The 'Rate My Kit' Thread

[mufc68]

Nice work on the rangers kits

 

[Mike]

Just made a Chelsea home kit. The best one so far imo. Would love some rates

View attachment 163884

Black doesn't go with Chelsea blue I'm afraid :S the sponsor is a little too large, and the watermark in the bottom right corner would look better if the colour was removed. 5/10.

 

[Chokopop]

Black doesn't go with Chelsea blue I'm afraid :S the sponsor is a little too large, and the watermark in the bottom right corner would look better if the colour was removed. 5/10.

Yeah just realised i uploaded the wrong one (with the black stripes) . But at least i know where to improve.. Thanks.

 

[StuW]

Rumoured Arsenal Away 2011-2012 -

 

[*Jones*]

more Liverpool:

15-16 Season:
H/A/T

16-17 Season:
H/A/T

17-18 Season (125 year anniversary hence the retro)
H/A/T

​

 

[StuW]

Germany Home -

 

[mvp93]

New York Cosmos H/A


​

 

[peskybendben]

Liverpool:

Manchester United:

 

[Chokopop]

Made a Liverpool kit. Would love some rates. Probably my best work so far :

View attachment 163969

 

[Epsxe95]

First kits ever using photoshop.

Fantasy Mainz 05 H/A

Comments and Rates please !

 

[Chokopop]

First kits ever using photoshop.

Fantasy Mainz 05 H/A

Comments and Rates please !

Well.. You're better than i was when i first started using Photoshop

Would give 'em 8/10

 

[Epsxe95]

Well.. You're better than i was when i first started using Photoshop

Would give 'em 8/10

Thanks for the positive feedback

 

[Cal.]

Decided to start making some of the retro-ish Newcastle kits I own.

 

[StuW]

I had that both kits with 'Shearer 9' on the back. Very good work Cal. just need resizing to 250x250

 

[Cal.]

I had that both kits with 'Shearer 9' on the back. Very good work Cal. just need resizing to 250x250

Thanks, I had the home as a kid, but with Sear 9 (people thought I'd misspelled Shearer..), don't think I had that away though. Why are people using 250*250 now though? Aren't the FB-kit packs 220*220?

 

[StuW]

250x250 for this thread, as otherwise they are too big

 

[Cal.]

250x250 for this thread, as otherwise they are too big

Ah didn't notice the first post had changed, will change them now

 

[Chokopop]

What would you rate this kit? Have put alot more effort in it than i usually do :

View attachment 163990

 

[mvp93]

New York Cosmos H/A


​

Rates??

 

[StuW]

What would you rate this kit? Have put alot more effort in it than i usually do :

View attachment 163990

The Chelsea badge needs lifting a few pixels so it is in line with the Nike logo, and the sponsor needs lifting too. I don't like the white sleeves, as I always imagine Chelsea in Blue, with white trims etc. Also, there is a white outline on the lion. Shorts & Socks are good though.

6/10, although make those changes and it's a 9

---------- Post added at 11:56 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:55 PM ----------

Rates??

Love them, retro yet modern, and I love the Cosmos too.

9/10

---------- Post added at 11:58 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:56 PM ----------

Liverpool:

Manchester United:

Love the Liverpool H/A, not sure about the away though, don't like the pattern.

ManUre - Home very nice, simple & effective, Away maybe a white 1/2px stroke around M&S, third I like, cannot see the badge much though.

Made a Liverpool kit. Would love some rates. Probably my best work so far :

View attachment 163969

Like this a lot, but logo is slightly too big, and needs lining up with the Umbro, and Sponsor needs lifting.