The 'Rate My Squad' Thread.

[Sam]

Napoli - Aug 2013

View attachment 171015

What do you think?

Good team, baffled why Lukaku isn't good enough though XD

Goalkeeper Review
You have a very good keeper in Martin Stekeleburg, but you may need to strengthen the back-up position, maybe you should look to bring in a younger keeper, try Lukas Hradecky or Ben Amos

Defender Review
Your Defence is definitely your strongest point, having Kjaer as back-up shows how good it is. Kyle Walker is amazing, so he should be good in the future also.

Midfield Review
This is a world beating Midfield with Hamsik playmaking and M'Villa being a rock, if there id any weakness, it would be Cigirani, look to bringing in James Rodrigues, Marco Verratti or John Fleck.

Striker Review
Again I'm confused as too why Lukaku is out on loan, but I guess he is still young, this is probably your weakest position, try signing Sanago, Babacar, someone like that to provide some beef up front

Overall Review
Great team, but could be better. 8.5/10

---------- Post added at 11:15 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:15 AM ----------

I think this thread should be re-named 'Raikan Rate My Squad'!

Ahem

 

[lewisd1992]

Good team, baffled why Lukaku isn't good enough though XD

Goalkeeper Review
You have a very good keeper in Martin Stekeleburg, but you may need to strengthen the back-up position, maybe you should look to bring in a younger keeper, try Lukas Hradecky or Ben Amos

Defender Review
Your Defence is definitely your strongest point, having Kjaer as back-up shows how good it is. Kyle Walker is amazing, so he should be good in the future also.

Midfield Review
This is a world beating Midfield with Hamsik playmaking and M'Villa being a rock, if there id any weakness, it would be Cigirani, look to bringing in James Rodrigues, Marco Verratti or John Fleck.

Striker Review
Again I'm confused as too why Lukaku is out on loan, but I guess he is still young, this is probably your weakest position, try signing Sanago, Babacar, someone like that to provide some beef up front

Overall Review
Great team, but could be better. 8.5/10

Yeah I've had Lukaku for two seasons now, scored hardly any.
And also I have Cigarini in AMC for some reason he plays amazingly good there.

 

[Sam]

Yeah I've had Lukaku for two seasons now, scored hardly any.
And also I have Cigarini in AMC for some reason he plays amazingly good there.

Alright, keep him there them

 

[Raikan007]

Napoli - Aug 2013

View attachment 171015

What do you think?

This is a very good sqaud, the only weakness I can suggest is Cigarini in Amc, he is a decent player but I think you should think about retraining Rossi as Amc to incorporate Cavani in the starting line up! Definately need a new Lb to cover, Cassani probably covers for you there correct? Walker on loan to cover for Rb when he gets back as well as Serge not bad!

I would suggest Alex Sandro - Santos, Georgiy Schennikov - CSKA.

Team rating: 8.9/10 great team, good mixture of youth and good players! maybe also look at a new keeper in the next year or two though! and a new AMC (Napoli bought Pastore in the 3rd season for 17.5 million) he would be fantastic there

if you need suggestions, feel free to PM me!

---------- Post added at 12:34 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:31 PM ----------

Here's another Team for rating if you don't mind Raikan.

Can't post SS yet cos I'm not on my computer:

Everton:

5-6th season in, Champions League winners, Premiership Winners

not a bad team there Sam, need to replace Hennessey as your keeper, he is sub standard! very good midfield, save for Arteta (old now) and Verratti is a shadow of the player he was last year! so need replacements there!

your bench is lacking in quality, also depends how Alacer and Isco have developed!

Team rating: 7.8/10 need to strengthen your replacements!

 

[King Sid]

What about this squad anyone? In 2012, I've also got Jordan Spence arriving in January.

I also have Jack Butland and Febian Brandy out on loan, along with the top youngsters Portsmouth start off with at the start of the game.

Also where would you expect this team to finish in the PL just out of interest?

 

[Sam]

This is a very good sqaud, the only weakness I can suggest is Cigarini in Amc, he is a decent player but I think you should think about retraining Rossi as Amc to incorporate Cavani in the starting line up! Definately need a new Lb to cover, Cassani probably covers for you there correct? Walker on loan to cover for Rb when he gets back as well as Serge not bad!

