Ultimate Tactic Testing League

Tripoligate4 · May 16, 2016

FM14SERBIA said:
on the Bottom of the OP ....

TACTIC NAME AP YC RC CG CA PAS
PARAGON BALANCED V1 50% 149 3 17 5 70%
PARAGON ATTACK V1 59% 161 3 20 6 76%
PARAGON I.F. BALANCED V1 51% 152 2 19 7 72%
PARAGON I.F. ATTACK V1 59% 157 0 26 4 77%
FMSERBIA 4231 WINGERS , AF 56% 135 3 15 11 74%
SICILIAN DEFENSE V5 58% 166 2 40 15 76%
SICILIAN DEFENSE WINGERS V5 59% 136 2 36 6 76%
SPECTRE V1 DEFENSIVE 52% 167 2 22 7 71%
SPECTRE V2 ATTACK 54% 159 7 28 9 72%
WORLD WAR 2 54% 140 1 23 8 74%
DATE 4-4-2 52% 195 2 32 5 73%
PARIS V2 57% 96 0 42 10 74%
FERENC PUSKAS V4 57% 170 4 28 12 76%
KINGDOM V2 54% 182 1 36 4 73%
DAZED AND CONFUSED 54% 141 0 30 10 75%

ty

Amsattack · May 16, 2016

Can you test Midsomer by Knap please

FM14SERBIA · May 16, 2016

Amsattack said:
Can you test Midsomer by Knap please

Now i am testing it

hehe

FM14SERBIA · May 16, 2016

FINISHED TESTING MIDSOMER 442 . NO Opposition Instructions , because Knap said tactic is better without OI-s ...

OVERALL TABLE

6.

MIDSOMER ( NO OI )

4-4-2

KNAP

90

50

12

28

200

132

68

162

HOME TABLE

4.

MIDSOMER ( NO OI )

4-4-2

KNAP

45

31

6

8

129

59

70

99

AWAY TABLE

9.

MIDSOMER ( NO OI )

4-4-2

KNAP

45

19

6

20

71

73

-2

63

Deleted member 91052 · May 16, 2016

I am finding with 442s, that No OIs work marginally better short term, but over the longer 90 game test they are marginally better with OIs.

Did you notice any performance drop over the last 45 games?

FM14SERBIA · May 16, 2016

Knap said:
I am finding with 442s, that No OIs work marginally better short term, but over the longer 90 game test they are marginally better with OIs.

Did you notice any performance drop over the last 45 games?

View attachment 151562 View attachment 151561 View attachment 151560 View attachment 151559 View attachment 151558

Overall Table

View attachment 151557

FM14SERBIA · May 16, 2016

FINISHED TESTING PARAGON BALANCED V3 . Anyone knows why TFF Tactics perform so badly in my testing ??? TFF is my favourite tactic creator and i dont know why his tactic is almost last in my testing ...

OVERALL TABLE

14.

PARAGON BALANCED V3

4-1-4-1

TOTALFOOTBALLFAN9

90

41

24

25

136

93

43

147

HOME TABLE

15.

PARAGON BALANCED V3

4-1-4-1

TOTALFOOTBALLFAN9

45

25

11

9

77

35

42

86

AWAY TABLE

10.

PARAGON BALANCED V3

4-1-4-1

TOTALFOOTBALLFAN9

45

16

13

16

59

58

1

61

FM14SERBIA · May 16, 2016

FINISHED TESTING PARAGON INSIDE FORWARD BALANCED V3 . I DONT KNOW WHAT IS THE PROBLEM WITH TFF TACTICS ...

OVERALL TABLE

16.

PARAGON I.F. BALANCED V3

4-3-3

TOTALFOOTBALLFAN9

90

40

22

28

132

102

30

142

HOME TABLE

12.

PARAGON I.F. BALANCED V3

4-3-3

TOTALFOOTBALLFAN9

45

28

8

9

74

35

39

92

AWAY TABLE

17.

PARAGON I.F. BALANCED V3

4-3-3

TOTALFOOTBALLFAN9

45

12

14

19

58

67

-9

50

Wigo15 · May 16, 2016

Ooohhh ive been waiting you to testparagon on your test all day and i cant believe what i see!!! Ive overachieved massively with v3 balance... have no idea whats wrong :/ maybe try retested and use instant result version maybe thats the case

FM14SERBIA · May 16, 2016

Wigo15 said:
Ooohhh ive been waiting you to testparagon on your test all day and i cant believe what i see!!! Ive overachieved massively with v3 balance... have no idea whats wrong :/ maybe try retested and use instant result version maybe thats the case

Not not ... my assistant manager dont change role for wide midfielders , because all my players have 16 attributes for all technical , mental and physical ... so my players is very good for wide midfielders formation.... Date 4-4-2 and Sicilian Defense also have wide midfielders ...

