Fm14 Deal or No Deal thread: Please use when asking if you should buy player x or y
- Thread starter Raikan007
- Start date
- Replies 717
- Views 357K
nufcmichael
Member
- Joined
- Dec 1, 2009
- Messages
- 77
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 6
Player: Riccardo Rosati
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are selling: PSG
Offer: ?19,5m
Year: 2026/2027
View attachment 443364
Team you are managing: Newcastle
Team who are selling: PSG
Offer: ?19,5m
Year: 2026/2027
View attachment 443364
Last edited:
I'd still say no deal. He's one of the best RB ingame. But if you're bent upon selling him, Phil Jones is phenomenal at RB. You may look into getting Danilo or de Sciglio also.
Deal or No Deal guys
Player: Asier Illarramendi
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are buying/selling: Real Madrid
Offer: 8.25 Mil
Year: 2015/16
I was hoping to sign vidal but he doesn't want to come here. I need someone Schweinsteiger-esque for my Jupp Heyneckes bayern Tactic. The price is a steal, but i have no idea how good Asier is in the game. Deal or no Deal guys?
Here is a screenshot View attachment 443245
Player: Asier Illarramendi
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are buying/selling: Real Madrid
Offer: 8.25 Mil
Year: 2015/16
I was hoping to sign vidal but he doesn't want to come here. I need someone Schweinsteiger-esque for my Jupp Heyneckes bayern Tactic. The price is a steal, but i have no idea how good Asier is in the game. Deal or no Deal guys?
Here is a screenshot View attachment 443245
Player: Lucas Romero
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are buying/selling: PSG
Offer: 41.5M
Year: 2015/16
He's been bossing my midfield for two seasons, Even took Gerrard out of my team for most of the first season.
Unfortunately, Silly me, I underestimated how good he would get and only put a 43M release clause in his contract, Fortunately for some odd reason, PSG won't up their bid to meet that release clause.
Do I sell for 41.5M or offer him a new contract with a higher/no release clause?
Keep in mind I have Jordan Rossiter coming up through the ranks.
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are buying/selling: PSG
Offer: 41.5M
Year: 2015/16
He's been bossing my midfield for two seasons, Even took Gerrard out of my team for most of the first season.
Unfortunately, Silly me, I underestimated how good he would get and only put a 43M release clause in his contract, Fortunately for some odd reason, PSG won't up their bid to meet that release clause.
Do I sell for 41.5M or offer him a new contract with a higher/no release clause?
Keep in mind I have Jordan Rossiter coming up through the ranks.
im tottenham second season, as strikers i have soldado and mitrovic, whom i just bought. i can buy sergio aguero for 44 mil and 200.000 per week, should i buy or pass? i wouldnt think about it and just buy if i didnt have mitrovic and soldado and play lone striker up front. soldado was ok last season not great.
wowpantslol
Member
- Joined
- Dec 13, 2013
- Messages
- 14
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 0
wowpantslol
Member
- Joined
- Dec 13, 2013
- Messages
- 14
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 0
View attachment 442755
that's rafael in 2016, also an excellent replacement is Corchia who is incredibly cheap in 2014
View attachment 442754
scout again to see how much wages he wants. no deal if its above 90k/week.
keep him for a season or 2 and offer him a new contract as well to get rid of the clause. you could sell for much more later.Player: Lucas Romero
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are buying/selling: PSG
Offer: 41.5M
Year: 2015/16
He's been bossing my midfield for two seasons, Even took Gerrard out of my team for most of the first season.
Unfortunately, Silly me, I underestimated how good he would get and only put a 43M release clause in his contract, Fortunately for some odd reason, PSG won't up their bid to meet that release clause.
Do I sell for 41.5M or offer him a new contract with a higher/no release clause?
Keep in mind I have Jordan Rossiter coming up through the ranks.
200k/week is a lot. no deal.
i wont sell for less than 50m. no deal.
no deal.
Player: Alex Sandro
Team you are managing: Southampton
Team who are buying/selling: FCP
Offer: 11 Million pounds (Wage 76k p/w)
Year: 2nd season (January transfer window).
I have Danny Fox who is 28, and has 6 months remaining on his contract. FCP are ok with selling Alex Sandro, as he is refusing to sign a contract with them. Should I take it, or continue with Danny Fox?
Team you are managing: Southampton
Team who are buying/selling: FCP
Offer: 11 Million pounds (Wage 76k p/w)
Year: 2nd season (January transfer window).
I have Danny Fox who is 28, and has 6 months remaining on his contract. FCP are ok with selling Alex Sandro, as he is refusing to sign a contract with them. Should I take it, or continue with Danny Fox?
Player: Asier Illarramendi
Team you are managing: Southampton
Team who are selling: Real Madrid
Offer: 8.72 Million pounds (Wage 89k p/w)
Year: 2nd season (January transfer window).
A DM is a main-stay in my tactics, especially for difficult away games. Illarramendi hasn't been used much at Madrid, and hence transfer listed and available for the knockdown price. I already have Jonathon dos Santos and Mohammed Sissoko. Should I bother going for the deal? His wages seem a tad too high for my liking, but I dunno how good he gets.
