I had a few
minor problems with this tactic when I started using it, like others have described; I'd put a couple of decent results together (considering the squad I had) and then inexplicably lose 0-1 to Villa or something. Considering my team however, (I'm playing with Swansea), I was doing better than I had any right to.
First season: 10th place finish.
Second season: 7th place finish (got me in to Europe)
Third season: 3rd place finish (won the Capital One Cup and the F.A. Cup which got me in the Champions League).
Current season: It's February and I'm sitting in first place undefeated. I haven't lost since the pre-season which means I am still in every competition (including the Champions League).
Fixtures
View attachment 345597
Table
View attachment 345598
I think the reason for the increases in performance is the emergence of my youth prospects. I've bought a few first-teamers over the years but never any big names; mostly people of reasonable ability for little money. This season though a few of last season's loaned players have broken in to the first team and I think that's the reason last year's stale games are being won this time around.
I also treated pre-season differently this time. I read
an article saying that your
General Training actually has no bearing on match performance or anything like this. All it does (unless you set it to
Team Cohesion) is give a priority to a certain set of stats in training. So setting it to
Tactics for instance will cause the Anticipation, Composure, Concentration, Decisions and Teamwork stats of your players to increase more than they otherwise would. Therefore it has nothing at all to do with learning formations or playing well. Thus in pre-season I stick it on
Team Cohesion and set it to very high intensity until my team-talk feedback reports say "the players would die for each other.
Match Training on the other hand goes on
Tactics Only (obviously) until the tactic is 100% fluid. To expedite this I change the scheduling so that
Match Training takes up 50% of the training (i.e. the slider is all the way to the left). This gets the tactic learned as fast as possible. Once this has been achieved I stick it on
Attacking Movement and take the slider down to three notches (20%).
I suspect that it's a combination of this pre-season routine plus my new youth options which has seen the remarkable jump in quality. It certainly isn't big name signings (I don't have any).