FM14SERBIA · May 16, 2016

Wigo15 said:
Ooohhh ive been waiting you to testparagon on your test all day and i cant believe what i see!!! Ive overachieved massively with v3 balance... have no idea whats wrong :/ maybe try retested and use instant result version maybe thats the case

Ehh i will try it with Instant Results version ...

Medmax · May 16, 2016

FM14SERBIA said:
Guys ... I hesitated a little bit of testing ... I dont know why TFF Tactics perform badly in my testing ... Anyone have any ideas ???

Edit - I will try to test TFF PARAGON BALANCED V3 INSTANT RESULT VERSION ...

I can't say for sure, and I have no facts backing up my opinion, but 7 out of the 7 leading tactics in your test have wide midfielders, playing and STAYING wide, or tweaked to play like wingers (left foot on left...), not like inside forwards cutting inside (right foot on left...)...

I tried to explain what we can see in the ME FOR THIS FM16 in this post: http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/share-download-fm-16-tactics/357895-annihilator-65.html#post2987999

and in this one: http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/share-download-fm-16-tactics/357895-annihilator-66.html#post2988078

Again, just my opinion

FM14SERBIA · May 16, 2016

Medmax said:
I can't say for sure, and I have no facts backing up my opinion, but 7 out of the 7 leading tactics in your test have wide midfielders, playing and STAYING wide, or tweaked to play like wingers (left foot on left...), not like inside forwards cutting inside (right foot on left...)...

I tried to explain what we can see in the ME FOR THIS FM16 in this post: http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/share-download-fm-16-tactics/357895-annihilator-65.html#post2987999

and in this one: http://www.fm-base.co.uk/forum/share-download-fm-16-tactics/357895-annihilator-66.html#post2988078

Again, just my opinion

Aham. So do you think problem is that in TFF tactics wide midfielders have Cut Inside instructions and they play like an Inside Forwards not as Wingers ...

Medmax · May 16, 2016

FM14SERBIA said:
Aham. So do you think problem is that in TFF tactics wide midfielders have Cut Inside instructions and they play like an Inside Forwards not as Wingers ...

In all honesty I didn't try his last one, Paragon, so I'm not be the best person to give any feedback about it. The crosses rely almost exclusively with the 2 fullbacks in his tactic, while pretty much all the others rely on the 2 fullbacks + the 2 wide midfielders/wingers.

Anyway, look at yours and all the tactic testing threads: I think it's really hard to keep consistency and keep long winning streak with plug and play in this FM... You really have to adapt with what you see in game.

FM14SERBIA · May 19, 2016

Guys ... this is my finale update 100% this is my best tactic database this year , no chance to create better database ...

So here are the results with my new database ... tomorrow i will continue testing ...

Sicilian Defense in all my tests is always 1st place , so in my opinion this is the best tactic this year at the moment ... TFF Tactic at Home almost same performance as Sicilian Defense , but in Away games Sicilian Defense is more better ...

OVERALL TABLE

R	TACTIC NAME	CREATOR NAME	M	W	D	L	GS	GA	GD	P
1.	SICILIAN DEFENSE V5	MR LANGVATN	90	56	18	16	199	103	96	186
2.	PARAGON BALANCED V4	TOTALFOOTBALLFAN9	90	44	23	23	154	93	61	155

HOME TABLE

R	TACTIC NAME	CREATOR NAME	M	W	D	L	GS	GA	GD	P
1.	SICILIAN DEFENSE V5	MR LANGVATN	45	35	6	4	116	35	81	111
2.	PARAGON BALANCED V4	TOTALFOOTBALLFAN9	45	32	10	3	93	26	67	106

AWAY TABLE

R	TACTIC NAME	CREATOR NAME	M	W	D	L	GS	GA	GD	P
1.	SICILIAN DEFENSE V5	MR LANGVATN	45	21	12	12	83	68	15	75
2.	PARAGON BALANCED V4	TOTALFOOTBALLFAN9	45	12	13	20	61	67	-6	49

FM14SERBIA · May 19, 2016

SICILIAN DEFENSE V5 RANKING TABLE PICTURES

View attachment 150840 View attachment 150839 View attachment 150838

FM14SERBIA · May 19, 2016

PARAGON BALANCED V4 RANKING TABLE PICTURES

View attachment 150837 View attachment 150836 View attachment 150835

FM14SERBIA · May 20, 2016

FINISHED TESTING FMSERBIA 4-2-3-1 WINGERS AND ADVANCED FORWARD

OVERALL TABLE

R	TACTIC NAME	CREATOR NAME	M	W	D	L	GS	GA	GD	P
1.	SICILIAN DEFENSE V5	MR LANGVATN	90	56	18	16	199	103	96	186
2.	PARAGON BALANCED V4	TOTALFOOTBALLFAN9	90	44	23	23	154	93	61	155
3.	FM SERBIA 4-2-3-1 WINGERS	FM14SERBIA	90	43	13	34	186	146	40	142

