The 'Rate my Photoshop work' Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Max
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 1K
  • Views Views 345K
Just made this:
2re6vpz.jpg

Thoughts please?
 
Dec said:
Just made this:
2re6vpz.jpg

Thoughts please?
Click to expand...

not bad although I'm havin a small problem with the right hand side of the render. Nice production on the rest of the sig, good but not great, lacks a punch oO).....

---------- Post added at 09:46 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:43 PM ----------

jose22 said:
my attepmt at a logo for my kits/sigs/work :)
Click to expand...


nice logo and you've certanily came on in your photoshop work, very clean and focused..... it doesn't say very much about whatever it's meant to be about lol that's my only critque really
 
Tidied her arm up:
pohm8.jpg


I don't know what to add though, I like the simple white/red scheme and sometimes sigs don't need to be like yours and all flashy as it doesn't work.
 
can add a pic of an ugly dude with the text "she's going in the w*nk bank"

heh
 
Dec said:
Tidied her arm up:
pohm8.jpg


I don't know what to add though, I like the simple white/red scheme and sometimes sigs don't need to be like yours and all flashy as it doesn't work.
Click to expand...

lol i don't always do flashy sigs <) it's a brilliantly done sig, don't get me wrong maybe just needs some depth of field and some dynamic lighting. maybe re-add the image a couple of times on different settings soft, hue ect. to see it that deepens it in anyway.
 
I tried but I hate images like that, I just love one focal point.

I did a Diana Vickers one too:
20ti784.jpg
 
Caspian_Rho said:
not bad although I'm havin a small problem with the right hand side of the render. Nice production on the rest of the sig, good but not great, lacks a punch oO).....

---------- Post added at 09:46 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:43 PM ----------




nice logo and you've certanily came on in your photoshop work, very clean and focused..... it doesn't say very much about whatever it's meant to be about lol that's my only critque really
Click to expand...

yeh i was following a tutorial so instead i used the 22 from my username to make the logo. which is why it doesnt really say much bout it
 
Dec said:
I tried but I hate images like that, I just love one focal point.

I did a Diana Vickers one too:
20ti784.jpg
Click to expand...

Diana's right arm needs some erasing on the layer above other than that sweet tag!

---------- Post added at 11:01 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:00 PM ----------

jose22 said:
yeh i was following a tutorial so instead i used the 22 from my username to make the logo. which is why it doesnt really say much bout it
Click to expand...


I was thinkin it was a tutorial... the result is pretty much perfect!
 
I tried to blend her in a bit but I guess it didn't work, thanks for the kind words :).
 
liverpoolxc.png


really not sure on this :/

no tutorial was used for like the first time ever for me
 
Try to use brushes, textures and colours to edit layers, I mean if you have a brush that edits a white bit on the shirt it can be a **** of a lot in the long run.
However it is great for a first time.
 
I prefer the one with border. It looks nicer.
 
jose22 said:
liverpoolxc.png


really not sure on this :/

no tutorial was used for like the first time ever for me
Click to expand...

Ima gonna start with the words here, Is it a fans sig or a non-fans sig?? 'Still empty handed' seems a very negative approach...... especially when your BG shows some celebration of something and they look far from empty handed lol

but an empty background works, and even more if you were to move the left logo portion (team name, mantra and badge) behind choker or err I mean Stevie rotate it anti-clockwise about 30 degrees and use a metal brush behind that again just to pull out some of the edges...

where's the border?? borders are essential in anything you present <) overall not bad for a first go with no tut

---------- Post added at 12:03 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:53 AM ----------

Coach Carter said:
Without Border.
work2e.png


With Border.
work1l.png


Comments?
Click to expand...


definitely needs the border but I'm thinking maybe on a harder edge than what you have presently. I'd take a more shock approach to the bg here, your render looks focused and is preparing for something, so I'd reflect that else where in the sig itself, maybe use sharpen on the sharpen edges filter on the render itself, indicating precision with elegance... It's all contextual really

If the writing is to do with the character I'd increase it's size, helps dramatise the render and over-all sig and maybe have it on soft-light reproduced a few times.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top