The Manchester United Thread

Hi fellow united fans been a while since my last post but from tonights game I have seen how imbalanced our squad is its unbelievable OK I'm going to try to dissect this.
Defensively we have no natural leader whats worseis that the back four/three are chopping and changing week in week out plus the space between the defence and midfield was unacceptable we were caught out a few times because no one was available and they tried to play out which didn't really work due to the pressing Southampton put us under, now from what I have seen from Rojo is he doesn't look confident in being physical and seem to
hesitate when the ball is in the air. Smalling, Jones and Evans well always injured and inconsistent. Wingbacks well lack of depth really when fit Shaw and Rafael are really good attacking wise but Rafael is a bit rash, having young and Valencia doesn't fill me with confidence at all wherever they play but they will have to do for now.

Midfield: Well lack of energy in midfield was evident a lack of movement we really need Herrera needs to stay fit and we really need di Maria's pace but then you have blind who's better defensively than fellaini who I see as a target man which can be useful but not United quality. Rooney and Mata I feel it is one or the other and I feel due to his captaincy Rooney wins but they are two different players Mata is a playmaker but would need a defensively solid structure to express himself freely and on our current form not happening anytime soon I know he can play on the wings but I feel he would leave the wing backs exposed. Rooney on the other hand has more energy and will track back more often and can provide a moment of absolute brilliance on occasion but is not a natural playmaker and LVG doesn't see him as a striker. Carrick and Fletcher are decent cover but Fletcher is not as good as he used to be and Carrick is not getting any younger but will be useful till the end of the season. We do have Januzai who can be quality in the future but he needs game time and I do have faith in LVG and we have Pereira also a good prospect just hope they get games.

Forwards: This position seems to be covered but really hasn't been any good Rvp had a good game today and will be crucial if he continues in this form. Falcao has been disappointing although he hasn't been fit for a while so can't comment just yet. Wilson really excites me he brings that youthful energy that is needed to the team and think he will be a great player in the future.

All in all i think what we need is a commanding centre back such as Shawcross. For full backs possibly Clyne or Coleman but doubt it. Mid we need someone like Strootman. The key to reaching top 4 is a consistant back four and being fit but that's my opinion I might be wrong but hey I ain't a football manager.
 
We absolutely stole that one tonight, probably one of the worst performances from a passing and creating chances sense i have watched.
 
Think team Vs Pool should be-

De Gea
Rafa
Jones
Rojo
Young
Carrick
Fellaini
Herrera
Valencia
Rooney
RVP

4231/433

No way you can predict them 11 will be fit, can't predict a united 11 this season.

Jones and rafael coming straight in against the scousers? rafael maybe but not both imo.
 
I think Rojo has bee brilliant considering the circumstances. Coming to a new league into a struggling team off one of the clubs worst season, ever changing back for and formation. And I think he has one of the best heading rates in the league, and will only get better imo. Fellaini is defo good enough to play for us and do a job tbh without his performances of late and De Gea we would not be in the top 4 now. Im pleased Fellaini has turned his Utd career around, did have a bad game today though. Think we need to sign a left back to cover for Shaw, and promote one of Janko or Varela from the Reserves. Think we defo need a CM maybe 2 tops and an experienced CB. Maybe a winger but If Nani keeps up his form and Zaha can come back we should be ok there.
 
I think Rojo has bee brilliant considering the circumstances. Coming to a new league into a struggling team off one of the clubs worst season, ever changing back for and formation. And I think he has one of the best heading rates in the league, and will only get better imo. Fellaini is defo good enough to play for us and do a job tbh without his performances of late and De Gea we would not be in the top 4 now. Im pleased Fellaini has turned his Utd career around, did have a bad game today though. Think we need to sign a left back to cover for Shaw, and promote one of Janko or Varela from the Reserves. Think we defo need a CM maybe 2 tops and an experienced CB. Maybe a winger but If Nani keeps up his form and Zaha can come back we should be ok there.

Blind and Rojo are decent cover for shaw imo it's a proper right back we need and not a backup, one to start someone more solid than raf granted that might hurt us going forward but also one who is fit for atleast 90% of season.

Zaha won't make it here, two different managers wanted nothing to do with him.
 
Would sell Evans as well, to injury prone not young anymore and just does not look as good as the other 3 we have.
 
Blind and Rojo are decent cover for shaw imo it's a proper right back we need and not a backup, one to start someone more solid than raf granted that might hurt us going forward but also one who is fit for atleast 90% of season.

Zaha won't make it here, two different managers wanted nothing to do with him.
Maybe right about Zaha actually. Saying that about FBs I think we don't need to buy just promote.
 
Janko may come good but i've said it before if vermijl was any decent for the first team he'd have played a few times by now.
 