HOME TABLE

R	TACTIC NAME	CREATOR NAME	M	W	D	L	GS	GA	GD	P
1.	SICILIAN DEFENSE V5	MR LANGVATN	45	35	6	4	116	35	81	111
2.	FMSERBIA 4-2-3-1 WINGERS	FM14SERBIA	45	35	5	5	119	44	75	110
3.	PARAGON BALANCED V4	TOTALFOOTBALLFAN9	45	32	10	3	93	26	67	106

AWAY TABLE

R	TACTIC NAME	CREATOR NAME	M	W	D	L	GS	GA	GD	P
1.	SICILIAN DEFENSE V5	MR LANGVATN	45	21	12	12	83	68	15	75
2.	PARAGON BALANCED V4	TOTALFOOTBALLFAN9	45	12	13	20	61	67	-6	49
3.	FMSERBIA 4-2-3-1 WINGERS	FM14SERBIA	45	8	8	29	67	102	-35	32

grokk · May 20, 2016

Hi
can u upload plz u DB?

FM14SERBIA · May 20, 2016

Ranking Table after 5 tactics ...

OVERALL TABLE

R	TACTIC NAME	CREATOR NAME	M	W	D	L	GS	GA	GD	P
1.	SICILIAN DEFENSE V5	MR LANGVATN	90	56	18	16	199	103	96	186
2.	KINGDOM V2	ZYNDAR AND C.E.	90	53	19	18	194	100	94	178
3.	PARAGON BALANCED V4	TOTALFOOTBALLFAN9	90	44	23	23	154	93	61	155
4.	BLUTHS 16.3 TWEAK	GOBBLUTHJD	90	42	21	27	158	125	33	147
5.	FM SERBIA 4-2-3-1 WINGERS	FM14SERBIA	90	43	13	34	186	146	40	142

HOME TABLE

R	TACTIC NAME	CREATOR NAME	M	W	D	L	GS	GA	GD	P
1.	KINGDOM V2	ZYNDAR AND C.E.	45	36	7	2	127	33	94	115
2.	SICILIAN DEFENSE V5	MR LANGVATN	45	35	6	4	116	35	81	111
3.	FMSERBIA 4-2-3-1 WINGERS	FM14SERBIA	45	35	5	5	119	44	75	110
4.	PARAGON BALANCED V4	TOTALFOOTBALLFAN9	45	32	10	3	93	26	67	106
5.	BLUTHS 16.3 TWEAK	GOBBLUTHJD	45	28	9	8	93	47	46	93

AWAY TABLE

R	TACTIC NAME	CREATOR NAME	M	W	D	L	GS	GA	GD	P
1.	SICILIAN DEFENSE V5	MR LANGVATN	45	21	12	12	83	68	15	75
2.	KINGDOM V2	ZYNDAR AND C.E.	45	17	12	16	67	67	0	63
3.	BLUTHS 16.3 TWEAK	GOBBLUTHJD	45	14	12	19	65	78	-13	54
4.	PARAGON BALANCED V4	TOTALFOOTBALLFAN9	45	12	13	20	61	67	-6	49
5.	FMSERBIA 4-2-3-1 WINGERS	FM14SERBIA	45	8	8	29	67	102	-35	32

SOME STATS ABOUT TACTICS

RD - RED CARD
YC - YELLOW CARD
CG - CORNER GOALS
CA - CORNER AGAINST

TACTIC NAME	RC	YC	CG	CA
SICILIAN DEFENSE V5	3	256	30	5
PARAGON BALANCED V4	3	282	16	4
FMSERBIA 4-2-3-1 WINGERS	8	253	22	6
KINGDOM V2	7	233	41	4
BLUTHS 16.3 TWEAK	5	240	28	4

TACTIC NAME	AP	YC	RC	CG	CA	PAS
PARAGON BALANCED V1	50%	149	3	17	5	70%
PARAGON ATTACK V1	59%	161	3	20	6	76%
PARAGON I.F. BALANCED V1	51%	152	2	19	7	72%
PARAGON I.F. ATTACK V1	59%	157	0	26	4	77%
FMSERBIA 4231 WINGERS , AF	56%	135	3	15	11	74%
SICILIAN DEFENSE V5	58%	166	2	40	15	76%
SICILIAN DEFENSE WINGERS V5	59%	136	2	36	6	76%
SPECTRE V1 DEFENSIVE	52%	167	2	22	7	71%
SPECTRE V2 ATTACK	54%	159	7	28	9	72%
WORLD WAR 2	54%	140	1	23	8	74%
DATE 4-4-2	52%	195	2	32	5	73%
PARIS V2	57%	96	0	42	10	74%
FERENC PUSKAS V4	57%	170	4	28	12	76%
KINGDOM V2	54%	182	1	36	4	73%
DAZED AND CONFUSED	54%	141	0	30	10	75%

Ultimate Tactic Testing League

Member

Member

Member

Member

Deleted member 91052

Guest

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

Member

FMBase

Beta

Resources