The 'Rate My Kit' Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jake
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 4K
  • Views Views 1M
Status
Not open for further replies.
nice mate , im in the process of a pack , but not sure if people will download ,youve seen my examples will you be downloading mine ?
 
pistolped7 said:
Hearts - Don't like 'em, the black doesn't suit a Hearts kit and the two templates aren't nice. 5/10.

Hibs - Don't like these either, don't like the templates and Hibs should have White sleeves. 4/10.
Click to expand...

who cares, they are fantasy
 
exactly thanks malarkey :) will you be downloading my spl fantasy pack , only need to do 2 sets of kits , then do the config and test it should be out tommorow ?
 
Malarkey said:
who cares, they are fantasy
Click to expand...

Have to agree with pistolped here. I thought the whole point of a "rate my kit" thread was to subject your kits to the opinions of others. If you don't care about the opinions than why would you be posting in this thread. Just because the kits are fantasy doesn't mean they aren't subject to opinions. And that is exactly what pistolped did. Provided a rating on the kit, and gave a clear explanation as to why. That doesn't mean you have to agree with his opinion, but should still respect it because that is the essence of this thread. I apologize in advance for ranting. :(
 
View attachment 162927

I was bored so I decided to have a go at the new Chelsea kit. Please rate! :)

(i put my name on the kit so that people can not steal my work!
 
Last edited:
peskybendben said:
I am thinking of making some FB fantasy kit packs. However, I am not really sure if enough people would be interested. I have done the Arsenal kits only so far, and would like some feedback. If people like them, I will go ahead with the project. Also, if people don't like the fact that the kits are different styles/colours to the kits from the in-game database, I am willing to provide an editor data file too. :)

Arsenal Home | Away | Third

3xNJW.png
bR7GS.png
lnDr2.png


I actually really like these, but it is what you people think what matters.
Click to expand...

Home Kit: 10/10, i really like this, very simple and nothing wrong eith it
Away kit: 9/10, again, nice and simple, just don't like colours as much so can't give a 10
Third: 7/10, nice but i dont like the red on the side, think it would look much better without the red, just black (with the red lines)

Overall: 9/10, very nice kits
 
pistolped7 said:
Yes, and I'm rating them. oO)
It's my opinion and just because they are fantasy means I can't say I don't like bits of them?
Click to expand...

jmoser said:
Have to agree with pistolped here. I thought the whole point of a "rate my kit" thread was to subject your kits to the opinions of others. If you don't care about the opinions than why would you be posting in this thread. Just because the kits are fantasy doesn't mean they aren't subject to opinions. And that is exactly what pistolped did. Provided a rating on the kit, and gave a clear explanation as to why. That doesn't mean you have to agree with his opinion, but should still respect it because that is the essence of this thread. I apologize in advance for ranting. :(
Click to expand...

doesnt matter, and i do respect pistolped's opinion as he is one of the best kit makers on here, i was just pointing out that fantasy kits dont have to resemble the real life version.

---------- Post added at 01:40 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:35 PM ----------

anyway, just played around and made some barcelona kits; home, away and third:

homete.png
awaysl.png
thirdy.png
 
Malarkey said:
doesnt matter, and i do respect pistolped's opinion as he is one of the best kit makers on here, i was just pointing out that fantasy kits dont have to resemble the real life version.

---------- Post added at 01:40 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:35 PM ----------

anyway, just played around and made some barcelona kits; home, away and third:

homete.png
awaysl.png
thirdy.png
Click to expand...

Fantasy is best when grounded in reality.

As for your kits, the first is the best, second has a nice design, but don't like pastel colours personally. The black border around the stripes on shorts and socks is inconsistent with the shirts, and detracts from these bits imo. Also on all kits you should trim the badge a bit, there's at least 3 specks of black hanging off the points of the border. One final thing, the placement of the patches at the bottom of the shirts is inconsistent, they aren't on the away, and are lower on the third than on the home.
 
Malarkey said:
doesnt matter, and i do respect pistolped's opinion as he is one of the best kit makers on here, i was just pointing out that fantasy kits dont have to resemble the real life version.

---------- Post added at 01:40 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:35 PM ----------

anyway, just played around and made some barcelona kits; home, away and third:

homete.png
awaysl.png
thirdy.png
Click to expand...

I really like the home, although it might look even better if you made the logos and sleeve ends the same colour as the collar, as it looks classier than the yellow.

Although I don't like the shorts or socks, especially on the home as they look out of place.
 
St.Johnstone Kits from my kitpack , just need to do one set of of kits then do the config and test them :D
RtQFQ.png
RrpCP.png
6nHSy.png
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top