The 'Rate My Kit' Thread

[Mike]

Rate these Lads

You're getting better mate. I think if you use a wider spectrum of colours and imagination you could be a very good kit maker. And use different templates i.e. FB, Project Dummy etc

As for the kits themselves, 7/10.

 

[pistolped7]

Barcelona home kit, I don't really like making stripy kits but I think this is the best I've made with a Barcelona home attempt.

​

Not too bad, but I'm not sure white on a Barca top would be a good idea, what with the rivalry with Real and such...but nice stuff. 7.5/10

 

[Calum]

You're getting better mate. I think if you use a wider spectrum of colours and imagination you could be a very good kit maker. And use different templates i.e. FB, Project Dummy etc

As for the kits themselves, 7/10.

I have no like bar so cheers !

 

[StuW]

nice research there stu

I research most sponsors, as it keeps fantasy kits realistic. For example, a Barca kit wouldn't look right with Nationwide building society on it>

 

[Niall]

@ Calum - I like the design but two of the kits are blue so it doesn't really work, 7/10 for the design though, it's just missing something, a little too plain.

Paris S-G H/A/T

Ratings & Advice please

 

[StuW]

@ Calum - I like the design but two of the kits are blue so it doesn't really work, 7/10 for the design though, it's just missing something, a little too plain.

Paris S-G H/A/T

Ratings & Advice please

H - 8/10 - Nice to see originality.
A - 9/10 - As Above.
T - 6/10 - I am not a fan of the design. I doesn't fit the kit.

 

[Calum]

@ Calum - I like the design but two of the kits are blue so it doesn't really work, 7/10 for the design though, it's just missing something, a little too plain.

Paris S-G H/A/T

Ratings & Advice please

Home 9
Away 9
Third 7

 

[JSmyth]

I need to size and place the sponsor the same for each kit but I'll do that after.

 

[StuW]

FC United of Manchester H/A/T​

 

[Niall]

@ JSmyth - On the home kit is the centre stripe supposed to overlap the collar? I think it would look better if the stripe was layered underneath the collar.

Also not a fan of the black stroke on the Barca badge, if you're going to have a stroke I think yellow would look better on the home and white would look better on the away.

If you sort out the proportions of the badges/sponsors you could have some nice kits on your hands

@ StuW - Very nice as per, how have you done the background on the red kit? Is it on a template or have you pen-tooled it? I've tried pentooling and then duplicating the layer to try to make an effect like that but it take foooorevvvverrrrrr :S

 

[Calum]

nice kits Stu

also since FCUM are in the Prem now what a derby with Utd they will have

 

[Mike]

@ StuW - Very nice as per, how have you done the background on the red kit? Is it on a template or have you pen-tooled it? I've tried pentooling and then duplicating the layer to try to make an effect like that but it take foooorevvvverrrrrr :S

It's on the template mate

 

[iNickStuff]

@ Calum - I like the design but two of the kits are blue so it doesn't really work, 7/10 for the design though, it's just missing something, a little too plain.

Paris S-G H/A/T

Ratings & Advice please

1. 7/10
2. 8/10
3. 6/10

My favourite is probably the away kit. Very nice work, I am liking the design.

 

[whyelse]

@ JSmyth - On the home kit is the centre stripe supposed to overlap the collar? I think it would look better if the stripe was layered underneath the collar.

Also not a fan of the black stroke on the Barca badge, if you're going to have a stroke I think yellow would look better on the home and white would look better per, how have you done the background on the red kit? Is it on a template or have you pen-tooled it? I've tried pentooling and then duplicating the layer to try to make an effect like that but it take foooorevvvverrrrrr :S

you should try pattern overlay if you try again

 

[Mike]

Aside from the collar and logos (that leaves the design ) this is a template I created myself. Any thoughts?

Here I showcase it with Arsenal:

 

[Frank]

Loving the home matey. Think the away could maybe have worked better with Redcurrent instead of Black.

 

[Calum]

Aside from the collar and logos (that leaves the design ) this is a template I created myself. Any thoughts?

Here I showcase it with Arsenal:

Wow they are the best kits i have ever seen on RMK i :wub: them both 100% if you entered them in KOTW you would have won hands down

 

[Mike]

A bit like that Frankie? ^^)

 

[whyelse]

Home inspired by Dannyfiveo and Away inspired by el Wulfio

my KOTW entry

 

[Micky139]

my KOTW entry

7/10 6/10 Not bad but i think the 1st would look better wth 3 stripes and i don't get the kinda smoke thing?