I think Rojo has bee brilliant considering the circumstances. Coming to a new league into a struggling team off one of the clubs worst season, ever changing back for and formation. And I think he has one of the best heading rates in the league, and will only get better imo. Fellaini is defo good enough to play for us and do a job tbh without his performances of late and De Gea we would not be in the top 4 now. Im pleased Fellaini has turned his Utd career around, did have a bad game today though. Think we need to sign a left back to cover for Shaw, and promote one of Janko or Varela from the Reserves. Think we defo need a CM maybe 2 tops and an experienced CB. Maybe a winger but If Nani keeps up his form and Zaha can come back we should be ok there.
Really wow well my opinion on Rojo was formed on the games I have seen him play and he has made a few mistakes when the ball is In the air but I have never checked statistics although I do hope he turns out to be a great piece of business. I agree with your comments about De Gea absolutely crucial to our team and regarding fellaini I think he does have a role to play although I don't see him making the starting line up when LVG sorts out the mid.
 
Janko may come good but i've said it before if vermijl was any decent for the first team he'd have played a few times by now.
Its strange coz Vermijl has trained with the 1st team since start of season. But Janko has just started last few weeks to get involved with the 1st team.
 
I think Rojo has bee brilliant considering the circumstances. Coming to a new league into a struggling team off one of the clubs worst season, ever changing back for and formation. And I think he has one of the best heading rates in the league, and will only get better imo. Fellaini is defo good enough to play for us and do a job tbh without his performances of late and De Gea we would not be in the top 4 now. Im pleased Fellaini has turned his Utd career around, did have a bad game today though. Think we need to sign a left back to cover for Shaw, and promote one of Janko or Varela from the Reserves. Think we defo need a CM maybe 2 tops and an experienced CB. Maybe a winger but If Nani keeps up his form and Zaha can come back we should be ok there.

Agreed. Rojo has done very well this season bar 1 or 2 games. Leicester was low point for him IMO but apart from that he has done really well.

He is new to the league and a big step up from Portuguese league. He hardly got any settled partner or played in settled formation. From 3 CBs to 2 CB and ever changing partner he has done very well.

Yesterday he was good defensively but he gave away possession very easily which is very unlike him.

Blind and Rojo are decent cover for shaw imo it's a proper right back we need and not a backup, one to start someone more solid than raf granted that might hurt us going forward but also one who is fit for atleast 90% of season.

Zaha won't make it here, two different managers wanted nothing to do with him.

IMO they shouldn't be cover for LB. Rojo is fine but he is our most important CB with Smalling injured and should play in his best position. We should sign a player who can cover both RB and LB.
 
We absolutely stole that one tonight, probably one of the worst performances from a passing and creating chances sense i have watched.

Its all about the results at this stage - United are rebuilding and have several injuries. If the points can continue to come then the performances should pick up after Christmas you would imagine
 
Whats peoples thoughts on the FA Cup draw. Hope to maybe see Pereira get a chance with Januzaj,Janko,Lindergaard,McNair,Blackett,Rothwell,Wilson and Falcao

Lindergaard
Janko,Thorpe,McNair,Blackett
Blind
Pearson,Periera
Januzaj,Falcao,Valencia

That's would be my Starting 11 433 with Rothwell,Wilson,Young,Evans,Mata,Verjmil and Perera the GK.
 
Last edited:
Whats peoples thoughts on the FA Cup draw. Hope to maybe see Pereira get a chance with Januzaj,Janko,Lindergaard,McNair,Blackett,Rothwell,Wilson and Falcao

Lindergaard
Janko,Thorpe,McNair,Blackett
Blind
Pearson,Periera
Januzaj,Falcao,Valencia

That's would be my Starting 11 433 with Rothwell,Wilson,Young,Evans,Mata,Verjmil and Perera the GK.


Mk dons part 2 waiting to happen, as strong as we can imo with maybe januzaj and blackett/mcnair in. It's annoying we've treated this cup like the mickey mouse cup in the past or had poor draws. Giving it a proper go this year will be nice.
 
Mk dons part 2 waiting to happen, as strong as we can imo with maybe januzaj and blackett/mcnair in. It's annoying we've treated this cup like the mickey mouse cup in the past or had poor draws. Giving it a proper go this year will be nice.
That's a strong team if you ask me. And with LVGs record of giving youth a chance in cups and General I can see a few in there. Also cant see him risking any injuries to key players in the cup knowing CL is a must this season.
 
That's a strong team if you ask me. And with LVGs record of giving youth a chance in cups and General I can see a few in there. Also cant see him risking any injuries to key players in the cup knowing CL is a must this season.

It is a decent team but i'd like rooney to start and maybe mata/carrick over pearson and if fit jones/evans over thorpe.


Also Valdes over Lindy......... :D
 
It is a decent team but i'd like rooney to start and maybe mata/carrick over pearson and if fit jones/evans over thorpe.


Also Valdes over Lindy......... :D
Yeah maybe put Mata in but I would not risk Rooney or Carrick, maybe on the bench. Valdes has not signed yet.
 
DDG*

Rafael/valencia*
Evans*
Rojo*
Young/rafael*


Fellaini*
Carrick*
Herrera*

Di Maria*

Rooney*
RVP*


A star next to everyone who i think might be okay for sunday.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top