.
 
Why do people want us to sign Diarra? He is not much better than Fletcher. ****, he is worse than Fletcher. Last season's Fletcher plus one creative mid will solve our mid field problems. Not average players like Diarra...
 
Why do people want us to sign Diarra? He is not much better than Fletcher. ****, he is worse than Fletcher. Last season's Fletcher plus one creative mid will solve our mid field problems. Not average players like Diarra...

Diarra is far from average. I don't know about signing him, but you shouldn't be disappointed if you do.
 
Diarra is far from average. I don't know about signing him, but you shouldn't be disappointed if you do.

I will be. We dont want him as we have good enough players than him. All he offers is work rate that Fletcher can do better.
 
I don't think we need to buy a world class destroyer, and Diarra isn't world class anyway. The way we dominate most games, a destroyer isn't really needed. Carrick will continue to sit and patrol the zone between defence and midfield so he adds that protection that the defence needs. It's only the big games that we should play a destroyer, and Fletcher can definitely do the job. It's so disappointing that he has been unavailable for the two finals against Barca, I think he would have made a big difference.

I'm not overly keen on a move for Young, although he is a good, versatile player. I'm just not sure we need another winger, especially with Welbeck coming back, and possibly Cleverly too? I think we need a creative midfielder to fill the void left by Scholes' imminent departure, and I would love to sign Aguero as a replacement for Berbatov. We don't need Diarra imo
 
I think we need an enforcer in the midfield, rather than a destroyer. I know Fletcher is a good player and I like him a lot, but he just doesn't strikes me as an enforcer. He's missing something although I can't tell what it is. Miss the days of Keane.
 
Ginger Prince has called it a day. One of the best midfielder of his generation. It was always joy to watch him pinging those diagonal passes, inch perfect 40 yard passes. Will miss you Scholes. Hope you teach our young lads lesson or two about passing and movement.

Now that Scholes is retired, Hargo released, I think we will surely buy a CM.
 
Ginger Prince has called it a day. One of the best midfielder of his generation. It was always joy to watch him pinging those diagonal passes, inch perfect 40 yard passes. Will miss you Scholes. Hope you teach our young lads lesson or two about passing and movement.

Now that Scholes is retired, Hargo released, I think we will surely buy a CM.

I hope he doesn't teach them the other side to his game...

Great player, and he's right to call it a day. He can still play those long-range passes but other aspects of his game have inevitably deteriorated and unlike Giggs, he can't be sure of a First Team place any more. I expect you'll sign Modric tbh but Sneijder probably has a wider range of passing? And would therefore be the ideal candidate - mixing attacking prowess and the ability to drive on from deep with a range of passing and shooting. Like Scholes, but more technical.
 
I think we need an enforcer in the midfield, rather than a destroyer. I know Fletcher is a good player and I like him a lot, but he just doesn't strikes me as an enforcer. He's missing something although I can't tell what it is. Miss the days of Keane.

My thoughts exactly. Right now your priorities are getting a new Scholes and a new Keane. The new Scholes should be Sneijder or Modric even if they're really expensive. I don't know about the new DM, there aren't any star enforcer DM's out there right now, but I think one of the Diarras (Lass or Alou) or Toulalan or Schweinsteiger would do the trick, at least much better than Carrick and Anderson. Those two along with your new goalkeeper will cost around 80 million ish I think, and other than maybe one or two more cheap players that is plenty for one transfer window.

And btw Valencia is a very good player, don't get me wrong, all I'm saying is that he's not a superstar and if you wanted to be excessive and make a huge signing on top of the other three, I'd go for a winger before a striker.
 
My thoughts exactly. Right now your priorities are getting a new Scholes and a new Keane. The new Scholes should be Sneijder or Modric even if they're really expensive. I don't know about the new DM, there aren't any star enforcer DM's out there right now, but I think one of the Diarras (Lass or Alou) or Toulalan or Schweinsteiger would do the trick, at least much better than Carrick and Anderson. Those two along with your new goalkeeper will cost around 80 million ish I think, and other than maybe one or two more cheap players that is plenty for one transfer window.

And btw Valencia is a very good player, don't get me wrong, all I'm saying is that he's not a superstar and if you wanted to be excessive and make a huge signing on top of the other three, I'd go for a winger before a striker.

thast just it, we dont care about superstars. Valencia does his job brilliantly thats all that matters. IF berbs goes we will bring in a striker. that is how SAF works. Priority is a playmaker and gk, then an enforcer, and it wont be any of those players you keep mentioning either, with the exception of Lass for the right price. It's more likely to be a young up and coming enforcer, thats why we are still looking at Rodwell

There are upto 10 players leaving this summer, we will sign as many as needed
 
thast just it, we dont care about superstars. Valencia does his job brilliantly thats all that matters. IF berbs goes we will bring in a striker. that is how SAF works. Priority is a playmaker and gk, then an enforcer, and it wont be any of those players you keep mentioning either, with the exception of Lass for the right price. It's more likely to be a young up and coming enforcer, thats why we are still looking at Rodwell

