The 'Rate My Squad' Thread.

  • Thread starter Thread starter StuW
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 113
  • Views Views 18K
duckers4 said:
Using LFC Marshalls update, my Liverpool squad just starting the third season:

GK: P.Reina
LB: D.Wilson
RB: M.Kelly
LCB: M.Skrtel
RCB: K.Mangane
LCM: S.Gerrard
RCM: R.Merieles
LW: I.Muniain
RW: L.Suarez
ACM: Ganso
ST: R.Lukaku

Subs:
B.Jones
D.Agger
C.Adam
A.Turan
A.Carroll
S.Jovetic
J.Shelvey
Click to expand...

I am now in February of the 2015/16 season and my squad has had a bit of a face life, see what you guys think:

GK: P.Reina
LB: G.Bale
RB: G.Johnson
LCB: D.Wilson
RCB: K.Mangane
LCM: S.Jovetic
CM: Ganso
RCM: I.Rakitic
LW: Neymar
RW: I.Muniain
ST: R.Lukaku

Subs:
Y.Cavaligia (regen - not far off Reina now at the age of 22)
M.Kelly
M.Skrtel
S.Gerrard
M.Marin
M.Zarate
Y.Sanogo

Also got J.Shelvey, E.Zidane & I.Marcano in reserves.
 
My MK Dons Team - 2013/2014

Itumelag Khune
Patrick Van Aanholt
Andreas Forero - Regen
Johnny Evans/Tal Ben Haim
Kyle Walker
John Fleck/Marko Arnuatovic
Lee Cattermole
Sergio Busquets
Marko Marin
Yaya Sanogo/Khouma Babacar
John Fleck - 44 goals in 48 games

Subs:
Scott Carson
Matt Mills
Alan Hutton
Jose Portillo - Regen
Nemanja Matic
Aleksandr Kerzhakov
Pablo Piatti
 
Sporting CP 2012/13

GK: Rui Patricio

RB: Serge Aurier
CB: Nuno André Coelho/Juanpé
LB: Evaldo

CM: Abriel/Zapatar/Matias Fernández

AMC: Fleck (loan)

ST: Yannick Djalo/Ronny Rodellin

SUB: Hildebrand
SUB: Pereira
SUB: Anderson Polga
SUB: Grimi
SUB: Adrien
SUB: Vuckevic
SUB: Macheda (loan)

Thoughts? It's one of the youngest but best team in Zon Sagres.
 
Last edited:
Man Utd 2013/14

GK: Rene Adler
DR: Rafael/Gregory van der Wiel
DCR: Nemanja Vidic
DCL: Nicolas Otamendi
DL: Fabio Coentrao
DMC: Darren Fletcher
MCR: Nuri Sahin
MCL: Sergio Canales
AMR: Nani
AML: Eden Hazard
STC: Javier Hernandez

Subs:
Carlos Kameni
Jonny Evans
Gregory van der Wiel/Rafael
Tom Huddlestone
Tom Cairney
Mario Balotelli
Vaclac Kadlec


Any thoughts appreciated.
​
 
Last edited:
Nice team - Only Heskey could make it better,may I ask what Canales like?
 
I thought this was the rate your squad thread, no one rates anything... let me start!

Buzzlite, its pretty much the same squad, you have overpaid A LOT for Boyata as I have mentioned in the PM you sent me. Enyeama is not bad, but you can get A LOT better quality as your number 2 at Barca!

Vidal is a good player, bit expensive (its in Us dollars I know, but still about 5 million too much) and also not played correctly! if you want a Lb buy a Lb, Juan Manual Vargas, Zhirkov or Lahm...



Rating: 6.5/10 due to the fact that you have overpaid alot and have not brought in the quality of players that you can!

Duckers, you have a good team there, Mangane must be getting on and you can do better than Rakitic in the centre as well as Gerrard being a ballie now, so you need a replacement there.. other than that...

Rating: 8.3/10 good mix of experience and youth and Munian is a classy player that will excel in that position


Sam, not a bad sqaud there, good strikers, good mids, not sure how you can afford all their wages though as most of them would ask for around 60-120k. But nonetheless, Khune is **** and you need to replace him, left back is also weak, look at replacing him!

Rating: 7.4/10 good team, some weak area's Cb included though


WFC4B3N: Not a bad squad, kept a lot of your original players which is good! you need some cover in the Cb department, Raphael Verane, Lucio, Marcano, Mussacchio.. as well as the Striking department, not a bad loan you have there with Mechada. good mixture of players...

Rating: 7.8/10 good squad, not all fantastic players, but I am certain as a whole, perform extremely well together! nice job


Prequel, not sure what team you are but I can only guess United, 4th season maybe? got a very nice team there, good mixture of players, Sahin and Canales are great players. I would suggest getting more cover for your Wings though. Harry Novillo, Nicolas Gaitan, Pablo Piatti..

Rating: 8.4/10 you pretty much have Hernandez, Nani, Fletcher, Vidic, Rafael, Evans from your starting team which is a bit of a drastic change in my opinion :) but that also depends on which season it is :) but a very good squad nonetheless!
 
Raikan007 said:
I thought this was the rate your squad thread, no one rates anything... let me start!

Buzzlite, its pretty much the same squad, you have overpaid A LOT for Boyata as I have mentioned in the PM you sent me. Enyeama is not bad, but you can get A LOT better quality as your number 2 at Barca!

