The 'Rate My Kit' Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jake
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 4K
  • Views Views 1M
Status
Not open for further replies.
Really like the simplicity of all of them *Mason*. However, to improve I would suggest making the badge a tiny bit smaller, and making it more in line with the Adidas logo. To do this you could probably just move it up a notch or two, and then to right a tad. Saying that though, I would still say a 9/10 for all three. :)
 
Looking at the logo now it is abit too low, cheers for the feedback mate:)
 
Nice Mason, simple and good colours too. Only thing is the badge is too low down as peskybendben said. Apart from that they're superb!
 
LutonColla_H.png


Can I get some rates/opinions on this Luton town kit I made? Especially on the collar, because I made that from scratch. The rest of the kit isn't really finished yet, but I wanted to get some feedback on the collar before continuing.
 
jmoser said:
LutonColla_H.png


Can I get some rates/opinions on this Luton town kit I made? Especially on the collar, because I made that from scratch. The rest of the kit isn't really finished yet, but I wanted to get some feedback on the collar before continuing.
Click to expand...

Perfect collar, for kotw I'm guessing?
 
Rosario Central away kit.

The chest band is supposed to resemble Che Guevara's iconic hat, as they were his home town club, and his signature is in the bottom left of the shirt.

centralawaysmall.png
 
jmoser said:
Home - Really, really nice, I love it. Easily my favorite of the bunch.
Away - Very solid, nice looking kit. Not convinced on the violet shapes on the arms, and their spillover into the chest. Something seems a bit off about them. And that particular adidas template with the tapering lines always makes kits look really wide in the hips. But on the whole, I like it especially the use of gold, goes very well with the violet.
Third - Decent at best, my least favorite of the bunch.

Oh, and a quick question. Do you use a different template other than FB? Your kits always seem to have a mesh texture to them.
Click to expand...
cheers :) tbh i had second thoughts about the away, and i stole part the third kits design off of somebody who made a deportivo kit(6)

nah mate i still use FB kits
 
2 sets from my on-going SPL fantasy kitpack
Hearts
DMKqc.png
LrRwz.png


Hibernian
HVv9J.png
LuNOR.png
c2Bw8.png


---------- Post added at 03:03 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:56 PM ----------

rates ??
 
peskybendben said:
Good try Madridboy! The home and third are very good attempts, however the third needs a little work. As you can see below, the pattern is slightly different, and there is a gradient in the centre, from blue to white to blue again.

arsenal-nike-03-04-arsenal-3rd.gif

(Image above is not my creation. This is a real shirt and was taken from a football shirt website)


true but I'm not very good at Kit Creations and don't really use PS alot :(, so I wouldn't know put it as Blue then white, then Blue again :(
Good luck! ;)
Click to expand...
 
*Dallas* said:
2 sets from my on-going SPL fantasy kitpack
Hearts
DMKqc.png
LrRwz.png


Hibernian
HVv9J.png
LuNOR.png
c2Bw8.png
??
Click to expand...

Hearts - Don't like 'em, the black doesn't suit a Hearts kit and the two templates aren't nice. 5/10.

Hibs - Don't like these either, don't like the templates and Hibs should have White sleeves. 4/10.
 
jmoser said:
Oh, and a quick question. Do you use a different template other than FB? Your kits always seem to have a mesh texture to them.
Click to expand...
The mesh and shadow haven't resized like the rest of the kits, and imho it doesn't look good. Either saving as .png and resizing it, or merging visible layers before resizing the .psd should do the trick, and also provide better picture quality.
 
I am thinking of making some FB fantasy kit packs. However, I am not really sure if enough people would be interested. I have done the Arsenal kits only so far, and would like some feedback. If people like them, I will go ahead with the project. Also, if people don't like the fact that the kits are different styles/colours to the kits from the in-game database, I am willing to provide an editor data file too. :)

Arsenal Home | Away | Third

3xNJW.png
bR7GS.png
lnDr2.png


I actually really like these, but it is what you people think what matters.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top