The 'Rate My Kit' Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Jake
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 4K
  • Views Views 1M
Status
Not open for further replies.
Calum said:
....
Click to expand...

Made using SSD, I presume? It's too bright IMO, no texture layer apparent, the green zavvi logo is a poor colour for that kit IMO, the adidas stripes on the left arm should be claret and I'm not keen on the wee curved bits going round the adidas stripes.

4/10 :)
 
dannyfiveo said:
Upload it to photobucket or something similar instead of attaching them .. .works for me

EDIT: That's a really good attempt saying it's your first.. that for the KOTW?
Click to expand...

Thanks Danny! Yeah that's the plan :S Will make an away at some point too :P

EDIT: And I tried uploading to imageshack, but didn't work? Will try photobucket!
 
Joss said:
EDIT: @Calum: 6/10 - Obviously I wouldn't do much better but I think (if poss?) you should have different colours for the addidas stripes on each side since the rest of the kit is split into two colours. Also don't like the colour of the away and maybe you shouldn't get rid of the logos on the back (inside) of the shirt. =)
Click to expand...

pistolped7 said:
Made using SSD, I presume? It's too bright IMO, no texture layer apparent, the green zavvi logo is a poor colour for that kit IMO, the adidas stripes on the left arm should be claret and I'm not keen on the wee curved bits going round the adidas stripes.

4/10 :)
Click to expand...

cheers for the rates lads :)

Joss your kits nice for your first time :O !!
8/10
 
Calum said:
cheers for the rates lads :)

Joss your kits nice for your first time :O !!
8/10
Click to expand...

No worries, and thanks!

Has anyone got any constructive advice for me? Got rid of the white BG now through photobucket =)
 
StuW said:
my current Newcastle kits -
H/A/T
CTRNy.png
imF6X.png
E8iPW.png
Click to expand...

Red & White 3rd kit..dodgy ground for a Mag..
Home and Away are very good..They should just keep the Newcastle Brown ale in there permanantly-- Newcastle will be forever associated with that.
 
Joss said:
No worries, and thanks!

Has anyone got any constructive advice for me? Got rid of the white BG now through photobucket =)
Click to expand...

Yeah, just keep making nice, simple kits like that and you're good! Less is more, but make the size a bit bigger, say 250x250?
 
INTER:
interhomey.png
interaway2.png
interthird.png


SOUTHEND:
southendhome.png
southendaway.png
southendthird.png


DERBY - Home:
derbyhome.png


RANGERS - Away:
rangersawayl.png
 
Haven't made any kits in ages, decided to enter these for kit of the week though.

BradfordHome.png
BradfordAway.png
 
PEOPLE NEED TO STOP POSTING JUST THEIR OWN KITS AND START GIVING FEEDBACK!

hiphopahol101 said:




Click to expand...

im really digging the away one. the logo looks a bit off on the home kit, but i think its hard to make it look good with the kit-style you are using. my favorit in the kotw so far.

ovD1n.png
vBrEt.png
 
Last edited:
how much fun would this thread be if everyone posted their own kits, and noone rated them?

I posted my kit, but gave feedback to some other dude.
 
if i was to sit and tell people how to make their kits better id be here all night with some people

some of us simply want people to view our kits, instead of finely analysing every little detail of peoples work (which is what i would end up doing because i am a perfectionist)
 
okay, sounds like im a minority :)

just thought the rate my kit thread was about rating kits
 
BradfordA.png

Away Kit for the KOTW Comp. Used Ajax's former sponsor, used to really like their kit!
Any feedback welcome as long as it's constructive!

PS - Took me an absolute age to do the sponsor, still loads of white bits despite cutting out as much as I could with magic wand ;)
 
Joss said:
BradfordA.png

Away Kit for the KOTW Comp. Used Ajax's former sponsor, used to really like their kit!
Any feedback welcome as long as it's constructive!

PS - Took me an absolute age to do the sponsor, still loads of white bits despite cutting out as much as I could with magic wand ;)
Click to expand...

10/10 top class :)
 
Last edited:
that is really a nice kit. something is odd about the nike logo tho
 
Kristian60 said:
that is really a nice kit. something is odd about the nike logo tho
Click to expand...

Yeah, think it was like that on my other entry too, not sure what went wrong though :S

And thanks Calum! |)
 
Havent done any kits for a while,

 
Status
Not open for further replies.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top