AllanT, here's different point of view
For example, after 35 min of the first half your team hasn't created a single chance and opposition has created 1-2 chances. You are unhappy and start tweaking but you don't know if you keep using this tactic without tweaks then rest of the match your team would create 10 CCC and opposition zero chances but you tweaked it and made it worse and your team didn’t create a single chances after your tweaks.
In other words, you never know when your team will have chances it could at any point of the match.
Good example is my game against Swansea. I was down by 3 goals after 1st half(conceded 2 goals from stupid corner) and my team hadn't created a single chance in 1st half but I didn't panicked and only switches for Overload version because I knew how strong is this tactic and what it capable of and I was right in 2nd half I created 7 CCC and won 3-4 but what would happened if I started tweaked it?
I think you've missed my point here or maybe i didn't get it across properly. I don't tweak the base tactic, it works fine as it is. I'll give an example of what i mean.
I'm playing against a very strong team and im sitting with a very deep D-Line and they are having numerous chances against me. So i decide to change something. For the purpose of my example, lets say that i decide to swap to "push Higher up" and put my fastest CD as Covering. There's a few potential outcomes.
1 - They score
2 - I score
3 - No notable action that is shown (depending on your highlights set up)
4 - One team starts dominating and having chances and missing with shots
5 - One team starts dominating and having chances and keeper saves or defenders tackle/clear
6 - One team starts dominating and hitting woodwork, goals disallowed or cleared off the line
7 - No notable action but players from one team get either booked or injured
If i get option 1, then i know then i need to change the teams mentality slightly. If its on control, then a swap to Attacking or Standard will normally sort it out. The AI generally wont score a goal then swap to "park the bus" unless there is not much time remaining.
If i get 3 or 7 then i revert back to how it was and change something else.
If i get 4, 5 or 6 then i know that something minor needs changing like swapping "Be more expressive" to "Be more Disciplined" for example.
If i score then 90% of the time, all that needs changing is one thing. 75% of the time, its a mentality change, but not always. Usually a quick swap from control to Attacking, or to Standard means you'll score again a few minutes later. The other times it usually revolves around the tempo of your play ie changing from Much lower, to Lower or Lower to Higher for example. It just depends on the team you are playing against.
Naturally if i swap something and its not working, i go back to how it was set before and look at something else.
Here's a few pics to show you how effective my tinkering has been. As i say though, i do not change anything permanently. It works great as it is. I just slightly adjust things mid game to compensate for mid match AI changes, then start all over again in the next match.
View attachment 334810View attachment 334809
Notice the time difference between the goals scored. You'll see a burst of goals in a short space of time, then nothing for 10-15 mins. This is when they have countered my tactics and once i've found the correct bit of the tactic to amend, and then there's another burst of goals.
This has the potential to work on every single game you play as remember but odds on it wont, this is just a computer program and once you press the right button, you'll beat it. Simple as that. Naturally better AI managers can sometimes alternate their tactical approach more than the lesser AI managers so i'm not saying you can get 11-0 or 8-0 wins every week. All i'm saying, is like any computer program, there's a way to hack it as long as your team is decent.
Here's my results this season so far, including the 36 game unbeaten run in all competitions, that im on at the moment.
View attachment 334808View attachment 334807
Edit: not sure why my sucker punch pic is at the bottom for lol :<