The 'Rate my Photoshop work' Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Max
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 1K
  • Views Views 345K
AussieOchoa said:
fabregasl.jpg


henryavacopy.png

A Fabregas signature and my new Henry avatar :) Rate please.
Click to expand...

Signature - 7/10

Really like the background but again I don't like the closeup on the players face. Text looks out of place.

Avatar - 9/10

I really like the avatar but I prefer not having a players badge in myself as I like to keep it simple and I would move Henry to the right a small bit. Also imo 100x100 looks best for avatars. I really like everything else though.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Not sure about this one I just made.

AdamJohnson.png
 
Last edited:
Liking the simplicity of that. Not sure about the reverse of his face, no matter how low opacity it is. The text works very well. It's all very bare and basic, but that looks good with the total effect.

9.5/10
 
Yeah, I was going for something a bit different. Sometimes the more simple the better.

---------- Post added at 02:59 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:55 AM ----------

iNickStuff said:
View attachment 118576

This better?
Click to expand...

7/10

For your first piece of work in Photoshop it is good, I'm not too keen on the pencil effect myself bit there are people that would like it.

Try lowering the level of the effect and it would look a bit better imo.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Some quick avatars I just made.

GattusoBoatengavatar.png
Villa.png
 
Last edited:
Love the Villa one, so simple, so beautiful. Other one, not so much, two people ruins it I think, some nice effects though.

So...

1 - 6/10
2 - 10/10

--------------

Two versions of a van der Vaart sig I made, one with text and badge, one without.

vandercopy.jpg


vander2copy.jpg
 
Nathan said:
Yeah, I was going for something a bit different. Sometimes the more simple the better.

---------- Post added at 02:59 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:55 AM ----------



7/10

For your first piece of work in Photoshop it is good, I'm not too keen on the pencil effect myself bit there are people that would like it.

Try lowering the level of the effect and it would look a bit better imo.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Some quick avatars I just made.

GattusoBoatengavatar.png
Villa.png
Click to expand...


1. 7/10
2. 9/10 , but it looks like he's doing a **** XD
 
AussieOchoa said:
Love the Villa one, so simple, so beautiful. Other one, not so much, two people ruins it I think, some nice effects though.

So...

1 - 6/10
2 - 10/10

--------------

Two versions of a van der Vaart sig I made, one with text and badge, one without.

vandercopy.jpg


vander2copy.jpg
Click to expand...

I prefer the csecound one more simpler and cooler IMO

9/10
 
AussieOchoa said:
Two versions of a van der Vaart sig I made, one with text and badge, one without.

vandercopy.jpg


vander2copy.jpg
Click to expand...

6/10

The orange doesn't look good with the dark desaturated background, the second is better as the text is in a bad position on the first and ruins it along with the inclusion of the Netherlands badge.

AussieOchoa said:
How bout this one then?

patocopy.jpg
Click to expand...

4/10

Just looks horrible, the background just looks bad and having Pato in the same colours doesn't look right either because he doesn't stand out.
 
Got very... very bored today so decided to create a vector. Of whom you say?

2nc2zdc.png


Why, of this man here. Yes, the face is horrible and it's missing the design on the kit as well but eh, first real try at a vector.
 
For a first try at a vector that is amazing, I've always wanted to work out how to make one. Did you follow a tutorial?
 
Nathan said:
For a first try at a vector that is amazing, I've always wanted to work out how to make one. Did you follow a tutorial?
Click to expand...
No tutorial needed lol. Because I knew a bit about the pentool already, all I needed was an image [in this case, Gary Hooper] and I was off. =p
 
It looks decent mate. Almost "pop arty" :P

What is a vector btw ?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top