The 'Rate My Kit' Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jake
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 4K
  • Views Views 1M
Status
Not open for further replies.
qI7JA.png
c3m5V.png

Another set of kits for my kit request thread - Macclesfield Town FC :)

I'll take credit for requesting! :)

---------- Post added at 11:17 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:46 PM ----------

My First Ever Kits

YocNq.png
tOUj4.png
 
Last edited:
9/10, 8/10, 7/10.

The sleeve badges need to be a bit bigger, and the stroke on the third kit sponsor looks wrong, maybe change the colour of the sponsor to black and have no stroke.

Apart from that, not bad. Really like the home.
 
Liverpool - H | A | T

lpoolH.png
lpoolA.png
lpool3.png


rates please, pleased with these :D
Nice simple designs
Home-7/10
Away-7.5/10
3rd-7.5/10

Just a bit of advice. Move your sponsors up a little bit. Also, the Premier League sleeve badges are a bit small
 
Sponsor's too big, the logos are a bit low in the home kit, the Standard Chartered logo in the away and third are too low. Also imo the kits would look better with the Standard Chartered logo smaller
 

My First Ever Kits

First off, you need to resize them to 250x250.

Secondly, the kits aren't too bad. Maybe reduce the stroke on the Fulham kit (logos/sponsor) by a few pixels, the lines on the left side of the Fulham shirt go off the edge of the kit. The Villa kit is a bit better, quite simple, but nice. :)

5/10, 7/10 for those two.
 
First off, you need to resize them to 250x250.

Secondly, the kits aren't too bad. Maybe reduce the stroke on the Fulham kit (logos/sponsor) by a few pixels, the lines on the left side of the Fulham shirt go off the edge of the kit. The Villa kit is a bit better, quite simple, but nice. :)

5/10, 7/10 for those two.

Thanks for the advice.
 
Not bad, wouldn't have had the black stroke around the sponsor, just doesn't go with the rest of the kit. Also, the badge looks a tiny bit big?

6/10
ok mate what size should i make the bagde then please
 

My First Ever Kits

YocNq.png
tOUj4.png

Fulham: I don't like the size of the stroke around the sponsor and the badge, would look my better without the 'FFC' on the sleaves, and i suggest using Fulhams real badge. Don't like the cottage, i know they play at craven cottage, the cottage you have used has no association with the football team at all, however neither does MJ lol. 6/10 nice effort.

Villa: Like this alot more, much more professional than the Fulham one, The AVFC badge looks like its missing something around the edge, maybe add a stroke thats a little bit darker than the original shirt, and the sponsor looks nice, don't think the stroke works, maybe try another sponsor if you want to add stroke, like the avfc lion, maybe make it a liitle more opaque. 7/10 for first attempt! :D

i often do that with the badges, but i make them alot more clear :) check >
WolvesH.png
PalermoT.png
 
ok mate what size should i make the bagde then please

when you paste a new badge on, whilst resizing it hold down shift, it keeps it in proportion, and just make the badge a little bit smaller, i suggest a different kit template, maybe FB or ss, they are much better quality :)
 
Just a few more kits to see where I can improve. Please rate and give constructive criticism.
yQfRM.png
Fk0kQ.png
2Br8V.png
 
Just a few more kits to see where I can improve. Please rate and give constructive criticism.
yQfRM.png
Fk0kQ.png
2Br8V.png

Holy ****! You've been making kits for 2 days and your already better than me. They're great. That Marseille kit=:wub:
Tottenham-9
Wycombe-8
Marseille-10
Maybe you could move your sponsors up a little though
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top