Vidal is a good player, bit expensive (its in Us dollars I know, but still about 5 million too much) and also not played correctly! if you want a Lb buy a Lb, Juan Manual Vargas, Zhirkov or Lahm...



Rating: 6.5/10 due to the fact that you have overpaid alot and have not brought in the quality of players that you can!

Duckers, you have a good team there, Mangane must be getting on and you can do better than Rakitic in the centre as well as Gerrard being a ballie now, so you need a replacement there.. other than that...

Rating: 8.3/10 good mix of experience and youth and Munian is a classy player that will excel in that position


Sam, not a bad sqaud there, good strikers, good mids, not sure how you can afford all their wages though as most of them would ask for around 60-120k. But nonetheless, Khune is **** and you need to replace him, left back is also weak, look at replacing him!

Rating: 7.4/10 good team, some weak area's Cb included though
Click to expand...

Cheers, who shall I replace them with, btw my Dons team finished 2nd in the Prem, money's no object ;)

---------- Post added at 12:45 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:39 PM ----------

Btw Raikan, my Man U team


Areola
Rafael
Suswama
Smalling
Varane - Retrained/Soumaoro
Van Eelzen/Isco
Mutch
Kouyate
El Maestro/Ismail
Balishov/Morrison
Maletic/Piazon/Alcacer

My youth/reserve
 
look at keepers like:

Renan - Avai
Sergio Asenjo - Atletico
Fernando Muslera - Lazio
Maxym Koval - Dinamo Kiev
Carlos Kameni - Espanyol
Sergio Romero - Az
Fabian Assmann - Independiente
Laurentiu Branescu - Juventus
Pierrick Cros - St Ettiene
Alphonso Areola - PSG

Left back:

Georgiy Schennikov - CSKA
Lionel Carole - Benfica
Samuel Souprayen - Rennes
Diego Contento - Bayern
 
XD I was just thinking that when I posted, it's just people who want their squad rated and aren't here to rate. Thanks for that though, I'll take a look in to them players, but my CB's; Coelho and Juanpé are playing brilliantly, Coelho has won CB of the year twice and Juanpé is at a similar level to Coelho but said that he can be even better. Only been playing half a season and he's on 7.20 overall, can only get better as he fits in more.
 
Raikan007 said:
I thought this was the rate your squad thread, no one rates anything... let me start!

Duckers, you have a good team there, Mangane must be getting on and you can do better than Rakitic in the centre as well as Gerrard being a ballie now, so you need a replacement there.. other than that...

Rating: 8.3/10 good mix of experience and youth and Munian is a classy player that will excel in that position
Click to expand...

Cheers for the feedback. Mangane is getting on a bit and its probably going to be his last season as first choice. To be fair he is averaging above 7's still and is nearly always 95% fit. I have got a regen coming at the end of the season called La Torre who cost me £11 million from Schalke but he looks immense so I will probably be throwing him into the mix with Wilson next season. Also looking to make Martin Kelly a regular as Johnson isnt getting any younger.
Rakitic has actually been really good for me but he isnt in my first team. I totally forgot about Andrea Poli who i signed at the start of last season who plays instead of Rakitic & Gerrard is only a reserve. What do you think of the team taking out Rakitic and replacing with Poli?
Muniain is absolutely immense and is doing really well. I signed him a few years ago for £15 million with add ons and i am definitley seeing the best out of him this season. As i mentioned i have just got through the January transfer window and i was rejecting bids from Barcelona & Juventus of £35 million.
 
avfc-ncfc said:
Capable of challenging for top 4 if not where should i improve?
Click to expand...
not sure about top 4 mate, I would be more realistic and say top half finish! maximum 7th, decent team there Andre' looks like a great player! Toloi is a great player as well! you need to look at a new Keeper though! take a look at some of the players I have suggested above! or you can PM and say ask for suggestions...

Team rating: 7.3/10, good midfield and wingers, striking and keeping weaknesses

---------- Post added at 10:50 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:27 AM ----------
WannaB said:
View attachment 170666

I'm quite curious to your opinions regarding my squad.
Click to expand...
nice Ajax team there and a good formation :) different!

left wing back looks like it needs a little attention! Saadi is on fire for you! he is a great young player! if you like your formation with the DM you may want to look at a new DM to bring in and train up for cover to De Zeeuw! Love Renan, did you buy him from my recommendation?

take a look at someone like Ognjen Vukojevic - Dinamo Kiev or Vincent Pajot - Stade Rennais or Necip Uysal - Besiktas maybe?

you also need a new Cb as Kara is decent, look at Mario Fernandes - Gremio, Neuton - Gremio (Pm me for any suggestions you need for your squad, will gladly help)

Team rating: 8.3/10 good mixture of youth and experience, good players in most positions but need cover for the postions I mentioned above :)
 
Here's another Team for rating if you don't mind Raikan.

Can't post SS yet cos I'm not on my computer:

Everton:

Sergio Asenjo
Seamus Coleman
Phil Jagielka
Ezequiel Munoz
Regen
Marko Arnuatovic
Mikel Arteta/Jack Rodwell
Marco Verratti/James Rodriguez
James Rodriguez/Gareth Bale
Hulk
Di Santo/Regen

Subs:
Wayne Hennessey
Regen
Efraid Jurez (sp)
Junior Medina
Charlie Adam
Isco
Alcacer

5-6th season in, Champions League winners, Premiership Winners
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

FMBase

Beta

Resources

Back
Top