There are upto 10 players leaving this summer, we will sign as many as needed

I think you need a LW tbh. Giggs is getting old, Nani is far more effective from the right, Park does his job well but isn't really a winger as much as a defensive forward. Bale/Coentrao (he can play LW too right?) would be ideal IMO. I agree, though that a playmaker and obviously a GK are and should be the priorities. I fully expect Modric to be a Utd player next season since he's a) probably cheaper than Sneijder, and b) probably more willing and c) Utd love Spurs players (Berba, Carrick for exmaple) ... Almost as much as Barcelona love Arsenal's players (Overmars, Petit, Henry, Hleb, Cesc, Afobe, Aneke)
 
I hope he doesn't teach them the other side to his game...

Great player, and he's right to call it a day. He can still play those long-range passes but other aspects of his game have inevitably deteriorated and unlike Giggs, he can't be sure of a First Team place any more. I expect you'll sign Modric tbh but Sneijder probably has a wider range of passing? And would therefore be the ideal candidate - mixing attacking prowess and the ability to drive on from deep with a range of passing and shooting. Like Scholes, but more technical.

Other side of his game was goals. Sad they are dried up since he is playing deeper now.. <)

More technical? I dont think I will agree with that.

Problem with Sneijder is, his fav position is #10, which Rooney is thriving now.. I'm not sure whether Sneijder can play in 2 man midfield. Whereas Modric has done it. Both would be dream signing. I dont think we can get either one..
 
I think you need a LW tbh. Giggs is getting old, Nani is far more effective from the right, Park does his job well but isn't really a winger as much as a defensive forward. Bale/Coentrao (he can play LW too right?) would be ideal IMO. I agree, though that a playmaker and obviously a GK are and should be the priorities. I fully expect Modric to be a Utd player next season since he's a) probably cheaper than Sneijder, and b) probably more willing and c) Utd love Spurs players (Berba, Carrick for exmaple) ... Almost as much as Barcelona love Arsenal's players (Overmars, Petit, Henry, Hleb, Cesc, Afobe, Aneke)

Bale is too one dimensional for his huge fee, at least Park can go in and out would only want one for the right price, plus Cleverley is two footed anyway, and is that kind of winger
 
I think you need a LW tbh. Giggs is getting old, Nani is far more effective from the right, Park does his job well but isn't really a winger as much as a defensive forward. Bale/Coentrao (he can play LW too right?) would be ideal IMO. I agree, though that a playmaker and obviously a GK are and should be the priorities. I fully expect Modric to be a Utd player next season since he's a) probably cheaper than Sneijder, and b) probably more willing and c) Utd love Spurs players (Berba, Carrick for exmaple) ... Almost as much as Barcelona love Arsenal's players (Overmars, Petit, Henry, Hleb, Cesc, Afobe, Aneke)


Nani didn't get extended run of games as LW. When he has started as LW, he drifter to central and right wing position and created chances. I dont want Bale as Nani is more than capable LW and when he starts as LW usually he gets free role.

Bale would cost more than 40 Million. Bastos would be excellent though..
 
No one mentioned Hamsik? He would be a cracking signing and has a good few years ahead of him.
 
Nani didn't get extended run of games as LW. When he has started as LW, he drifter to central and right wing position and created chances. I dont want Bale as Nani is more than capable LW and when he starts as LW usually he gets free role.

Bale would cost more than 40 Million. Bastos would be excellent though..

But that's the point about Nani - he's two footed, but he evidently prefers the RW. If you can get one for the right price I think it could be key - two out and out wingers with defensive attributes too in Valencia and X (Bale/Bastos/Coentrao?) and other options in Nani and Park, who will cut inside and take a long shot or create chances from a more central position. If Valencia gets injured, you put Nani on the RW and trust Park on the left for an extended period of time which would mean having two fairly similar (in that they both drift into a central position) wingers on either side. No need to break the bank for one but you'll need one in the next 2 years imho.

Isn't Cleverley a CM?
 
But that's the point about Nani - he's two footed, but he evidently prefers the RW. If you can get one for the right price I think it could be key - two out and out wingers with defensive attributes too in Valencia and X (Bale/Bastos/Coentrao?) and other options in Nani and Park, who will cut inside and take a long shot or create chances from a more central position. If Valencia gets injured, you put Nani on the RW and trust Park on the left for an extended period of time which would mean having two fairly similar (in that they both drift into a central position) wingers on either side. No need to break the bank for one but you'll need one in the next 2 years imho.

Isn't Cleverley a CM?

plays across the midfield

Agree about Nani, definitely prefers the right, doesnt seem to trust his left for crossing as much as he does for shooting wierdly
 
Back
Top