I think maybe seeing the match in too much detail (i.e. in 3D) can cause you to notice things that aren't there and attempt to "fix what ain't broke" per se. Viewing the match in 2D allows you to view the bigger picture and respond to major changes in the game. However it is certainly the case that you miss something small but not so insignificant. I've had my successes and failures through both methods. For example I've just tried a 2D game again for the first time in my current season (2nd season in save, 1st season for Forest in the EPL) and managed a magnificent 4-2 win over Man City, scoring three goals in the last 10 minutes. Swings and roundabouts etc etc.