Team you are managing: Southampton
Team who are selling: Real Madrid
Offer: 8.72 Million pounds (Wage 89k p/w)
Year: 2nd season (January transfer window).
A DM is a main-stay in my tactics, especially for difficult away games. Illarramendi hasn't been used much at Madrid, and hence transfer listed and available for the knockdown price. I already have Jonathon dos Santos and Mohammed Sissoko. Should I bother going for the deal? His wages seem a tad too high for my liking, but I dunno how good he gets.
Player: Danilo/Martin Montoya
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are selling: Porto/Barca
Offer: ?18m/?3.8m
Player's Value: ?12m/?5m
Year: Summer 15/16
I sold Johnson first season and bought De Sciglio for the long-term, with Kelly and Reveillere as cover but as the latter is now retiring and I'm not totally won over by De Sciglio I'm looking for serious competion or an upgrade. Clearly Montoya is the better value deal but I was wondering if you guys felt that Danilo is worth the premium. With CL this season and hopefully an attempt at the Prem crown I was looking for some thoughts. I shouldn't really need the LB cover Montoya provides so that can be largely dismissed.
Team you are managing: Liverpool
Team who are selling: Porto/Barca
Offer: ?18m/?3.8m
Player's Value: ?12m/?5m
Year: Summer 15/16
I sold Johnson first season and bought De Sciglio for the long-term, with Kelly and Reveillere as cover but as the latter is now retiring and I'm not totally won over by De Sciglio I'm looking for serious competion or an upgrade. Clearly Montoya is the better value deal but I was wondering if you guys felt that Danilo is worth the premium. With CL this season and hopefully an attempt at the Prem crown I was looking for some thoughts. I shouldn't really need the LB cover Montoya provides so that can be largely dismissed.
Montoya didnt do justice for my arsenal, Danilo is a beast for me
no deal. go after lucas/gaston gil romero or marco verratti instead.
slicecheese
Member
- Joined
- Aug 7, 2010
- Messages
- 123
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 0
Player: Alejandro Pozuelo
Team you are managing: Swansea
Team who are buying: Manchester United
Offer: 32m Pounds
Year: 2017/2018
His the top scorer for the premier league and european golden shoe last season. But should i sell him? The offer is tempting.
Team you are managing: Swansea
Team who are buying: Manchester United
Offer: 32m Pounds
Year: 2017/2018
His the top scorer for the premier league and european golden shoe last season. But should i sell him? The offer is tempting.
Scotty98TR
Member
- Joined
- Jul 13, 2012
- Messages
- 3,472
- Reaction score
- 1
- Points
- 0
No deal. Quality players - especially strikers - are really hard to buy on this FM, and even when you do manage to buy them, its for a ridiculous amount. I can't see you being able to get anyone anywhere near as good for the money, so I wouldnt.
Player: Oxlade Chamberlain
Team you are managing: Arsenal
Team who are buying: PSG
Offer: 48m (or i could bundle szcehny and little money for cavani, i have ter stegen and lewandowski is terrible this year, despite having such great season last year)
Player's Value: 30m
Year: Summer 15/16
I have Bernard (who I'd rather sell than Oxlade), Lamela, Griezmann. All of my wingers are the game changers in my current year (last year was lewandowski's)..
Team you are managing: Arsenal
Team who are buying: PSG
Offer: 48m (or i could bundle szcehny and little money for cavani, i have ter stegen and lewandowski is terrible this year, despite having such great season last year)
Player's Value: 30m
Year: Summer 15/16
I have Bernard (who I'd rather sell than Oxlade), Lamela, Griezmann. All of my wingers are the game changers in my current year (last year was lewandowski's)..
Scotty98TR
Member
- Joined
- Jul 13, 2012
- Messages
- 3,472
- Reaction score
- 1
- Points
- 0
Player: Gwendal Le Bras - Regen - See screenshot
Team you are managing: Arsenal
Team who are Selling: Real Madrid
Offer: ?43m (Release Clause
Year: Summer 16/17
Other: This kid looks like he'll become amazing. But he isn't fantastic yet, and has yet to play a senior match. After selling alot of players, I have ?60m to spend, and ?200k a week spare, but I can't find anyone to spend it on. So should I blow it all on this 17 year old?
Screenshot: View attachment 441418
Team you are managing: Arsenal
Team who are Selling: Real Madrid
Offer: ?43m (Release Clause
Year: Summer 16/17
Other: This kid looks like he'll become amazing. But he isn't fantastic yet, and has yet to play a senior match. After selling alot of players, I have ?60m to spend, and ?200k a week spare, but I can't find anyone to spend it on. So should I blow it all on this 17 year old?
Screenshot: View attachment 441418
Do you have good replacements lined up for him? Oxlade is amongst the best players on the Right, and as such I'd say No Deal. But if you've good regens lined up to take over from him, go ahead..