The 'Rate my Photoshop work' Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Max
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 1K
  • Views Views 346K
Triv said:
looks nice to me but is his shirt meant to be back to front?


absolutely :wub: the Walcott one tho, its a beaut (shame its an Arsenal player)
Click to expand...

Yeah I flipped the render, was waiting for someone to point it out. Glad it took atleast 3 people before anyone noticed.

Thats the reason I am using my Wallcott sig. :P
 
Just made this sig, I like it but I would like some more opinions on it.

TheoWalcott.png
 
It has nothing to do with football, but I made this in photoshop yesterday.

What do you guys think?

test3.png
 
AussieOchoa said:
I like it... a LOT! Good work...

drogbacopy.jpg

My new sig :)
Click to expand...

7/10

The colours and grainyness of the signature doesn't work well and I personally don't like the closeup, the right side is a bit bare aswell But I do like the badge.
 
Liking it a lot man, the effect of Torres is realllly nice. Also the effect of the lines behind him is nice as well. The badge looks a little odd out there by itself, but also again, nice effects. The text is well done as always.

8.5/10 from me :)

acarrollcopy.png
 
picture.php


Did this whilst in the Reprographics room of my school. This is my first-ever real piece of work on Photoshop, barring school ones and the fact that I used the CS1 version to make it.

Feel free to make constructive criticism.
 
Last edited:
ChelseaFan11 said:
torresgood.jpg


my new sig,
opinions ?
Click to expand...

6/10

The cartoonish efeect just doesn't look right at all, the effect with the badge doesn't go well with the rest of the sig, good effort to try something different though.

AussieOchoa said:
soldadocopy.jpg

Put that together just then, fairly pleased...


Also made this...

iniestavacopy.jpg
Click to expand...

Signature - 8/10

I like it but in my opinion it would probably look better without the Valencia badge and the border is the wrong colour.

Avatar - 4/10

Sorry but the avatar just doesn't look right at all, the colours are all wrong and the background just doesn't look right with the differences in brightness and colours.


Can't see iNickStuff's work.
 
Nathan said:
6/10

The cartoonish efeect just doesn't look right at all, the effect with the badge doesn't go well with the rest of the sig, good effort to try something different though.



Signature - 8/10

I like it but in my opinion it would probably look better without the Valencia badge and the border is the wrong colour.

Avatar - 4/10

Sorry but the avatar just doesn't look right at all, the colours are all wrong and the background just doesn't look right with the differences in brightness and colours.


Can't see iNickStuff's work.
Click to expand...

View attachment 118576

This better?
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top