I would suggest Alex Sandro - Santos, Georgiy Schennikov - CSKA.

Team rating: 8.9/10 great team, good mixture of youth and good players! maybe also look at a new keeper in the next year or two though! and a new AMC (Napoli bought Pastore in the 3rd season for 17.5 million) he would be fantastic there

if you need suggestions, feel free to PM me!

---------- Post added at 12:34 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:31 PM ----------



not a bad team there Sam, need to replace Hennessey as your keeper, he is sub standard! very good midfield, save for Arteta (old now) and Verratti is a shadow of the player he was last year! so need replacements there!

your bench is lacking in quality, also depends how Alacer and Isco have developed!

Team rating: 7.8/10 need to strengthen your replacements!

Thanks, I will look to strengthen my replacements ASAP

 

[avfc-ncfc]

not sure about top 4 mate, I would be more realistic and say top half finish! maximum 7th, decent team there Andre' looks like a great player! Toloi is a great player as well! you need to look at a new Keeper though! take a look at some of the players I have suggested above! or you can PM and say ask for suggestions...

Team rating: 7.3/10, good midfield and wingers, striking and keeping weaknesses

---------- Post added at 10:50 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:27 AM ----------


nice Ajax team there and a good formation different!

left wing back looks like it needs a little attention! Saadi is on fire for you! he is a great young player! if you like your formation with the DM you may want to look at a new DM to bring in and train up for cover to De Zeeuw! Love Renan, did you buy him from my recommendation?

take a look at someone like Ognjen Vukojevic - Dinamo Kiev or Vincent Pajot - Stade Rennais or Necip Uysal - Besiktas maybe?

you also need a new Cb as Kara is decent, look at Mario Fernandes - Gremio, Neuton - Gremio (Pm me for any suggestions you need for your squad, will gladly help)

Team rating: 8.3/10 good mixture of youth and experience, good players in most positions but need cover for the postions I mentioned above

Cheers for the advice and i did look at improving my strike force but Welbeck has scored 44 in 71 and Nolan Roux has scored 46 and assisted 28 in 80 appearances so i didn't think that was to bad. Can you recommend me a striker and goalie then. I had 25 million to spend last summer.

Thanks pal.

 

[TheEquinox]

Curious if you guys think I can compete for championship this season :
Here my Stuttgart team in season 2017 / 2018 and last season's table

View attachment 171121View attachment 171124View attachment 171125View attachment 171122View attachment 171120View attachment 171123

Edit : So it won't let me upload the other two screenshots, so my first team lineup is

Leno

Otto - Tasci - Santana - Westermann

Fer

Träsch - Polanski

Ilicevic -------------------- Dimitrov

Pfeifer
​

And last season I finished 3rd behind HSV and Dortmund

Transfers for the new season :

Otto 8,25M € from Leverkusen (instead of Celozzi)
Westermann 1,9M € from HSV (instead of Kopplin)
Dimitrov 5,25M € from Catania (instead of Fabbrini)
Kuzmin 130k € from Spartak Moscow (backup / youth prospect)
Bischoff 1,5M € from Ajax (backup / youth prospect)
Langen 1,2M € from Leverkusen (backup / youth prospect)
Littmann 5,25M € from Mallorca (backup to be able to switch to 4-4-2)

 

[ZavonHines]

My squad for West ham (First season)
Green
L.Jacobson J.Tomkins M.Upson W.Bridge

S.Parker M.Noble T.Hitzlsperger

D.Ba C.Cole Z.Hines

 

[Gabe Hoppus]

Wolves - 2010/11

Traditional 4-4-2, and expectations set in "Mid-table"


1st Eleven:


Wayne Hennessey
Kevin Foley - Sebastian Coates - Christopher Berra - Stephen Ward
Ákos Buzsáky - David Jones - Karl Henry - Nenad Milijas
Kevin Doyle - Steven Fletcher

Reserve team:

Adriano Basso
Richard Stearman - Jody Craddock - Ronald Zubar - Lasha Salukvadze
Piero Mingola - Radosav Petrovic - Michael Mancienne - Andreas Ivanschitz
Leigh Griffiths - Pablo Mouche



Long-term injuries:

Matt Jarvis - 3 months
Michael Knightly - 7 months
Stephen Hunt - 2 months
Steven Mouyokolo - 1 month
Sam Vokes - 6 months
Andy van der Meyde - 2 months



Transfers:

In:

Ivanschitz < Main - 925k
Coates < Nacional - 2.8m
Salukvadze < free - 0
Buzsáky < QPR - 2.8m
Mouche < Boca - 1.9m
van der Meyde < free - 0
Petrovic < Partiza - 2.5m
Mingola < Watford - Ln Fee 55k


Out:

Ikeme > Sunderland - 1.1m
Hahnemann > Derby - 750k
Ebanks-Blake > Newcastle - 3.9m
Elokobi > Stoke - 2.6m
Rooney > Port Vale - loan
Hammill > Leicester - Ln fee 28k
Edward > Derby - loan
Guédioura > Cagliari - Ln fee 120k
Batth > Carlisle - loan

​

 

[thorton]

Man City April 2013

Formation

GK
FB(att) - CB(cover) - CB(stop) - FB(att)
Def Mid(sup)
BWM(def) - Adv Pl(att)
Treq
Poacher - Complete(att)

Primary Playmaker = Treq
Target Man = Complete Fwd
Supply = Mixed


Starting 11 (league):

De Gea
Srna - Mario Fernandes - Vincent Kompany - Coentrao
Yaya Touré
De Jong - Hamsik
Silva
Tevez - Babacar

Starting 11 (cup):

De Gea
Srna - Mario Fernandes - Vincent Kompany - A.Cole
Yaya Touré
Phil Jones - Wilshere
Thiago
Tevez - Dzeko​

Rotation/Hot Prospects:

GK:
Laurentiu Branescu

Def:
Zabaleta

Mid:
Milner
Suso
Abdallah Yaisien

Fwd:
Wickham
Sanogo

Plus a few regens

 

[Mousemat_FM]

View attachment 171402

Celtic - 1st season
All injuries all long term
Transfer window about to come up, so would be curious as to what everyone makes of my squad and any hints on possible additions, would be more than welcome.

Thanks

 

[prow07]

My Newcastle squad as of January 2014 (First team and Reserves), i have a mix of experienced and younger players in my squad, and i've got a cracking U18 regen, Jack Batty.

GK's and CB's
View attachment 171408
Full Backs
View attachment 171407
CM's
View attachment 171406
Forwards
View attachment 171405
Wide Midfielders/Wingers
View attachment 171404
Transfers
Allan McGregor - £5m
Guillermo Ochoa - £7.5
Ahmed Elmohammady - £3m
Chris Samba - £4.1m
Jeremy Helan - £1.5m
Chris Smalling - £2.1m
Tim Adler - £20k
Andrea Poli - £6.5m
Marco Marchionni - £1.8m
Nathan Delfouneso - £6.5m

Free Transfers... Patrick Van Aanholt, Miralem Sulejmani, Luis Suarez, Kenny Miller, Ivica Olic, Arsenio Valpoort.

 

[WannaB]

nice Ajax team there and a good formation different!

left wing back looks like it needs a little attention! Saadi is on fire for you! he is a great young player! if you like your formation with the DM you may want to look at a new DM to bring in and train up for cover to De Zeeuw! Love Renan, did you buy him from my recommendation?

take a look at someone like Ognjen Vukojevic - Dinamo Kiev or Vincent Pajot - Stade Rennais or Necip Uysal - Besiktas maybe?

you also need a new Cb as Kara is decent, look at Mario Fernandes - Gremio, Neuton - Gremio (Pm me for any suggestions you need for your squad, will gladly help)

Team rating: 8.3/10 good mixture of youth and experience, good players in most positions but need cover for the postions I mentioned above

Thanks Raikan! Yeah, i bought Renan, Saadi, Verratti, Mariano etc. all on your (not only you, everyone on FM Base really) recommendations. They're class.

Kara or Enoh are my replacement for De Zeeuw, they're decent tho not world class.

My left wing position has always been my weakspot. I've retrained Romario and Mariano for that position so if someone falls out, i always have one replacement.

Mario Fernandes is class, i know. Wanted him but i don't want to loose my 2 central defenders as i believe Mario is much better. Plus, i also prefer league players of the same country (EG English Premier league, English platers etc.)

Once again thanks!