The 'Rate My Kit' Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jake
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 4K
  • Views Views 1M
Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't know if that was regarding my kits but can I just say we weren't argueing. In my eyes people were feedbacking and I was giving them my idea so I can improve how it is communicated through their feedback on my reply to them.

The only unconstructive one was Jones' but I took it with some sugar.
 
Dec said:
I don't know if that was regarding my kits but can I just say we weren't argueing. In my eyes people were feedbacking and I was giving them my idea so I can improve how it is communicated through their feedback on my reply to them.
Click to expand...

You may see it one way, but most people will see that as arguing. I read every post from when you posted them kits, and I would go with argument.

BTW, France kits 7/10. Simple:)
 
Triv said:
@Jose22 what is the sponsor used on those Rubin kits?
Click to expand...

i cant remember... but its something related to whater ever country Rubin Kazan are from (this i also cant remember)

sorry
 
jose22 said:
i cant remember... but its something related to whater ever country Rubin Kazan are from (this i also cant remember)

sorry
Click to expand...

ritard:P

Rubin Kazan - Russia
Sponsor - God Knows....
 
jose22 said:
i cant remember... but its something related to whater ever country Rubin Kazan are from (this i also cant remember)

sorry
Click to expand...
lol Russia

whatever it is i like it and those kits look so simple/smart/sleek on the eye, they're very very nice
 
Not every disagreement is an arguement if you ask me that is very loose but hey you're the mod ;).

Thanks for the feedback, you should know I like simple kits :P.
 
Dec said:
Not every disagreement is an arguement if you ask me that is very loose but hey you're the mod ;).

Thanks for the feedback, you should know I like simple kits :P.
Click to expand...

It is just that the way it reads makes it very easy to misinterpret, and another mod may see a healthy debate, another an argument.
 
Yes, I agree with that but with kit rating you need to step back a bit as it is a very touchy subject but doesn't really pass a spam, flame or arguement boundry often and stopping something like the communication the raters and I had was not really helpful as we were nearing an end and making progress on it.
Try and only step in when it reaches personal level or overspills into spam I would say as long as the original poster can take feedback like I was doing it should be allowed in my opinion for the good of the maker and thread.
 
England

Fantasy England Kits (Home and Away), see what you think.

xaorph.png


HOME (above)

ifmzgl.png


AWAY (above)

Heres a Villa kit. Just made it, what do you think?

k0ipn6.png
 
Last edited:
nicko9168 said:
Fantasy England Kits (Home and Away), see what you think.
Click to expand...

ENGLAND HOME

This reminds me of a training kit for some reason, I'd lose the sponsor to be honest.. but the rest looks fine, maybe add a bit more trim, like cuff and a end shirt trim.. Or maybe some Puma logos on the sleeves

ENGLAND AWAY

Probably same routine with this regarding the sponsor, I'd probably add some faint detail to the sleeves and see how that turns out..

​

furaiz said:
Can someone at least give me feedback?
Click to expand...

I like the colour combination, Just think the Ps3 sponsor is a little small, I see what you've tried to do by keeping it within the stripe, but I'd try a little bevel & emboss and maybe add some stroke so it stands out more..But the rest is good, maybe try the collar white too

Here's an England one
England-h-3.png

​
 
@ dannyfiveo

I like the kit, its great, but the 'cuffs' or ends of the arms etc, look a little out of place. IMO, i would have a solid red colour there, rather than stripes.

View attachment 117391
 
Last edited:
My second attempt at making kits, Understand they are plain without sponsors, I couldn't find any I liked to go with the kit so just decided to leave them. Feedback and how I can improve would be appreciated (even if you want rather than posting on here a VM or PM would be read aswell and replied to.)

BorussiaDortmundHome240x240.jpg
BorussiaDortmundAway240x240.jpg


---------- Post added at 10:51 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:49 PM ----------

Calum said:
picture.php
picture.php
picture.php


Rate Please :)
Click to expand...

I like the home and third not too keen on the away myself, personally for me I would move the umbro badge on third more to the left so its inside the blue stripe but im no expert so XD good strips again though mate ;)
 
I don't like the third one, the stripes don't look right to me.

The tottenham one is plain, but the sponsor looks good on the kit.

Your first one is the best, I like the burger king logo and everything.

Can you give feedback to mine as well?
I did post it just before ya ^^
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top